Slashdot Mirror
Amazon Cuts Off North Carolina Affiliates
Amazon.com has reportedly cut off all affiliates in North Carolina as a preemptive response to the sales tax change being pushed through the state legislature. The Seattle-based online retailer warned affiliates last week that such a move might be necessary, but the early shutoff seems to be a move in hopes of swaying opinion on the proposed legislation. "Local affiliates say they were 'blind-sided' by the company's action. 'I got this e-mail at 4:30 this morning,' said James Barrett, a technology consultant from Winston-Salem. 'It wasn't saying your account will be shut down. It said it is shut down. That just blew me up right there.' Barrett said that he is frustrated at lawmakers for considering the tax, but equally aggravated with Amazon. 'They're trying to tick off all their associates and get them to call down to Raleigh,' Barrett said. 'I think that is pretty tacky. That's not the way to use people who are referring business to your business.'"
I agree. This is admirable response by Amazon. Even legal thievery has its limits. NC is laying claims beyond their jurisdiction in my opinion.
"Threatening" government with pulling out is often weak and empty and used far too often. Eventually, with all the posturing that goes on, someone has to make a move that is exact and meaningful. Amazon made a move rather than attempt to actually "play" politics through threats and posturing. So I have to disagree. Amazon is not playing politics. Surely they have taken into account that they would alienate some people in N.C. but they have to prove they are serious.
Amazon isn't sending lobbyists with bags of cash. Amazon isn't asking sellers to plea to the government. Doing so would, in fact, be playing politics. By making a decisive and definitive action, they are make their statement in the only clean and honest way possible. Begging and threatening politicians is only playing their game. To withdraw is the only way... unless you can think of another?
Undoing a law after it has passed is a good deal harder than preventing it from passing. The DMCA seems to be sticking around regardless of how frequently it is abused and how much it harms the people. It's a bad and unpopular law that could only have been passed in the way it was (subversively) and it's not going away. Amazon is speaking not only to N.C., but to every state of the union. Taxing the internet is a very bad idea just as a state seizing a domain name because the operators who do not operate in the same state is violating that state's law is a bad idea. States should never exceed their borders and yet attempt to do so at every opportunity.