Slashdot Mirror
Expanding the Electricity Grid May Be a Mistake
Perhaps T. Boone Pickens was onto something. Al writes "An article in Technology Review argues that plans to string new high-voltage lines across the US to bring wind power from the midsection of the country to the coasts, could be an expensive mistake. What's needed instead are improved local and regional electricity transmission, the development of an efficient and adaptable smart grid, and the demonstration of technology such as carbon capture and sequestration, which could prove a cheaper way to reduce carbon dioxide emissions than transmitting power from North Dakota to New York City."
Blah blah blah.
It obviously has nothing to do with the 15-30 year window before you reach 1:1 parity with energy invested::energy harvested.
Or with the cost of DC transmission.
Or with the potential impact on the weather.
You're right, it has to be Big %insert something you hate here%.
BTW--whatever happened to people complaining about Big GOVERNMENT, hmm? Nobody's complaining about Obama throwing around $800B, spending 20% of it, then claiming it was successful. Or Tim Geithner being willing to continue throwing money at banks for new derivatives that are being issued today.
There are much bigger things to worry about at the moment than "Big Coal".
The whole smart grid idea gives me the willies. First, it will be used an excuse to block the building of generating capacity of any type. All electric generators have an environmental downside. The existence of a "smart" grid will be another excuse to not boost generating capacity. If the wind mills don't produce electricity, so what? we will just turn off your computer. Problem solved.
Second, the smart grid is a new avenue for government intrusion into our lives. Members of "minority" groups will claim that any action to cut power to their neighborhoods is racism. Power cuts to the districts of Nancy Pelosi, John Murtha and Barney Frank will be rarer than hen's teeth. Don't bother to buy a new refrigerator if you live in John Boehner's district.
Non-union factories won't get electricity, but Government Motors and Fiatsler will have all they need. But wait, there is more. Too fat? No electricity for your kitchen. Want to stay up late. Sorry, lights are out at 10 p.m. in this town.
In the land of the blind, the one-eyed man is king.
You're absolutely right, and that's why we need either nuclear power or a large power transmission grid to lower CO2 emissions.
Wrong. Two billion people in the world don't have electricity. Carbon-based sources produce the most, and cheapest energy. Carbon-based sources are responsible for the doubling of human life expectancy.
It's time to forget about environmental propaganda and start being concerned with the lives of individuals who need abundant, cheap energy to survive, and to thrive.
Mine is Good