Slashdot Mirror
Judge Rules To Reveal Anonymous Blogger's Identity Over Insults
Several readers have written to tell us of a ruling in the New York Supreme Court which will allow model Liskula Cohen to find out the identity of an anonymous blogger who posted some of her photos with captions including the words "psychotic," "skank," and "ho." The site was part of Blogger.com, and Google has already complied with a request for the author's IP address and email. "[Cohen's attorney] said that once his legal team tracks the e-mail address to a name, the next step will be to sue Cohen's detractor for defamation. He said he suspected the creator of the blog is an acquaintance of Cohen. The blog has not been operational for months. The unidentified creator of the blog was represented in court by an attorney, Anne Salisbury, who said her client voluntarily took the blog down when Cohen initiated legal action against it. ... the judge quoted a Virginia court that ruled in a similar case that nameless online taunters should be held accountable when their derision crosses a line. 'The protection of the right to communicate anonymously must be balanced against the need to assure that those persons who choose to abuse the opportunities presented by this medium can be made to answer for such transgressions.'"
You're an idiot.
Nobody is arguing that one has an absolute right to privacy if they are making libelous claims, but nobody has the right to call you into account for stating opinions. There's no law against stating opinion and therefore no violation that qualifies for release of someone's private information.
If the guy was posting someone's social security number online or claiming that the person molested them or committed some horrible act, they would have a point. But there is no legal recourse for being called a skank.
It's interesting, by using the legal system to try to destroy this blogger for juvenile insults, the model actually proved she's a psychotic skank ho.
Isn't that funny? The psychotic skank ho only had grounds to sue until she actually sued.
Poor psychotic skank ho. I feel sorry for her psychotic skank ho ass.
It's been a long time.