Slashdot Mirror
Harald Welte Calls Out Netgear's Open Source Sham
Simon80 writes "Harald Welte, known for his involvement in various open source communities, has pointed out the shortcomings of Netgear's open source router hype. Netgear's own astroturfed community site reveals that the router requires the use of binary-only kernel modules for the wireless and ethernet hardware, which is supplied by Broadcom. Also worth noting are the missing features in third-party firmware versions supplied by Netgear."
One of the open firmware shortcomings is "WPA and WPA2 are not working." That is a pretty big shortcoming.
This post climbed Mt. Washington.
*looks at his brand New Atheros 9k powered wifi card which requires no firmware.*
Yes, I have no plans to utilize any cards requiring a blob again. The bar has been raised.
Comment removed based on user account deletion
In all fairness, Harald's original blog post isn't that rude to them; the Slashdot summary, I believe, is condescending and wrong.
However, I and many other folks are not as concerned about binary modules as Harald is. I view a binary module as a good first step - once a company gets comfortable with part of the code being open source, they'll gradually be receptive to open sourcing other modules. In many cases, yes, this takes a long time; and in some cases it causes companies to get scared and backtrack on open source commitments.
But still I view open source with some binaries as better than no commitments. I encourage people who view themselves as open source advocates to maintain a professional and respectful attitude towards companies who haven't opened up completely.