Technical Objections To the Ogg Container Format

E1ven writes "The Ogg container format is being promoted by the Xiph Foundation for use with its Vorbis and Theora codecs. Unfortunately, a number of technical shortcomings in the format render it ill-suited to most, if not all, use cases. This article examines the most severe of these flaws."

Comments

Re:Just complaining

[jbezorg]

My contention is this:

If he lied about the details of the Ogg format, then his conclusions are invalid (ex falso quodlibet).

The point you make here is obvious but from an apparent position of authority you emphasized this and bring it to my attention. From that, I inferred that you may have some doubts about the details presented.

I have not verified the format does what he says it does

In actuality, you don't know and haven't bothered.

Sincerely, Thanks for providing the logic analysis but I think it would be foolish of me to draw a conclusion from only half the answer.