Slashdot Mirror
In Ukraine, IT Freelancing Under Threat
An anonymous reader writes "According to the new tax law (Google translation; Russian original) that is being developed now and should take effect on January 1, 2011, it will not be possible for a private Ukrainian entrepreneur to provide any services to foreign companies without becoming a full-fledged company with a dedicated bookkeeper. Currently it is possible to perform such services and pay the equivalent of $25 in tax. Instead of raising the tax (which is overall welcomed by the community), the legislators plan to outlaw ISP, e-commerce, and Internet-based services — along with any services provided to foreign entities — for individual entrepreneurs. So starting in 2011, freelancers in Ukraine will have several choices: stop doing freelance work, start working illegally, become a full-fledged company subject to multiple cumbersome rules for taxation, or leave the country."
They will work illegally. No big deal. That's what any intelligent citizen of any country does when their lawmaking weasels start cranking stupid laws like that.
Also as a Ukrainian (at least, Ukrainian born), I'm proud of the choice most would choose when faced with an oppressive, corrupt government.
Well, he got elected fair and square after 6 years of rule by the pro-Western faction, so I guess people hated them more...
The deal is the widespread tax evasion in Ukraine. Not widespread as "German federal states are buying the Swiss bank account CD and expect a rise of self reports" but as in "Taxes? Somebody actually pays taxes in this country?"
"It's such a fine line between stupid and clever" -- David St. Hubbins, Spinal Tap
Oh yes, the Reagan theory of economy. I wonder how many more countries will go bankrupt before they realize that it doesn't work, and that they are not an exception?
But hey, the financial elite of those countries can get themselves a bit more money at the expense of everyone else, so it's okay, right?
Forget magic. Any technology distinguishable from divine power is insufficiently advanced.
Shhhh. The former Soviet states are now shining examples of capitalism. Pointing out that internal passports are still required (and that pro-Western governments are so hated that governments which implements these sorts of laws are voted in democratically) ruins the dream.
The comparison is unfair. According to Wikipedia (which we know is inerrant) 95% of taxes in Germany are to the federation; German states collect much less taxation than US states, and their taxation rights are limited. In particular, the German VAT goes to the federation, whereas sales tax in the US go to the states or other local authorities (IIRC).
A fair comparison would be summing up all the federal and state Finanzämter and comparing with the sum of the IRS and local tax authorities in the US.
Victims of 9/11: <3000. Traffic in the US: >30,000/y
In my world no company would get any public funding at all.
In your world there would be no corporations, only cooperatives and partnerships. There is absolutely no basis in libertarian political theory for the existence of corporations, whose primary purpose is to allow groups of individuals acting under the rubric of "a corporation" to do something that no individual acting alone, in partnership, or as part of a cooperative can do: avoid legal liability for the consequences of their individual actions.
Corporate law is a pure product of the state's monopoly on force, which is being used to decree that certain types of organization (corporations) are to be priviledged over others (cooperatives, partnerships and individuals acting alone.) The only reason for this is pragmatic: corporations are huge engines of creation and productivity, and we owe a great deal of our wealth to the corporate form of organization. But that wealth is made possible only by the nanny-state sheltering individuals within corporations from the consequences of their actions.
So it is not clear why any libertarian keep talking about what "companies" can or cannot do, as in a libertarian system there would not and could not be any companies or corporations, only fully-liable individuals acting in partnership or cooperation.
Blasphemy is a human right. Blasphemophobia kills.