Slashdot Mirror
22 Million SSL Certificates In Use Are Invalid
darthcamaro writes "While SSL certs are widely used on the Internet today, a new study from Qualys, set to be officially released at Black Hat in July, is going to show some shocking statistics. Among the findings in the study is that only 3% of SSL certs in use were actually properly configured. Quoting: '"So we have about 22 million SSL servers with certificates that are completely invalid because they do not match the domain name on which they reside," Ivan Ristic, director of engineering at Qualys, said.'"
The worst is when they even force users to add exceptions just to watch random websites (Firefox, I'm looking at you). Now not only do I have to deal with the annoying warning blown out of all imaginary proportions, but I'm also adding an exception to a random website just because I want to browse it once in a life time that I may never remember to remove in the future and may cause real security issues later.
I really can't understand what's so wrong with temporary exceptions...
How can we ever expect to get any use out of this stuff if we're constantly training the users to ignore everything the security software is trying to tell them?
We can't, and we shouldn't. When users regularly see warning messages that are abacadabra to many of those users, the effect is predictable (and well understood): user won't read warnings anymore, and just do whatever is most likely to make the warning disappear.
At that point, you're just wasting user's time, making sure that genuine serious events dive below the radar, and waste system resources / application code (warning dialog boxes, etc) that doesn't get you any real-world gain. Which means that overall, you're doing worse than if you had just silently ignored those warnings.
If you want secure: make it work, solid, and easy to use. If that's too much to ask, better forget about it - a half-baked feeling of security is worse than being aware of its absence.
So an obvious better solution would be to handle invalid/broken security tokens for what they are (non-secure), and don't bother users with it other than small (visible) clues that could be checked by users who care and/or know what they're doing. Eg. expired SSL cert in a browser session -> no warning dialog, show URL like regular URLs in address bar (vs. special markup used for secure connections), and open/no lock icon in status bar.