Slashdot Mirror


Considering a Fair Penalty For Illegal File-sharing

An anonymous reader writes with this excerpt, following up on yesterday's announcement of the 1.5 million dollar verdict against Jammie Thomas: "This week a federal jury handed down the verdict in the third file-sharing trial against a Minnesota mother of four who has been fighting against the charges brought by the RIAA since 2005. Understandably, a lot of people are outraged by this verdict and while reading through comments about the fine on some online forums, I saw some interesting opinions on how these fines should be assessed. The point that $62,500 per song is excessively high seems to be something that everyone can agree on, but what actually is fair seems to be a big point of contention."

2 of 728 comments (clear)

  1. Re:Hang on... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0, Flamebait

    Bullshit...

    Having rich friends does not make you rich, nor does having rich parents (though that can be more of a help), nor does being lucky.
    What makes you rich is the amount of wealth YOU have, not your friends or parents. I am rich and neither my parents, nor most of my friends are rich. Get off of this ridiculous notion that everyone who is rich was handed their wealth on a silver platter. I worked my ass off for 17 years and didn't fall into the traps of debt and reckless spending that most Americans fall into. Now I have a 7 figure bank account, a nice peice of property that is mine free and clear and a 3 year old vehicle which I also owe no money on. All of this with a salary of less that 75,000 a year. I did odd jobs, worked retail on weekends and lived on a real budget. Beleive me I am not the exception to the rule here. You wouldn't know most rich people if they kicked you in the nuts.

  2. Re:Ill gotten gains by Hognoxious · · Score: 0, Flamebait

    Or your wife just died

    Don't get my hopes up.

    --
    Confucius say, "Find worm in apple - bad. Find half a worm - worse."