Slashdot Mirror
Fedora Project Drops SQLNinja 'Hacker' Tool
simonb writes, "In what can only be described as a fit of insanity, the Fedora Board have declared a 'hacker tool' not fit for entry into their software repositories. Today your SQL injection tools, tomorrow your nmap?" The Register links the Fedora board's meeting minutes. From the story: "The move came on Monday in a unanimous vote by the Fedora Project's board of directors rejecting a request that SQLNinja be added to the archive of open-source applications. It came even as a long list of other hacker tools are included in the bundle and was harshly criticized by some security watchers. 'It seems incredibly short sighted to reject software based on perceived legal usage,' said Jacob Appelbaum, a full-time programmer for the Tor Project. 'They have decided to become judges of likely usage based on their own experience. That is a path of madness.' ... [T]he board unanimously decided to add a new statement to Fedora's legal guidelines concerning the inclusion of hacking tools. ... Smith said the language is intended to clarify its stance on a class of software that can be used both to secure and penetrate protected networks."
I'm afraid that I don't understand your point. Are you saying that, because this isn't a program that just goes "oh look, I think I found a vulnerability" but actually exploits it, that it's any less valuable to someone in charge of network security?
If you're trying to secure a system, a tool which identifies the vulnerabilities is of great use. This tool doesn't find the vulnerabities, you have to do that yourself. Once you find a vulnerable webpage, you use this tool to exploit it.
It's kind like checking a building for open doors, actively trying to jimmy the doors, or see how easily the locks can be picked. That's valuable as it identifies weaknesses. This tool would be more akin to going in and stealing things after someone else pointed out the unlocked door.
Of course no-one has pointed out the political angle. I doubt RedHat wants to host a tool in the repositories whose stated purpose is for compromising Microsoft SQL databases.
Disclaimer: I used to work for Red Hat and personally know some of the board.
SQLNinja is not a security analysis tool. It is no more useful for telling you if your database app is insecure than a blowtorch is for telling you if you have a gas leak. SQL injection vulnerabilities are *trivial* to detect with simple input fuzzing.
SQLNinja is certainly a legitimately useful *demonstration* tool for developers and administrators to show their bosses just how severe their problems are, such that they might be prioritized, but it's designed for software that doesn't even run on Fedora, so it provides negligible benefit to the Fedora community. Anyone who knows enough to search for "SQL injection tool" can find it and install it, so there's really not much of a barrier here, but leaving it out of the distribution reduces the risk of Fedora being used as a gateway to the fat wallet of Red Hat in any litigation, a problem which most community distributions do not suffer from.
Fedora takes a lot of moral stands, but they're ultimately about things that will somehow benefit the Fedora community in the long term, and there's really no foreseeable payoff here, or certainly none that overrides the fantastic headache it could incur. I certainly can't fault them for picking their battles.
There's no failure quite as dissatisfying as a complete and total solution to the wrong problem.