Slashdot Mirror


Feds Help You Find Your Fastest Internet Service

jfruhlinger writes "Slashdot previously covered the National Broadband Map, designed by the US Federal government to illustrate where the 'digital divide' between those with access to high-speed Internet and those who go without. But, as blogger Ryan Faas points out, you can use it for a much more individualistic purpose: to find your fastest local wired or wireless ISP. Just plug in your name and address and you'll soon see what your options are."

7 of 163 comments (clear)

  1. Advertised speeds, not useful by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Checked my location, advertised speed and reality are not the same.

    Thanks but try again.

  2. Not accurate results by mschaffer · · Score: 4, Informative

    The National Broadband Map gives erroneous results. For example, it states that Verizon has broadband service for my address, but it doesn't.

  3. Pure Bullshit by phantomcircuit · · Score: 4, Interesting

    That site says comcast offers 1 gbps service to my house.

    1. Re:Pure Bullshit by Omega+Hacker · · Score: 5, Insightful

      It amazes me that they think this was an effective use of over $250 million dollars. If they had simply set up a proper crowd-sourcing system including actual speed tests plus enough marketing to get people to help fill it in, we would have ended up with actually useful data. Hell, they could have given a $3-5 reward to every single residential end-point in the entire US for providing info and still come in radically under that budget. And honestly, how much time does it take to go to comcast.com or twtelecom.com and look at their plans for a given region to at least get some basic sanity checks on this data??

      --
      GStreamer - The only way to stream!
  4. Re:Obligatority by hairyfeet · · Score: 5, Interesting

    Sadly this thing isn't even worth joking about, it is a 200 million dollar lie that is so full of shit its eyes are brown. Plugged in my mom's address (I've been fighting for a decade to get something better than dialup for her) and it said I had FOUR count them four choices, two of which don't even operate in this area, one which told us point blank if you are even a single block out of the city limits to piss off, and the fourth refuses to run a single inch unless you give them 300% of the costs of the line upfront to ensure their incredible ass raping profits. Oh and they also have a WISP listed that we actually tried and is lucky if it works four hours a night and have worse TOS than Hughesnet.

    So yeah, if you are using this thing for anything more than a laugh you are just wasting your time the way the government wasted your money on this fairy tale. So far I've plugged in a dozen addresses and not a single one was close to reality and both the speeds and carriers available were complete bullshit.

    --
    ACs don't waste your time replying, your posts are never seen by me.
  5. This map is completely useless by MobyDisk · · Score: 5, Informative

    Using my address, I see 6 ISPs offering >3Mbps service. All of that is completely wrong.

    1) Verizon: 50 - 100Mbps.
    When I tried to get Verizon DSL, they told me it wasn't supported in my area. The reality is it is a lower middle class area and many people on my street can't afford internet access. So they probably could provide it, but don't bother.
    2) Cavalier Telephone: 50 - 100Mbps
    Ironically, they use Verizon's lines. Their service was so bad it was getting to be less than the 384Mbps they claimed it was. I canceled a few years ago.
    3) Clearwire: 10 - 25Mbps
    This is a wireless provider, and I don't even think it can theoretically reach those kinds of speeds. I stopped by one of their booths at the mall and they can actually tell you the signal-to-noise ratio for a given address and they told me that service probably wouldn't work here. That is believable, since I don't get cell service at my house either.
    4) Comcast: 50 - 100Mbps
    I signed-up for Comcast business class internet and they called me and apologized and said their lines couldn't handle anything more than their low-end 3Mbps service. But it sure beat Cavalier Telephone so I went with it. But even at their "turbo-boost" they still only claim 12, so what the heck is with 50 - 100?
    5, 6) T-mobile claiming 6 - 10 Mbps (wirelessly? I don't think so...) and Covad claiming 3 - 6 Mbps.
    Perhaps I should switch to Covad for being the only one to make an honest claim.

  6. Report the inaccuracies to them by InvisiBill · · Score: 3, Informative
    http://www.broadbandmap.gov/faq#ms4

    What can I do if I think that the information about my address is incorrect?
    If you see information that you believe is incorrect, please let us know. You can let us know if you believe the provider is not available at that location. Please remember that the search results show information about the census block or road segment. Generally, if broadband is available within part of a census block or road segment, it is available across all of that area, but not always.