European Court of Justice Rejects Stem-Cell Patents
ianare writes "The European Court of Justice Friday issued a preliminary opinion that procedures involving human embryonic stem cells are not patentable — even if the process in question does not involve the direct destruction of embryos — because they are tantamount to making industrial use of human embryos, which 'would be contrary to ethics and public policy.'"
Personally I don't think ethics should play a role in what is patentable.
Then you don't understand the nature of ethics. Ethics play a role in everything we do, even by their absence.
I'm sure that some would argue that the ethical requirement on a court is to apply simple objective tests that would reach a different conclusion to this, but that's very different from saying that ethics don't apply.