Slashdot Mirror


Man Robs Bank of $1 To Get Health Care In Jail

f1vlad writes "A 59-year-old man has been jailed in Gastonia, N.C., on charges of larceny after allegedly robbing an RBC Bank for $1 so he could get health care in prison. Richard James Verone handed a female teller a note demanding the money and claiming that he had a gun, according to the police report."

29 of 950 comments (clear)

  1. Sad, but I can see doing it too by elrous0 · · Score: 5, Insightful

    If you can't get a job, that's about the quickest, easiest way to get healthcare in the U.S. The healthcare isn't great in jails and prisons, but it beats the hell out of nothing.

    For those of you fortunate enough to live in developed countries, let me break down the U.S. system for you. Here are the only ways to get healthcare in the U.S.:

    1) Go to prison or jail. Not the best care, but beats nothing
    2) Be real poor. This will usually qualify you for Medicaid--which sucks, but is also better than nothing.
    3) Be a child. There are usually programs for providing healthcare for kids.
    4) Be over 65. This will qualify you for Medicare--which isn't the best by a longshot (many doctors won't accept it) but it's a lot better than Medicaid
    5) Get a job with benefits. This means a full-time job (working as a cashier at Walmart won't cut it). Better come armed with a college degree. Quality is all over the map.
    6) Join the military. Very good healthcare. But this could involve getting shot at.
    7) Become a Congressman of other high-ranking government official. Best fucking care you can get. Expect gold-plated bedpans for yourself and your family, even as you rail against government-supported healthcare for everyone else.

    Of course, you can also elect to pay for it yourself. But, if you have ever seen what even basic healthcare costs in the U.S., you will realize this is impractical for anyone who isn't Bill Gates. A single emergency room visit could easily bankrupt even a moderately well-off individual. And don't even THINK about having surgery unless you've got a mansion to mortgage.

    --
    SJW: Someone who has run out of real oppression, and has to fake it.
    1. Re:Sad, but I can see doing it too by WrongSizeGlass · · Score: 5, Insightful

      1) Go to prison or jail. Not the best care, but beats nothing

      No always. Take a look at California's prison healthcare issues. This guy will probably be charged by the state (instead of federal) and the state may even deal with him as a non-violent offender who gets house arrest (and has to pay for his own monitoring). The DA & prosecutor aren't stupid - they'll want to discourage this type of activity.

    2. Re:Sad, but I can see doing it too by Hazel+Bergeron · · Score: 5, Informative

      I'm sorry that it's so tough for you guys in the US. Here in the UK, Cameron (like Reagan's mini-me Thatcher and various oddly-admired gentlemen all the way back to half-American Churchill) is trying his best to turn us into the 51st state.

      But it turns out that quite a lot of British people love the NHS. And, imperfect as all human endeavours will be, so do I. And I don't just love it in principle - I, like almost everyone in the UK, have experienced and benefitted from it.

      (I also have experienced US healthcare. Oh dear. The US does a few things very right - why must it get some things so wrong?)

    3. Re:Sad, but I can see doing it too by Hazel+Bergeron · · Score: 5, Interesting

      So what you're saying is that he'll have to commit a more serious crime?

    4. Re:Sad, but I can see doing it too by cob666 · · Score: 5, Informative

      While I agree with everything you said I will say that I am currently self employed and paying for my own health insurance, my monthly premiums are just over 600 per month (I'm 45 and in pretty good health). While routine visits are paid for I still have a $30 co-pay for every doctor visit and usually a $25 co-pay for prescriptions (although I have paid higher for more costly medication). Anything other than routine requires pre-authorization from the insurance company and is more times than not declined with no explanation the first or even second time my doctor requests it (such as physical therapy for a knee). Also, every year my premiums increase by 10-15 percent and my premiums are almost to the point where I will NOT be able to afford that monthly cost.

      --
      Do what thou wilt shall be the whole of the Law - Aleister Crowley
    5. Re:Sad, but I can see doing it too by BSAtHome · · Score: 5, Funny

      Why do you assume he has a house?

      House-arrest for a homeless. That'll be nice. Please stay on the corner of 5th and west st. for the duration of your time to be served.

    6. Re:Sad, but I can see doing it too by TheGratefulNet · · Score: 5, Insightful

      young.

      yes, yes, you skip over the most obvious thing.

      I'm nearly 50. I'm not in bad health but things do get worse over time, as you get older. they just do.

      enjoy your youth and $150/mo payment. it won't last forever. remember this post in 20 or 30 years time.

      --

      --
      "It is now safe to switch off your computer."
    7. Re:Sad, but I can see doing it too by gclef · · Score: 5, Insightful

      "Americans can always be counted on to do the right thing...after they have exhausted all other possibilities."
          -- Winston Churchill

    8. Re:Sad, but I can see doing it too by moonbender · · Score: 4, Informative

      FWIW, approximately the same amount of money pays for full private coverage in Germany. (Most people pay far less, unemployed people pay nothing.) Visits to the doctor, prescription meds, glasses, hospital stays and surgery are basically all covered 100%. If you don't need the coverage for a full quarter, a part of the fees is returned.

      --
      Switch back to Slashdot's D1 system.
    9. Re:Sad, but I can see doing it too by Sir_Sri · · Score: 5, Interesting

      $1500 is a lot when you're out of work. And more to the point, how often can that 1500 re-occur? Admittedly I'm in canada so we don't treat people like they'll have to pay out of pocket. But my best friend at 29 had cancer. He was admitted, sent home, re-admitted to hospital several times in a week, and 3 times in one day. It wasn't even that the hospital was trying to be rid of him, he just had a lot of different parts of his body failing in different ways and they'd solve one problem, send him home (because the feeling is you recover better at home) and 2 days later something else would go wrong.

      He's sorted out health wise now. But that's beside the point. If you end up in hospital multiple times in a month, how often will your insurance re-bill you.

      What does "full coverage" mean? Prescription drugs? Do you have a co-pay? If you have a deductible of 1500 in hospital care (or something like that) it's certainly not 'full'. What if you go to a hospital in a different city than where you live? Does your insurance company approve (or not) of places you can go? Also, under what conditions can they drop your coverage. That was the trick with my friend, as he learned through friends in various support groups. In the US the first time you get cancer you're probably covered by insurance. But the moment they think you're cured for 3 months they drop your ass like a rock, and no one else will touch you with a 100 metre, I'm sorry, foot, pole, and then you're in deep shit.

    10. Re:Sad, but I can see doing it too by elrous0 · · Score: 5, Insightful

      So, you can get health insurance for your family for 10,000 to 15,000 per year, and not have to pay much else.

      Tell me, do you actually consider your words before you start typing away? Do you have any idea how much money that is to the average family in the U.S.? The average household income in the U.S. is $31,000. And that's before taxes, rent, food, etc. Do you really think someone making $31K a year can afford $10K-$15 just for health insurance?

      Are you high, or just fucking stupid?

      --
      SJW: Someone who has run out of real oppression, and has to fake it.
    11. Re:Sad, but I can see doing it too by Intrepid+imaginaut · · Score: 5, Insightful

      That's pretty much it. This has to be one of the saddest stories I've ever heard.

    12. Re:Sad, but I can see doing it too by azalin · · Score: 5, Informative

      For those of you who don't know what "full private coverage" means (eg everyone not from germany):
      * Single or double room if you are in hospital (your choice)
      * free choice of clinic
      * treatment by the chief physician
      * full dental care
      * glasses, contact lenses
      * alternative medication and treatment (eg acupuncture)
      * massage and physiotherapie
      * psychotherapy
      All paid for. You usally get the best your hospital / doctor has to offer.

    13. Re:Sad, but I can see doing it too by elrous0 · · Score: 4, Informative

      Because he's a conservative who's never been unemployed, broke, and sick. He thinks that all we need is a tax-free savings account to save our healthcare system. He thinks there is an unemployed cancer patient sitting out there who would be just fine--if only he could pay for his own healthcare without a small tax on his savings. All we need is for the government to get out of the way; and all the poor, unemployed, underemployed, etc, would finally have the freedom to pay for their own healthcare with the millions of $ that are going to magically appear out of nowhere once we cut taxes on the rich and corporations.

      In other words, because he's an deluded ideologue with no connection to reality.

      --
      SJW: Someone who has run out of real oppression, and has to fake it.
    14. Re:Sad, but I can see doing it too by geekoid · · Score: 4, Insightful

      " Universal care in other countries doesn't fix this. "
      Yes, in fact it can.

      Remember, much of are cots are acquired because we DON"T have UHC.

      Poor women go into ER to complain about 'Chest pains' and then mention they might be pregnant to gt a pregnancy kit. So they get 2000 in tests when all they really needed was a 15 dollar pregnancy kit.

      People go to ER to get treated for something that would have been substantial cheaper if they had access to a doctor to get treated right away instead of having to wait for an emergency.

      Dental issues are seldom considered an emergency.. until it's so infected that have to go to the ER because the infection is spreading to the brain.

      People get minimum they needed to get to treat the emergency, not the underling problem, so they come back every time a chronic problem becomes and emergency.

      And so on..

      We do pay for this, with higher Dr. and hospital costs, higher insurance rates.

      This doesn't even get into how not having UHC strangles many small and growing business.
      Get to a point where you need senior people? you will need to provide health care for those employees. This costs business a lot of money. If we all paid with taxes, then there would be less of a burden an small business.

      UHC lowers the cost of health. The market, by it's very nature, will not help people. There is NO competing for 50% of the population. given a free market, they have no choice.

      You're solution leads to great and cheep healthcare for the most well off people only, because insurance is about offsetting costs. SO it's in the business best interest to insure you until you leave the optimal area. so if your re 18-30, and make 150K+ a year, the 'free market' will be happy to help you.

      This is shown in history.

      --
      The Kruger Dunning explains most post on /. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dunning%E2%80%93Kruger_effect
    15. Re:Sad, but I can see doing it too by Grishnakh · · Score: 5, Funny

      Here's what he needs to do: when he's at his sentencing hearing, and they sentence him to house arrest, he needs to grab a pen, go over to the DA/prosecuting attorney, and stab him with it. Take out his eyes if possible (he's a lawyer, he deserves it). Then put his hands up and say "send me to prison!"

      There's no way they can avoid sending him to prison after brutally maiming a lawyer (since hurting a lawyer gets you the same penalty as hurting a human, even though lawyers aren't human).

    16. Re:Sad, but I can see doing it too by Hylandr · · Score: 4, Insightful

      Welcome to the US legal health system.

      FTFY.

      - Dan.

      --
      ~ People that think they are better than anyone else for any reason are the cause of all the strife in the world.
    17. Re:Sad, but I can see doing it too by funkylovemonkey · · Score: 5, Interesting

      About six years ago I developed a kidney stone that refused to pass. I was right out of college, had just lost my health coverage and did not have a job with insurance. The pain was chronic and possibly dangerous (I won't go into the details but also fairly rare). Finally I went to my local hospital and paid out of pocket. After four or five visits along with a CT scan and a trip to the emergency room (and about six hundred dollars in hospital bills) they finally told me that I needed lithotripsy to destroy the stone. Because I had no insurance the cost of them blasting the stone in an out patient operation (basically going into the hospital that morning and being kicked to the curb by lunch) was roughly 8000 dollars. Instead I flew to Germany where a weeks stay in the hospital and two lithotripsy operations (because the stone did not break up the first time) along with x-rays, ultrasounds and other tests cost me 3000 dollars. Add in a plane ticket that cost about 600 and I paid less then half to fly across the world to get the operation done then I would have paid here in the states (even worse, if I had to have two operations in the states the total would have been 16,000, whereas the German doctors only charged me a few hundred more for a few more days in the hospital). I had grown up hearing all my life about the horrors of socialized medicine. About long waits and incompetent care. What I experienced was the opposite. I had longer waits in US hospitals (including a two hour wait for a CT scan, I never waited more then half an hour for anything in Germany). What shocked me more was how brazenly I was treated by the doctors here in the US, who seemed almost uninterested in what I had to say and were more interested in getting me out of their office. I also had the unfortunate experience in the US during this time of having one of my samples switched with someone else's and had the doctor (erroneously) call me into the office to tell me I had Hepatitis C. I wasn't amused.

  2. Yeap by ciderbrew · · Score: 5, Insightful

    That's the way to do it when you've got nothing. How awful must his life have been to think that prison is a step up.
    I love the NHS.

    1. Re:Yeap by sgtrock · · Score: 5, Informative

      From Gapminder.Org for 2006:

      UK life expectancy 80 years. % of GDP spent on healthcare: 8.4%

      US life expectancy 78 years. % of GDP spent on healthcare: 15%

      In fact, the ONLY country in the world who spends more on healthcare as a percentage of GDP than the US is Timor-Leste at 16%. Most of the so-called 'socialist' medical plans are MUCH MUCH cheaper than the US and provide FAR better results. In fact, Every. Single. Country. who has a longer life expectancy than the US has a nationalized healthcare system that costs much less than ours. Why the HELL aren't the Dems hammering on this point?

      Posted by a somewhat bitter US citizen who knows the answer but still doesn't like it. :-(

  3. Sounds like The Onion by Relyx · · Score: 4, Insightful

    When I saw this story appear in my feed, I thought it was an article from The Onion. My god...

  4. Re:DUH by rjstanford · · Score: 4, Informative

    You can get immediate treatment at any hospital ER. You can not get ongoing, expensive, "voluntary" treatment without insurance.

    --
    You're special forces then? That's great! I just love your olympics!
  5. Re:Why bother? by hedwards · · Score: 5, Insightful

    It never ceases to surprise me just how OK Americans are with rape, so long as the person being raped isn't a woman. Perhaps before we start lecturing other nations about human rights abuses, we might want to remember that there is a prohibition against cruel and unusual punishment, and only the most narrow minded of people would consider prison conditions to not be a part of the punishment.

  6. Re:Sad state of by sqrt(2) · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Then I have some really bad news for you.

    You're ALREADY paying for all those people you are so don't like. Yes, it's true, you pay in form of taxes which cover ER visits that never get paid by poor people (who are often also unhealthy, go figure); you pay in the form of higher insurance premiums so that health care can be profitable (and because the pool of people is much smaller); you pay in the form of your business having less healthy employees; you pay in the form of a more dangerous society, as more people get pushed into crime because they cannot afford to care for themselves even working full time.

    The jokes is really on you, because if you'd give up your ideological hatred for those people and for the idea that some social problems can be best tackled collectively through strategic actions by government, you'd end up paying less in taxes to cover Universal Healthcare than you currently pay for private insurance and all the unseen costs of having the terrible system we have today in the US.

    I understand your frustration, but you're advocating a position that actually ends up being counter productive to your stated goals.

    --
    If you build it, nerds will come. Soylentnews.org
  7. Re:Sad state of by TheSpoom · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Now how are your strategic actions by the government going to help me end up paying less in taxes to cover that person's lung cancer?

    Because the US is (at least in theory) a civilized country, meaning that the person with lung cancer is going to be covered every time he goes to the ER anyway, as hospitals cannot refuse to give life-saving care. You're almost certainly paying more for the emergency care as they die than you would to give them the care they need to live.

    If you are in fact arguing that hospitals should refuse life-saving care on the basis of a lack of insurance, you're a horrible human being.

    --
    It's better to vote for what you want and not get it than to vote for what you don't want and get it.
    - E. Debs
  8. Re:Sad state of by NMerriam · · Score: 5, Informative

    It must be tough to live your whole life worrying that someone, somewhere is having something good happen that they didn't "deserve". And of course if something bad happens, fuck that person, they obviously did deserve it. got cancer? Fuck you, here's a free bullet, grandma. Go suck some dick in a back alley if you want chemotherapy. Also, we need tort reform so that grandma can't sue the company that told her Asbestos was safe to eat in her breakfast cereal every morning for 30 years even though they had proof it was deadly. I don't want ambulance chasers affecting my 401k.

    Fuck you sick people, if you weren't such lazy and immoral people you'd be healthy and rich like me!

    God bless America.

    --
    Recursive: Adj. See Recursive.
  9. Re:the tea party and libertarian view of the usa by bussdriver · · Score: 4, Insightful

    nope. Americans are suckered by propaganda; its all about emotions and not about facts and results. Just like global warming, for too many citizens its about their personal identity as a conservative or whatever and they can't be what they want/believe they are (and what is best) if they hold opposition positions-- its like the issues were made part of the definition of what they are... and they have been and it has been done under their nose--- instead of having them define their group they wish to belong to they define themselves to fit within the group. Ironic they are also such individualists...

  10. Reintegration -- a sop by fyngyrz · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Sure they have programs to let ex-cons re-enter the society

    These are sops; ex-cons are flat-out unemployable. Heck, even if you're *not* a con it's tough to find a job for most people. But if you are... you're done. You're never, ever going to re-integrate with society unless you have resources of your own that make getting a job unnecessary.

    The US is in the active process of creating a permanently unemployable underclass, consumed by rage and resentment, with a constantly increasing pool of criminal skills. The next "war" will be against this self-inflicted injury to society, and you can bet your last red cent it will consume the tattered rags of liberty remaining to non-felons today... felons are just a little ahead of the curve.

    --
    I've fallen off your lawn, and I can't get up.
  11. "in the active process of..." by Benfea · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Are you [bad word] kidding me? In the process of creating a permanently unemployable underclass? As in present progressive tense? No, you should use the past tense. Try "have created" instead.

    The conservatives and libertarians threw much of our rights under the bus in order to elect "tough on crime" candidates. Not only did this undermine our constitutional rights and create a giant prison industry that rivals the military industrial complex (why didn't anyone hold their feet to the fire for massively expanding government while campaigning as the "small government" crowd?), but creating a permanently unemployable underclass was the whole [bad word] point.

    Conservative/libertarian economic philosophy has been undermining the middle class since the days of Reagan. One of the ways conservatives and libertarians have been able to mask this fact was by transferring large numbers of the working poor into prison, thus reducing job-seeking competition for people falling from the middle class into the upper reaches of the working poor. Without this part of the strategy, those riots you see in Wisconsin, Michigan and other places would have started happening a long time ago.