Slashdot Mirror


Google Launches News Badges

theodp writes "Does it make you sad that you're too grown up to earn Scouting Merit Badges? Well, thanks to the PhDs at Google, you can now start earning Google News badges as you read articles about your favorite topics. The more you read, the higher rank you'll attain; Bronze, Silver, Gold, Platinum and finally, Ultimate. They say, 'Your badges are private by default, but if you want, you can share your badges with your friends. Tell them about your news interests, display your expertise, start a conversation or just plain brag about how well-read you are.'"

28 of 112 comments (clear)

  1. Corporate News != Reading by improfane · · Score: 2, Interesting

    Contrary to popular belief, reading news that is mass produced by large corporations with vested interests and that manipulate and actively suppress fact does not make you "well read".

    Not even sophomoric. Books are real reading. I want badges for the number of science fiction books. I read four in the last two weeks!

    These badges just prove that you're addicted to some thing that is new and always being updated. It's like refreshing on Slashdot for a new article to appear. At least I'll get a badge for wasting my time reading the news now! Facebook culture everywhere.

    --
    Slashdot needs Geekcode | Can anyone recommend any good SCIFI? My tastes: Foundation, Startide Rising, CITY, Ringworld,
    1. Re:Corporate News != Reading by Ambvai · · Score: 2

      Ignoring any arguments about mainstream journalism, at least it's a push to try and get people to read more news. People respond to the whole achievements system and this is being pointed towards something useful.

    2. Re:Corporate News != Reading by sakdoctor · · Score: 2

      Any achievements system can be gamed.
      For every online chufty badge, a bot WILL be written to exploit it. No exceptions.

    3. Re:Corporate News != Reading by fuzzyfuzzyfungus · · Score: 2

      Luckily, only newspaper publishers are controlled by corporations with vested interests, so readers of books are entirely safe...

      The assertion that much of contemporary journalism is rubbish at best and propaganda at worst is hardly false; but it isn't as though the economics of other information-dissemination media, especially the ones with relatively high costs or natural-monopolies in infrastructure are any different.

    4. Re:Corporate News != Reading by gl4ss · · Score: 3, Interesting

      just going in on a specific genre doesn't make you well read either. reading exclusively scifi and fantasy just makes you a dork idiot, too, though if you have time there's no reason why you shouldn't have read potters, if only to rip on it's stupid text and print edit techniques which are straight from elementary school to increase page count. some news give some context for reading some books though, like potters.. but it's different kind of reading when you read the news, because current events after all are current events and updates on past current events are still news. if you want to list what you've read in the past 4 weeks go ahead, it's easy enough, nobody's going to give a crap though and nobody's going to give a crap about these badges. though, how long till someone codes a firefox extension that gets you the badge levels?

      --
      world was created 5 seconds before this post as it is.
    5. Re:Corporate News != Reading by mat+catastrophe · · Score: 2

      Were your science-fiction books not also "mass produced by large corporations with vested interests and that manipulate and actively suppress fact"? Could they possibly be publishing fiction with themes that reinforce the same sort of effect you find reprehensible in the media?

      Sci-fi has a long history of being written by reactionary, patriarchal, authoritarian people, you know.

      --
      sig not found
    6. Re:Corporate News != Reading by improfane · · Score: 2

      Another example of this was in the British newspaper industry in the 1960s. Working class newspapers faded from the market because corporate newspapers were able to raise more funding through advertisements.

      You cannot compete against well funded.

      --
      Slashdot needs Geekcode | Can anyone recommend any good SCIFI? My tastes: Foundation, Startide Rising, CITY, Ringworld,
  2. Web history mandatory. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Insightful

    To get started with badges, visit Google News from a signed-in account with web history

    Ha-ha. Fuck no.

    I refuse to give up one of the few pieces of data about me that Google allows me to control... for a few pixels.

    1. Re:Web history mandatory. by TubeSteak · · Score: 4, Insightful

      I refuse to give up one of the few pieces of data about me that Google allows me to control... for a few pixels.

      I feel much the same way.
      But I'm giving it a week before someone creates a firefox/chrome plugin that will autosurf google news and earn you all 500 badges.

      Wherever there are online badges, there are people who will cheat to get them.

      --
      [Fuck Beta]
      o0t!
    2. Re:Web history mandatory. by jbn-o · · Score: 5, Interesting

      I refuse to give up one of the few pieces of data about me that Google allows me to control... for a few pixels.

      Madam what you are is clear, we are merely haggling over price.

  3. Re:This is stupid by WrongSizeGlass · · Score: 5, Funny

    How does reading the news make you an expert on anything other than reading news?

    I'll let you know as soon as I read a story that tells me the answer to your question.

  4. not for apps users by tero · · Score: 2

    Oh well look at that, yet another feature that Google Apps users will not be able to use.

    It seems the best way to opt-out of new Google stuff is to become their customer - then you can't get on these things even if you wanted it.

  5. Badges? by Anne_Nonymous · · Score: 5, Funny

    We don't need no stinkin' badges.

    1. Re:Badges? by derGoldstein · · Score: 4, Funny

      They're for weak people who need others in order to validate their existence.

      Now MOD ME UP DAMN YOU!!!! I NEED YOUR VALIDATION!!!

      --
      Entomologically speaking, the spider is not a bug, it's a feature.
  6. "Well read" by traindirector · · Score: 3, Insightful

    Exactly--a preoccupation with "news" stories is the opposite of being well read. Being well read involves understanding the depths of artistic works / events. News stories provide the opposite, especially from the establishment media. They provide surface-level summaries of what some people have said that generally serve corporate and political interests.

    I don't think anyone's immune to being interested in the latest happenings, waiting for some great or tragic event to bolster or destroy a cause or bring salvation or damnation. But this superficiality works against a true understanding of what's going on, and such a reward system incentivizes chasing "what's new" over what's true or what's good.

  7. Badges... by ChinggisK · · Score: 4, Funny

    ...badges badges badges badges badges badges badges mushroom mushroom MUSHROOM!

  8. Good! by molnarcs · · Score: 2, Interesting

    I know that there'll be a steady stream of snarky remarks about who ridiculous the whole idea is, but it's still a brilliant move. Due to my work, I'm in constant touch with the "new generation" - students in the range of 13-25. And they like this kind of stuff. Don't ask me why, but they are fascinated by the possibilities of exhibitionism on the Internet - "telling the world what you're doing" kinda of stuff. Had a girlfriend a few months back, and she loved Facebook of course, and location services. She loved to "check in" every place she went to, and let everybody know that she is there. Once we traveled to the south of the city, which is a huge area of mangrove forest. There's absolutely nothing there, just a very small and rather poor fishing village, lots of water, swamp, and thick mangrove forests. And when we arrived, she was trying to check in with her phone. Amazing! This is just one of the many reasons why our relationship was brief. But the point is, that young people love collecting things like that, even if it sounds ridiculous to some of us. I'm not that old actually (34), but I know many here are older than that ;)

  9. Obligatory Web Comic by BJ_Covert_Action · · Score: 4, Funny

    The future is one step closer: courtesy of SMBC.

  10. I'm a non-Flemish... by srussia · · Score: 2

    Belgian, you insensitive clod!

    --
    Set your phasers on "funky"!
  11. science fiction doesnt either by decora · · Score: 5, Insightful

    lets take "magnetar capital" for example.

    there has been one book that discusses this little hedge fund, its called EConned (which grew out of a blog called nakedcapitalism.com).

    on the other hand there have been a half-dozen news stories about it, some of the first being in the Wall Street Journal and New York Times.

    there have been pretty much zero science fiction books that deal with financial engineering, credit derivatives, tranched securities, and everything else related to the financial crisis.

    there are a lot of good reporters working for the 'corporate media', including louise story and gillian tett.

    ---------

    i could also talk about the Vietnam War Crimes Working Group Files, which were originally found by an 'independent researcher', but later more thoroughly examined by someone who had worked for the LA Times.

    i dont think there are any science fiction books about the Vietnam War Crimes Working Group Files.

    1. Re:science fiction doesnt either by Mindcontrolled · · Score: 2

      Ah well, don't mind it. The "everything in the news is biased bullshit" is just another one of those faux-cynic memes spouted around here daily. It's working along the same lines as the "all politicians are equal"-meme. Doesn't help dealing with reality, but it won't go away either. Like the smell of piss in a derelict subway station.

      --
      Ubi solitudinem faciunt, pacem appellant.
  12. Can someone help me? by dtmos · · Score: 2

    Why would:

    (a) My friends be interested in my news interests? I'm not interested in theirs. . .except under unusual circumstances, when I'll just ask them myself. . . .
    (b) I want to display my expertise, start a conversation or just plain brag about how well-read I am? Wouldn't that just drive any (remaining) friends away?
    (c) I want to give Google a signed-in account with web history, and permission to track me in even greater detail?

    I confess that this type of stuff just baffles me completely. What's the attraction?

    1. Re:Can someone help me? by BJ_Covert_Action · · Score: 2

      I want to display my expertise, start a conversation or just plain brag about how well-read I am? Wouldn't that just drive any (remaining) friends away?

      While I agree that bragging about how well-read you are will probably just piss folks off, there is nothing wrong with wanting to display your expertise. If you've worked hard to get to a certain point in your life, and you have developed a certain level of intimate knowledge on a particular subject, that would certainly be a lifetime achievement that you would probably be proud to show off from time to time.

      That's not to say that you should be a giant d-bag and start every sentence with, "Well, I am an expert in ....." But speaking intelligently on a subject that is relevant to your expertise is perfectly acceptable. For instance, if you work in the space industry, then you can offer a fairly unique insight when your friends start talking about the end of the Space Shuttle program and what it means for America's future space exploration activities. Similar situations could occur for doctors with regards to insight on the healthcare debate, environmental science majors with insight on the climate change controversy, and so on.

      Displaying your expertise shouldn't drive your friends away unless you are a smug wanker about it.

  13. Re:How will this ever succeed in America? by obarthelemy · · Score: 2

    most news IS ignorance, most media do not touch the important stuff. They'll blab for 5 minutes about a 10-deaths accident, or a 5-victims killer. Do YOU know how many people die each year in the US, and of what causes ? They'll rag on about 5% extra taxes.. do you know how much of those taxes are either wasted, or counterproductive ? etc, etc...

    News is entertainment at best, political indoctrination at worst.

    News is not culture, is not knowledge, is not wisdom. Especially the way it's done now.

    --
    The Cloud - because you don't care if your apps and data are up in the air.
  14. Re:Dumb idea by aix+tom · · Score: 2

    So where can I pick up my "I survived 5 minutes of Fox News without my head exploding, although I did get a slight nose bleed" badge?

  15. 2010 Google April Fools' Day Hoax=2011 Innovation by theodp · · Score: 4, Informative

    ReaderAdvantage Program: As a 2010 April Fools' Day joke, Google announced a reward program for Google Reader known as ReaderAdvantage, in which points accumulated by users for reading items could earn them Novice, Gold, Platinum, or Totally Sweet Badges, which Google revealed was a goof.

  16. Buying college/university radio stations by traindirector · · Score: 2

    What you say about radio stations is true. One of the newer tactics is enticing cash strapped colleges and universities to sell their radio stations/frequencies (usually to the great dismay of the communications department and the community). So instead of having a community service or an educational tool or both, you end up with something probably legally classified as a "religious nonprofit" set up as a repeater of some remotely-produced dogmafeed. [Did I just make that term up? No search engine results from the majors. I think it's appropriate for this type of station.]

  17. Obligatory by jawahar · · Score: 2

    "If you don't read a newspaper you are uninformed. If you do read a newspaper, you are misinformed." Mark Twain