Slashdot Mirror


Pirate Party Wins Seat In Berlin

An anonymous reader writes "The Pirate Party won its first seat in the Berlin state elections with almost 9% of the vote. From the article: '"We will get right to work," top Pirate candidate, Andreas Baum, told ZDF television. "This is all new for us."'"

20 of 241 comments (clear)

  1. Re:First... by wo1verin3 · · Score: 4, Informative

    Just in time for Talk Like a Pirate Day, September 19th.

  2. Maybe... by MrEricSir · · Score: 4, Funny

    ...others can copy their strategy?

    --
    There's no -1 for "I don't get it."
  3. But where by dlb · · Score: 3, Funny

    is the Ninja Party?

    1. Re:But where by SomePgmr · · Score: 4, Funny

      They're present, but go unnoticed.

    2. Re:But where by geekmux · · Score: 3, Funny

      is the Ninja Party?

      They've been there all along. They're so sneaky, they've changed their name to "Congress".

      Just watch C-SPAN or find a live feed of the Congressional floor. They're all very hard at work, you just can't see any of them.

      Yeah, I know. They're REALLY good Ninjas.

  4. Not just one by Shoe+Puppet · · Score: 4, Informative

    They haven't just won one seat but about 14-15. Interestingly, more seats would have been mostly useless to them as they have only nominated 15 candidates -- if they gain more seats than that or if they have to replace a member mid-term, they will have to leave that seat empty.

    --
    (+1, Disagree)
    1. Re:Not just one by Asic+Eng · · Score: 4, Informative

      Yes their original goal was "merely" to get over the 5% hurdle. German state and federal elections are run with a proportional voting system, but there is a 5% cut-off. So if you have less than 5% of the votes you will not get any seats, even if your proportion of the votes would amount to one or two. (Leaving out some details here, but that's the gist of it.) So getting over that hurdle is a big deal for a new party.

  5. Not just one by BitterKraut · · Score: 5, Informative

    Chances are that everyone on their list, which comprised only 15 candidates, will win a seat in the Berlin senate.

  6. Re:First... by vranash · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Weren't pirates often 'reliefing' the government of it's 'hard earned' tax dollars? By 'hard earned' I meant: 'stolen from the poor'?:D

  7. Reactions of other parties by tp1024 · · Score: 4, Interesting

    The funny thing is of course how the other parties reacted. When it became clear that the Pirate Party would likely get into the parliament (predicted to get 6.5% at most), they were already scandalized, how anybody could vote such loonies. Now, I must confess I haven't watched all the reactions of other parties, but after the election both SPD and CDU were dismissive to the point of insulting those who voted for the Pirate Party. (Whose voters are more educated than the average of the electorate.)

    A representative of the Left party pointed out that having to few members nominated than the seats they won indicated that they must have overestimated themselves (sic!). Green Representative Renate Künast claimed that her party got the most gains of all parties - the Green Party gained 4.5% more votes than during the last election in 2006 ... but the Pirate Party gained about 6% over that result - reaching 9%. Also none, none of the other parties saw fit to even mention the name Pirate Party even once. They all skirted the issue by saying something like - those others, a new party in the left spectrum or whatever.

    Aloofness abounds among established parties, caring about their claim to power first, other parties in the government next and the people ... oh ... well what? The people? Who's that?

    1. Re:Reactions of other parties by Arancaytar · · Score: 4, Insightful

      Sure. Minus the creationism, gold standard and crazy stuff, of course.

    2. Re:Reactions of other parties by tp1024 · · Score: 3, Interesting

      Most parties have firm opinions on all sorts of matters. Often contradictory opinions both within one party and with other parties. In order to make those opinions seem to be substantial, they cite experts whom they know to support their opinions in the first place. Or they hire experts or "scientists" or statisticians to write up some scientific seeming study with preconceived conclusions.

      Given that, I prefer a party that limits its opinions to things it (and me) truly believes in. And tries to use its own best judgment and explicitly that of its voters on those points where it doesn't - instead of stubbornly staying with a party line it is keeping only because it has adopted some opinion to some point for some reason in the past and now can't change it, because of they've already backed those random opinions up with heaps and heaps of lies and propaganda that would fly in its face if it were to change even some of those opinions.

    3. Re:Reactions of other parties by henni16 · · Score: 4, Interesting

      Sorry, but this is simply not true.
      Except for "When it became clear that the Pirate Party would likely get into the parliament (predicted to get 6.5% at most), they were already scandalized, how anybody could vote such loonies."

      I'm not sure what you've watched, but it certainly wasn't the coverage by ARD or later the local RBB. Or not a lot of it.

      Other parties had no problem naming them and dis so frequently as the success of the Pirates and the catastrophic result of the FDP were the main topics of most discussions.
      Yeah, of course they also called the Pirates "new", but so did the Pirates themselves.
      During a talk with representatives of all parties (that matter), they even did a little "special" analyzing where the pirates' 9% came from and asked everybody's opinion about that and why their parties didn't manage to get those votes.

      Some politicians from the "established" parties even congratulated the Pirates. I remember people from the Greens and the Lefts doing so.
      And they certainly didn't say "Congratulations to those others".

      And I don't remember a Left party guy talking about "they overestimated themselves".
      But I do remember one pointing out how the Pirates _under_estimated their own chances and that the Pirates obviously were surprised by their success as much as anybody else, citing (almost) not having enough candidates listed to fill the seats they won as a proof.
      And he wasn't alone, several Pirate candidates repeatedly stated how they were "baff" (perplexed) or "still a bit in shock" in view of their success.

      I also have no problem with Künast claiming they gained the most as those gains and losses are calculated in comparison to the last state election in 2006 and the Pirates weren't yet on the ballot back then.
      If you say the Pirates gained 6% to reach their 9%, you're comparing their result today to the 3% they got in Berlin during the last national election in 2009, i.e. you're comparing apples and oranges because
      a) people vote differently in state and national elections and
      b) the gains and losses of the other parties were based on the results of a different election.
      Yeah, technically the Pirates gained the most since they went from nothing to 9%, but I don't blame her for ignoring the n00bs when the main intent is to show how they are more awesome than the sucktitide that's their traditional enemies or their (realistic) competitors when it comes to building the government.

  8. Re:Dear Pirate Party: by Tom · · Score: 5, Insightful

    If you had actually read the statements of the german Pirate Party, you'd know their position is not one of "screw the creators, everything free for everyone", but quite a bit more thought-out. Go read it.

    --
    Assorted stuff I do sometimes: Lemuria.org
  9. Re:Dear Pirate Party: by Adrian+Lopez · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Stop screwing creators.

    Tell that to the music labels.

    --
    "In prison you just have to shut your eyes and take it. Here you have to shut your eyes and give it."
  10. Re:Dear Pirate Party: by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Insightful

    Can you justify a retroactive copyright extension like the one that got just passed in Europe one month ago? How the hell a retroactive extension is going to encourage creation in the past? Or is the copyright extension including a time machine?

    With these things one wonders how they are not getting even more votes....

  11. big win by Tom · · Score: 5, Informative

    This is a huge win for the german Pirate Party, as it puts it on the radar of all the mainstream press, even those that tried to ignore it so far.

    By this time tomorrow, everyone in Germany will have heard about the Pirate Party. That one of the old, established parties has been decisively kicked from parliament (~2% of the votes, with 5% being required to enter parliament) only strengthens this perception, as the Pirate Party is called a "replacement" in some circles - the party kicked out is the Liberal party, which aside from being strictly capitalistic also used to ride on the tickets of things like freedom, liberty, individualism - stuff that is close to the Pirates as well.

    Also, the PP has gotten through other important barriers straight away: They're officially a faction, with all the rights (an office in the parliament building, etc.) of the old parties. It will be receiving campaign money (Germany has a system where the parties receive tax money to cover their expenses during the campaigns, based on the number of votes they got, but you need a certain amount to receive any at all. The purpose of the system is to make sure not only the rich can afford campaigns, and parties don't need to rely on contributions from lobbyists/companies/etc. to campaign).

    --
    Assorted stuff I do sometimes: Lemuria.org
  12. Re:First... by Aighearach · · Score: 3, Funny

    A: His lips move.

    Or his parrot's do.

  13. Re:No surprises here... by multi+io · · Score: 3, Interesting

    Uhm, no? The name "Pirate Party" works much better in Sweden, which has Pirates in their history and a population that knows enough English to know the term "software piracy". In Germany, pirates are usually associated with Somalia and the German equivalent for "pirated software" translates as "robbery copy". There was a lot of debate about weather or not it's a good idea to even call it "Pirate Party", in the end it was decided that a consistent name across all countries has more value than having names that better match the local culture.

    tl;dr In Germany, "Pirate" is a meaningless, valueless (or bad) word when used in politics.

    Not exactly true; "Softwarepiraterie" (literally "software piracy") is a well-known german term that's used in public discussions about the subject quite frequently.

  14. Re:Dear Pirate Party: by Kjella · · Score: 3, Informative

    They say a lot of things, but under Politics -> Copyright you find statements like:

    Daher fordern wir, das nichtkommerzielle Kopieren, ZugÃnglichmachen, Speichern und Nutzen von Werken nicht nur zu legalisieren, sondern explizit zu fÃrdern, um die allgemeine Verfügbarkeit von Information, Wissen und Kultur zu verbessern, denn dies stellt eine essentielle Grundvoraussetzung für die soziale, technische und wirtschaftliche Weiterentwicklung unserer Gesellschaft dar.

    Or in English (unofficial translation):

    Therefore we demand that non-commercial copying, sharing, storing and use of works not only be legalized, but explicitly promoted to improve the overall availability of information, knowledge and culture, because this is a crucial prerequisite for the social, technical and economic development of our society.

    I think there's a few copyright holders who would choke on that one. Also they want to built open, anonymous wifi networks and absolve the ISPs of all liability = free file sharing in practice. They have a very broad political program compared to the Swedish party, but they are no less radical when it comes to copyright. I do hope hey pass the 5% barrier in the national election in 2013, then it could get real fun (they had 2% in 2009 - more than 3x what the Swedish PP managed in their national election...)

    --
    Live today, because you never know what tomorrow brings