Slashdot Mirror
Amazon Launching eBook Lending Program, Publishers Unenthusiastic
An anonymous reader writes "The Wall Street Journal reports that Amazon is starting a program to lend ebooks to Kindle users. It will allow users to borrow just one title at a time, but readers will be able to keep the borrowed ebook for as long as they want. The initial library will only have around 5,000 titles, because 'None of the six largest publishers in the U.S. is participating.' The article continues, 'Several senior publishing executives said recently they were concerned that a digital-lending program of the sort contemplated by Amazon would harm future sales of their older titles or damage ties to other book retailers. ... The new program, called Kindle Owners' Lending Library, cannot be accessed via apps on other devices, which means it won't work on Apple Inc.'s iPad or iPhone, even though people can read Kindle books on both devices. This restriction is intended to drive Kindle device sales, says Amazon.'"
No big publisher wants more to bring anything like a library back to life. Publishers had to have hated the fact that something like a library existed in the first place, and if digital publishing can wipe away libraries, you know they will be happy. A digital library is something that the publishers have to hate.
Yay, I have a sig.
Ebook lending is so dumb. It's a silly method to try and bring back the good ole days when people couldn't pirate your stuff because it was a big stack of dead tree. Now it's just some bits, and it's super easy to copy, so copy the hell out of it and sell it at a low price that reflects the ease with which it can be copied. I could pirate videogames, but instead I buy them on steam, because it's easier and better. They aren't just providing some alternative to piracy, they're providing a *better* alternative, and that's why I want to pay for it.
A nice organized ebook store with low prices that tracks what I've purchased is *better* than just pirating them and stashing them on a disk somewhere and loosing them all when that disk dies.
Publishers and people like amazon (amazon, to be fair, does an ok job already) need to think about what they can provide that is better than piracy. Ebook lending is not better than piracy, it's annoying and confusing and sucks.
Ze Atomic Device! It iz Ztolen!
Unlike Kindle Owners' Lending Library, brick-and-mortar libraries lend out physical goods and thus have no need to make an additional copy on the borrower's device. This is the key difference from publishers' point of view.
(In before whoosh)
Remember that libraries are not free, in fact you subsidize them with your property taxes (in the US, idk about other countries). Libraries are awesome, but they are not "free".
Slashdot is proof that Sturgeon's Law applies to mankind.
You get one free book rental a month with no due date if you're a member of prime.
If you read a lot and really quickly that probably won't be enough... if you're like me where you don't always have the time- this is about right and I'll read free classics in between.
eBooks are not cheap- they're bloody expensive for what they are. I got a kindle thinking it would save money- but the average new ebook is more expensive than the average paperback.
Lucky for me I like classics and older books just fine- most of which are free- if not from Kindle then from Gutenberg... Occassionally Kindle has special deals- 99cent books etc which include one or two newer books.
This won't be all books available for check-out, but apparantly will number in the thousands and include some new releases.
This might actually push me to Amazon prime- I've already considered it due to movies/tv shows and increased shipping. A book a month (if consider they're about $10 to $15 a pop if you buy the newer ebooks) makes prime even more usefull.
"That's the way to do it" - Punch
It looks like nypl offers epub format on some books (can't say if that's the case for all titles), which isn't Kindle specific. So other readers will work.
Anybody bother to find out what the AUTHORS think of this or do we just have the opinion of what is essentially the middlemen ?
Actually, I stand corrected. It's being bundled with the Amazon Prime service, which is $79 a year but comes with a host of other stuff. So it's not really free after all - more like a lagniappe.
Occasionally living proof of the Ballmer peak.