Slashdot Mirror
Ask Slashdot: Statistical Analysis Packages For Libraries?
HolyLime writes "I'm a librarian in a small academic library. Increasingly the administration is asking our department to collect data on various aspects of our activities, class taught, students helped, circulation, collection development, and so on. This is generating a large stream of data that is making it difficult, and time consuming, to qualitatively analyze. For anything complicated, I currently use excel, or an analogous spreadsheet program. I am aware of statistical analysis programs, like SPSS or SAS. Can anyone give me recommendations for statistical analysis programs? I also place emphasis on anything that is open source and easy to implement since it will allow me to bypass the convoluted purchase approval process."
R is my personal favorite but you're going to have to get down and dirty with some high level programming (scripting). Check out the data import package (you would probably export your spreadsheets to flat txt files and import although the functionality is ever increasing). There's no user interface in this suggestion ... what there is, however, is a massive collection of packages for statistical analysis. Very well maintained, constantly updated and ever expanding.
The other suggestion has a better GUI but is really heavyweight. WEKA has helped me time and time again perform advanced statistical calculations on data sets and it's in Java so runs on just about anything. Their interface occasionally improves too, they now have an explorer that I use to prep data and remove outliers/null data (don't worry, this isn't climate data). It's well documented.
These (probably) require an intermediate data transformation step but are open source and extensively supported. Any examples of what you wanted to do? Simple stuff like standard deviation or complex stuff like principle component analysis (PCA)? I guess if it was just simple stuff, that'd be built into Excel, right? Maybe your problems are simple enough to just need a good macro writer to tackle? Whatever happens, good luck!
My work here is dung.
Look at the free SPSS work-alike PSPP. http://www.gnu.org/software/pspp/ Sounds like R might be a bit much for your needs.
I also place emphasis on anything that is open source and easy to implement since it will allow me to bypass the convoluted purchase approval process.
Sorry to burst your bubble, but if you want good support and easy implementation, you have to look for normal paid-for solutions. Besides, open source is not synonym for free. This is especially true with specialized software or something you want good support for. Open source just means you get the code aswell, so you can implement your own additions (without use of plugins) or change it.
Your point may be valid. But what would really help your validity is mentioning some proprietary products that beat R and WEKA at their own game. Sure, I've used Matlab and it can't be beat in some respects and is heavily supported. But to suggest that just because it effortlessly interfaces with Excel spreadsheets when the person could get by with a simple export in Excel to run their R script on the resulting files? Not worth the cash, in my opinion. I don't go out and buy every piece of software to evaluate it, though. I'm aware of Matlab and Mathematica and have used them quite a bit ... but I still prefer R and WEKA. So, CmdrPony, go ahead and list all the proprietary point-and-click-omg-it-just-works software for our friend here. We're all waiting.
But unless you get an product from a company that is spending money to develop it, you never get good software and good support.
Say, friendo, have you ever heard of Linux? Eclipse? Audacity? PostGRES? VLC?
No one can make both because everything in this world costs money, and developers have to live too. Open source and free software model works well for the likes of Google and Firefox because the developments get paid by money made with advertising. Statistical analysis software, and other specialized software is a different matter.
Can you tell me what advertising model is employed to funnel money through Firefox into Google? I mean, Google makes a competing product called Chrome -- the rendering engines are even different! What in the world are you free basing?
My work here is dung.
Excel and other spreadsheets suck at stats:
* Burns, P. (2005). Spreadsheet Addiction.
* Cryer, J. (2001). Problems with using Microsoft Excel for StatisticsPDF.
* Pottel, H. (n.d.). Statistical flaws in Excel. PDF
* Practical Stats (n.d.), Is Microsoft Excel an Adequate Statistics Package?
* Heiser, D. (2008). Errors, faults and fixes for Excel statistical functions and routines
For a more comprehensive and technical discussion, see the papers by Yu (2008); Yalta (2008); and McCullough & Heiser in Computational Statistics and Data Analysis 52(10).
I will echo the support for the open-source statistics package R. R is incredibly powerful, and in the natural sciences it is fast becoming the standard statistics software.
I will also echo the sentiment that, by itself, R is fairly low-level and typically requires at least some simple programming to get what you want.
However, there is a very nice graphical front end for R called RKWard (http://rkward.sourceforge.net/). With RKWard, importing and exporting data, running basic analyses on it (descriptive statistics, linear regression, t-tests, etc.), and producing basic graphs is very straightforward and does not require detailed knowledge of the R language. Plus, RKWard is also a nice development environment for writing R code, so if you want to take your project further, you can easily do so. So, I'd recommend giving RKWard + R a look.