Slashdot Mirror
Battery Turns Saltwater Into Drinking Water
An anonymous reader writes "German researchers have developed a battery that can remove sodium and chloride ions from seawater. In theory, their invention could be far more energy efficient than thermal desalination or reverse osmosis. This would cut the cost of using salt water for drinking or irrigation. It could also be used to make compact desalination systems for boats and life rafts, or crops. Each battery is made with manganese oxide nanorod electrodes, which absorb sodium when an electrical current passes through them. When the current is reversed, they dump the sodium ions out into waste water."
Not sure what math they're using when 50% removal of ions is considered "de-salinated". I guess they're getting there, so by publishing this article, maybe they'll be able to snag some venture capital?
They call it a battery because it is a series of electrical cells. The term "battery" means the series arrangement; it comes from a military term for a series of guns. Generating electricity is the best-known use of an electrical battery, but isn't the definition.
Of course, (good) reverse osmosis cleans out a LOT more out of the water then just salt, e.g. bacteria, viruses.
Batteries don't generate energy. They store it, chemically. (Well, the ones we usually think of as "batteries" work chemically.)
Nonetheless, I don't know how they propose to be more energy efficient than a mirror-based distillation rig. Besides keeping the parabola aimed at the sun, which requires negligible energy, the main costs of running such a rig are keeping it supplied with water to distill and flushing it out with solvent once in a while to prevent salt buildup. (You can even use filtered seawater for the solvent.) The latter costs seem unavoidable for electrical-cell-based desalination, and the former is, as I said, negligible.
Of course, it only works in parts of the world that get a lot of sunshine, so for example it would be a non-starter in northern Ohio. (Not that we need desalination in Ohio. Most of our water management issues involve finding ways to get the water to drain away more efficiently so it doesn't flood our basements; that seems likely to be common in places that don't get enough sunshine to boil water with a parabolic mirror... but I suppose there could be exceptions.)
Cut that out, or I will ship you to Norilsk in a box.
Interesting, but how much energy does it take to run this thing? (they call it a 'battery', but I don't think it actually generates electricity).
Re-read TFA. They came up with this desalination gizmo by reversing another gizmo that does create electrical energy.
I think this's brilliant thinking. They didn't just read the paper. They read it, understood its implications, and extrapolated them in the opposite direction. That's what I expect from scientists. I wish I saw that kind of thinking more often.
As for this gizmo, I'd like to see it built as a group of looping boxes, progressively yielding purer product as it goes through them in sequence. Add other boxes in the chain to filter out other stuff that this gizmo doesn't filter, and you end up with an office water-cooler machine that produces pure water and recyclable sludge. I'd definitely buy one!
"Tongue tied and twisted, just an Earth bound misfit
Please do. Help End the Dumb First Post meme.
(Dr. Emmett Brown) "According to my calculations, the nature of the First Post directly influences the quality of the entire thread. When a really good First Post is made, the quality of the thread increases between 25-75%, because in most neutral (non flame bait) stories, once the "famous first slot" is taken, and then there are some five to seven good replies, trolls don't bother as much with low grade slots down farther in the chain. The improvements to the quality include a 20% drop in "Slashdot sux" comments too.
(/Dr. Emmett Brown)
Say what you like about those awesome back to the future movies, Doc Brown was awesome because his math was almost never wrong.
My first Journal Entry ever, in 8 years! http://slashdot.org/journal/365947/aphelion-scifi-fantasy-horror-poetry-webzine
From the abstract: "Here, we demonstrate an energy consumption of 0.29 Wh lâ"1 for the removal of 25% salt using this novel desalination battery, which is promising when compared to reverse osmosis ( 0.2 Wh lâ"1), the most efficient technique presently available."
I think they already have RO filters with hand pumps that would fit that niche.
As with " battery hens", few readers will know what "battery" means in that context.
Cannon artillery analogies are as obsolete as ballista analogies.
"This post is an artistic work of fiction and falsehood. Only a fool would take anything posted here as fact."
I remember in the '90s the Innovations catalogue sold inflatable thermal desalination rafts. You inflated them and they floated on the sea concentrating sunlight on the surface like a greenhouse. The water evaporated and then condensed on the inside of the glass and trickled out into the edges. They produced about 2 pints of water per day and were intended to be kept on life rafts (they couldn't operate on them, but they could float beside them and work, as long as there was sunshine). I presume they haven't stopped existing in the last 15 years...
I am TheRaven on Soylent News
Very pure water is bad for you, as it leeches good minerals out of your cells (reverse reverse osmosis, if I'm not mistaken aka osmosis). If your desalination does too good a job, you have to "cut" that water with impure water.
Actually, the authors call it a battery in their paper. And it is.
Here's the salient part of the paper:
In this work, we demonstrate a novel electrochemical cell named a “mixing entropy battery”, which extracts energy from the difference in concentration of two solutions and stores it as chemical energy inside the electrode material’s bulk crystal structure. This approach allows us to overcome the challenges of supercapacitor electrodes based on activated carbon. This device consists of a reversible electrochemical system where the salts in the electrolyte are the reactants and the electrode stores ions. We employed two different electrodes: an anionic electrode, which interacts with Cl ions selectively; and a cationic electrode, which interacts with Na+ ions selectively. These electrodes are initially submerged in a low ionic strength solution (river water) in their discharged states, when the electrode materials contain the respective ions incorporated in their structures. In this dilute solution, the battery is charged by removing the Na+ and Cl ions from the respective electrodes (Figure 1a, step 1). Successively, the dilute electrolyte is exchanged for a concentrated solution (seawater), which is accompanied by an increase in the potential difference between the electrodes (Figure 1a, step 2). At this higher potential difference, the battery is discharged, as the anions and cations are reincorporated into their respective electrodes (Figure 1a, step 3). The concentrated solution is then removed and substituted by the dilute electrolyte (river water), which results in a decrease in potential difference between the electrodes (Figure 1a, step 4). We note that the exchange of solution could also be carried out via a flow process, which could be attractive for large scale energy extraction.
My sister opened a computer store in Hawaii. She sells C shells by the seashore.
Seriously?
We already do utilize the water that falls from the sky, you know those river things that run into the ocean and most communities were built around?
Water is finite, even that magic skywater. Upstream communities cannot take all the water they want, as downstream communities rely on the same water source. Desalinization technologies not only allow coastal communities to grow where there isn't a major river, but also frees up water for greater upstream use.
I don't suffer from insanity, I enjoy every minute of it!
A report reviewing some of the research as of 1980: Health Risks from Drinking Demineralised Water.
http://www.landfallnavigation.com/memss.html
Just the other day it was discovered water magically evaporates thru sheets of graphene about as fast as you can pour.
Kind of makes it difficult to see the point of experiments involving basic chemistry with lousy effeciency falling off a cliff as concentration of salt is reduced.