Slashdot Mirror
California Considers DNA Privacy Law
ananyo writes "California lawmakers are weighing a bill aimed at protecting their state's citizens from surreptitious genetic testing but scientists are voicing their growing concerns that, if passed, such a law would have a costly and damaging effect on research. The bill, dubbed the Genetic Information Privacy Act, would require an individual's written consent for the collection, analysis, retention, and sharing of his or her genetic information—including DNA, genetic test results, and even family disease history. The University of California has submitted a formal letter objecting to the bill, estimating that the measure could increase administrative costs by up to $594,000 annually — money which would come out of the cash-strapped state's General Fund. The university has also expressed concern that its researchers would suffer competitive losses in obtaining research grants."
They should go one further and replace "uniquely identifying" DNA testing of criminal suspects with "just enough DNA to exclude the suspect" tests, repeated as needed with different parts of the DNA until the suspect is cleared or it's really his DNA.
Instead of testing a few dozen markers all at once and keeping that data on file, test only one or two. If it's a match, test another marker or two, and so on. Stop and cut the guy loose as soon as you find a mis-match.
Not only is this more morally justifiable than taking a full DNA "fingerprint," it will cut down on people who object to having DNA taken because they either know or believe they have left DNA at a place where a crime occurred in the past (even if they didn't commit any crimes) or they believe they are likely to do so in the future.
Also, change arrest-expunction laws for those who aren't convicted so that once the case is closed OR once it's obvious that the state isn't still looking at a given suspect, his DNA, fingerprints, etc. are automatically destroyed, without the former suspect having to hire a lawyer or pay fees to make it happen.
Knowledge is how to play a game, intelligence is how to win, wisdom is knowing what game to play.
It's just a consent form. Make sure it assigns the right to use your genetic information for any research purpose you like, publish it, exchange it with others, etc. etc. Get your subjects to sign it and stuff it in a file cabinet. Done.
Is there an exception for law enforcement?
Yeah. I'm sure I echo the family of Henrietta Lacks when I say 'Fuck 'em.'