Slashdot Mirror


Patent and Copyright Wars Gone Wild

snydeq writes "While Apple and Samsung fight over patents and prototypes, other copyright trolls are waging an X-rated battle on innocent users, as lawyers representing some adult movie companies are sending letters accusing users of illegally downloading their movies and saying that, for a price, they can make the charges go away. 'Cases like this, usually involving pornographic content, are very common,' Mitch Stoltz, a staff attorney for the Electronic Frontier Foundation said. At least 250,000 individuals have been named in group lawsuits over the last few years. There's a very common belief that if someone pirates your Wi-Fi connection or uses your computer without your permission, you are responsible for illegal downloads of copyrighted material. That's not true, says Stoltz; the law is quite clear. However, the lawyers who bring those cases use that misperception to convince innocent people that they had better pay up. Since $3,500 is just a fraction of the money it would take to fight a case in court, most people simply settle."

7 of 197 comments (clear)

  1. Dear Proprietarians and Patent Trolls by Ralph+Spoilsport · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Fuck You.

    --
    Shoes for Industry. Shoes for the Dead.
    1. Re:Dear Proprietarians and Patent Trolls by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Insightful

      Why, yes. Yes we can.

    2. Re:Dear Proprietarians and Patent Trolls by drooling-dog · · Score: 5, Insightful

      Absolutely we can. The "system" didn't appear out of nowhere from pure intentions. It was designed, bought and paid for by the very interests that are now abusing it for profit. It's how politics works now.

    3. Re:Dear Proprietarians and Patent Trolls by ldobehardcore · · Score: 5, Funny

      Cthulu 2012: Why Settle For A Lesser Evil?

      --
      Hectice, baby, Mercator says hello to you
  2. Re:Plus, there's the embarrassment factor by Gaygirlie · · Score: 5, Funny

    I wouldn't mind. Everyone knows I'm a regular, old perv, it'd just earn me some street-cred.

  3. Stonewall or Fight! by grot · · Score: 5, Informative

    IAAL, and I've worked on a bunch of these cases. The real problem is, it's almost always cheaper to settle than to fight. This is what we call a "cost of defense" shakedown: if it would cost $5k to fight, then it makes sense to pay $3k to make it go away. However, there are a few things to keep in mind:

    * The trolls are very unlikely to go after any individual, no matter how much they huff and puff. The reason is, if they have 1000 Does in a complaint, and they start going against one of them, that Doe will (eventually) get copies of the evidence against him. If it's sh!t (and I believe it will probably turn out to be) then the other 999 Does will see that, and no longer be willing to pay.

    * The insurance industry had a problem with cost-of-defense complaints: crappy auto accidents that weren't worth more than a few grand in damages. But they banded together and fought every single one of them (paying just the actual damages & medical, and fighting almost every "pain & suffering" claim). And now, you can hardly find a PI lawyer to take a small case -- they know there's no money in it. So the insurance companies don't have to fight any more, and they don't even consider paying anything you can't produce a receipt for.

    The only way to clean up these trolls is if some Does sack up and fight, or if the courts stop going along with the shakedown.

  4. Re:Plus, there's the embarrassment factor by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Insightful

    You know this may finally be just the impetus that we need to come out into the open....

    I too am a pervert.

    That felt good to get off my chest :)

    It's funny, lately I had a friend confess to me he was in deep shit with his girlfriend over an alleged "porn addiction" because he got caught surfing porn. I told him every man is addicted to porn. There is no such thing as "porn addiction", the truth is, there is masturbation addiction. As long as you are not chaffing, or getting pulled over, or distracted by sounds of people in the park, or unable to keep a job, you are just fine.

    Women... you are full of shit. All of you are reading your versions of porn right now. It's called Fifty Shades of Wet Vagina.

    We don't have anything to hide guys. Don't let these assclown lawyers bully you into submission. Stand up! Be Proud!

    I MASTURBATE TO PORN ON THE INTERNET!

    Where's our fucking parade?

    submitted anonymously because I don't want anybody to see I wrote this.. especially the you-know-who