Slashdot Mirror


Confessions of a Left-Handed Technology User

harrymcc writes "Over at TIME.com, I wrote about my trials and tribulations as a left-handed person who uses technology products. An awful lot of them have clearly been designed with the right-handed majority in mind, even when they claimed they weren't. But the good news is that modern smartphones and tablets are very lefty-friendly compared to the devices that preceded them."

27 of 267 comments (clear)

  1. Microsoft logo needs an update by Bill+Dimm · · Score: 2

    The Microsoft logo used for this story is outdated.

    1. Re:Microsoft logo needs an update by asmkm22 · · Score: 2

      They need to bring back the Bill Gates Borg logo.

    2. Re:Microsoft logo needs an update by tiffany352 · · Score: 2

      I say it should be replaced with a Steve Ballmer Borg logo.

  2. Silly by andy16666 · · Score: 5, Interesting

    As a life long lefty, I can honestly say I've never felt the need to complain because a piece of technology isn't designed for me. I don't find any technology gadget I own to be designed in such a way so as to impede my usage of it.

    I do know lefties who complain constantly about the injustice afforded them, but to be honest I've never been able to empathize with them.

    1. Re:Silly by neminem · · Score: 2

      Do you count scissors or pens as technology? Cause, as a left-handed person, those are annoying. But I've never had a problem with a phone, laptop, keyboard or printer. I've always used a mouse right-handed, though - I write left-handed, but I'd feel weird putting a mouse in that hand.

    2. Re:Silly by John+Napkintosh · · Score: 3, Funny

      You should suggest that they get together and open a store filled with products which cater to the left-handed people to address this persecution. Some sort of emporium of left-handedness. A leftorium, if you will.

      --

      Long signatures suck.
    3. Re:Silly by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Funny

      I'm left-handed and have always used a right-handed mouse or trackball.

      This. As a lefty, I can not for the life of me understand how righties mouse and fap at the same time.

    4. Re:Silly by Antipater · · Score: 2

      This. Also, fancy fountain pens draw lines of different thickness depending on their angle - a thicker line when moving up and down, a thinner one when moving sideways. The angle of pen to paper for a lefty is 90 degrees different from a righty; that means that anything that would be a thick line when written by a righty is a thin line for a lefty and vice versa. It's not an issue for normal stuff, but if you ever look at calligraphy written by a lefty it just looks - odd. Backwards.

      --
      Everything is better with chainsaws.
    5. Re:Silly by Steauengeglase · · Score: 2

      This, the DS was probably the worst offender. How am I supposed to use the control pad and write at the same time? It was easier to lay the thing on the table, direct the D-pad with my pinkie and write with the same hand. Definitely a design flaw.

      Other than that, guns and guitars are the only things that give me problems, keyboards and mice, not so much. Actually I think southpaws may come out a little ahead. Few people draw with a mouse, so it leave you with an advantage when picking out keys and navigating.

    6. Re:Silly by realityimpaired · · Score: 3, Interesting

      Well, what's your definition of left-handed? We should start by discussing this. For most people it's "people who WRITE with the left hand" even if you do everything else with the right one.

      Depends... I'm left-dominant, but I write with my right hand. According to my parents, I used my left until I reached grade school, and then switched to the right in order to fit in, because nobody else was using their left and I was being teased. Sports, however, I play left in hockey, soccer, baseball, and golf, and when I train in Jiu Jitsu, I practice both sides equally. I *can* write with my left hand in English (my native language) or French (which I learned to write concurrently with English), but it looks like it was written by a 6-year old. Interestingly, with alphabets I learned later in life, like Japanese, I can use either hand, and usually pick which hand I'm going to write with based on whether I'm writing right-to-left, or left-to-right in order to avoid smudging the ink.

      Does that make me ambidextrous, left-handed, or right-handed?

      (and technology-wise, I don't really care... I have a right-handed trackball mouse right now, so my workstation is set up in a right-handed configuration, but my uncle has his set up left-handed, and I can use it without needing to think much).

    7. Re:Silly by NotSanguine · · Score: 2

      As a lefty, the only things that really annoy me are clipboards and wristwatches. Both are purposely designed for righties. As for the mouse, I'm so used to the "righty" button locations that I don't even think about it. I tried switching the buttons a few times, but it just annoyed me.

      All that said, this isn't exactly a news flash..."We interrupt your regular programming to bring you a special news bulletin: because most people are right-handed, the left-handed are sometimes minorly inconvenienced. Film at eleven." Please!

      --
      No, no, you're not thinking; you're just being logical. --Niels Bohr
  3. Re:First World Problem Here by mr1911 · · Score: 5, Funny

    You should really lock your PC when you walk away. Someone just trolled you and made you look like a complete jackass.

    --
    This post comes with a double-your-money-back guarantee!
    Any offense taken to this post is at your sole discretion.
  4. What's the big deal? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Interesting

    I'm left-handed and I seriously don't see all of the life-challenges that are moaned about in this article and others, whether they concern technology or not. I'm pretty convinced that life as a left-hander is no harder than it would be if I were right-handed.

  5. Re:First World Problem Here by somersault · · Score: 4, Interesting

    I'm left handed, but I've never had an issue using mice or trackpads right handed. After a little test right now it seems I also use my right hand more often when using a tablet or smartphone - probably because of the mouse thing.

    Random facts that perhaps nobody cares about: I play baseball, golf and hockey with a right handed orientation, but racket games like tennis and badminton left handed. I am more comfortable brushing my teeth and shaving with my left hand, but have recently been occasionally practice with my right just for fun. When I was a kid, I broke my left wrist and so was forced to learn to write, eat etc, with my right hand for a while. It's fun to practice being ambidextrous.

    --
    which is totally what she said
  6. CD Jewel cases by ehud42 · · Score: 4, Interesting

    Other than smudging the ink from those awful erasable pens, I never payed much attention to products working or not working for us lefties, until CD's came along. Actually, it wasn't until I watched my right handed friend struggle to open a CD case. Somehow he was awkwardly trying to pry the front open with his right hand, which between the case swinging open against the natural movement of the right arm, and somehow gripping the edges of the lid with his left hand as he held the back, was quite entertaining.

    For me it was natural to hold the back with my right hand (hinge side on my middle fingers, other side on my thumb) and then grab the front with my left hand (fingers/thumb along top and bottom). The case just opened beautifully.

    It is the only tech device I can think of that worked better for us lefties from day one.

    --
    I'm in my right mind and I have the answer to everything!
    1. Re:CD Jewel cases by Kozz · · Score: 2

      For me it was natural to hold the back with my right hand (hinge side on my middle fingers, other side on my thumb) and then grab the front with my left hand (fingers/thumb along top and bottom). The case just opened beautifully.

      Aside from the fact that CD jewel cases aren't very well designed... I'm right-handed and open CDs exactly the same way you do. My "handedness" never occurred to me while using them.

      Does your right-handed friend also open the cover of books across his body with his right hand?

      --
      I only post comments when someone on the internet is wrong.
    2. Re:CD Jewel cases by mcgrew · · Score: 2

      Your friend is neither intelligent nor dextrous. Lacking dexterity all he would have to do to open it "right handed" would be to turn it upside down. He also is probably aliterate or illiterate, since CDs open the same way books do.

  7. Re:I'm a lefty by John+Napkintosh · · Score: 4, Interesting

    As a lefty, I always thought it was a good thing that the mouse is on the right. Mousing isn't something that requires incredible accuracy, and the accuracy it does require is easily learned in a rather small amount of time, so long as my hand was compatible with the ergonomics of the mouse, I was in good shape. And it freed up my left hand for combination keystrokes and shortcuts and one-handed typing, which definitely requires more deliberate movements and precision than right-handed mousing does for a lefty.

    --

    Long signatures suck.
  8. Going a bit too far by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Insightful

    One of the photo captions: "Steve Jobs claimed to be ambidextrous, but as this 1981 photo shows, he wore his watch on his left hand -- a tattletale sign of right-handedness"

    Really?! On which hand is an ambidextrous person supposed to wear a watch?

    1. Re:Going a bit too far by Quirkz · · Score: 2

      The other other hand, I suppose.

  9. Re:First World Problem Here by Quirkz · · Score: 5, Interesting

    I will acknowledge your obscure facts and respond with my own. I'm a righty, but I deal cards left handed because I was taught by my mother, who is a lefty. You might say that makes sense, except she deals like a righty, and when I learned I properly mirror-imaged her teaching like I did with everything else she showed me. I guess we just both share a family proclivity for dealing cards backwards.

    I also learned to mouse lefty when I started suffering carpal tunnel effects. I have gotten some very weird reactions from people trying to use my desk, including an absurd number of "oh! I didn't know you were left handed!" comments from people who have no reason to know or care what my primary hand is, but suddenly seemed to think it was a big deal. I've had a couple of other visitors actually move the mouse over to the right side of the keyboard, despite the fact they were standing and only needed to use the mouse for a few seconds (easily could have just used the mouse where it was) and one person who went so far as to comment as he moved it "you've got the mouse on the wrong side" like I didn't know where I'd left it.

  10. "Right" Side of the Road by CanEHdian · · Score: 2

    This is exactly how I am explaining to everyone what the 'ideal' (so it won't be confusing) side of the road is to drive on:

    Assumptions:
    1. There are two side-by-side seats in front, with a center console for instrumentation.
    2. One sits on the opposite side of the side of the road one drives on (e.g. drive on the right, sit on the left).
    3. Drivers prefer to use their dominant hand for tasks that require the most precise motor control.

    Argument:
    Since the console, which holds the gear shift, climate control, GPS, stereo, etc. is in the centre, it depends on what the dominant hand is for the majority of the population. If that happens to be the right hand, the console should be to the right of the driver, hence the driver is sitting in the left seat. With assumption 2 that follows the car should drive on the right-hand side of the road.

    Lefties can rejoyce themselves in thinking what it would be like for a right-handed person to learn to drive with a standard stick-shift over in the UK.

    --
    When the copyright term is "forever minus a day", live every day like it's the last.
    1. Re:"Right" Side of the Road by SleazyRidr · · Score: 2

      You can always tell when I've just switched countries: I tell people that I like a clear windscreen before I go around a corner, and when it starts to rain I want the blinker on so my car is easier to see.

  11. "You're holding it wrong" by PPalmgren · · Score: 2

    Most recent example of a hand bias that hit major headlines. While I doubt Apple made this mistake by using only right-handed testers and it likely had more to do with minimal testing in poor signal areas, this problem manifested more frequently with the way a lefty held their phone.

  12. Re:First World Problem Here by somersault · · Score: 2

    Oh yeah, I also play guitar right handed. I actually think this probably gives a benefit to dexterity on the fingerboard, which requires more spacial coordination than simply choosing which string to pluck. So I'm not sure why left handers even want to play using the opposite orientation - especially given that this means you can't just pick up any old guitar at someone's house and play.

    --
    which is totally what she said
  13. Confessions of a right-handed user by subreality · · Score: 2

    A few years ago I started setting my desk up lefty: keyboard on the right, mouse on the left. This means that the QWERTY section is dead center and that reaching over to the mouse is a much shorter distance. My typing speed is up considerably and my right wrist no longer bends at a weird angle.

    Retraining to mouse left-handed was easy. It took a few days of being a fumbling klutz but now it's completely natural. Having to buy ambidextrous mice really limits your options though.

    You lefties DO NOT want a lefty keyboard. That just gets you back to the same dysfunction that I had to escape. I want a lefty keyboard. Does anyone know of a lefty keyboard with light clicky keyswitches (Cherry MX Blues are perfect)?

  14. Re:Which side of keyboard you put the mouse? by HornWumpus · · Score: 2

    You are apparently a one handed typer. Comes from fapping so much.

    --
    John McAfee 'It was like that time I hired that Bangkok prostitute; to do my taxes, while I fucked my accountant'