Slashdot Mirror


A Supercomputer On the Moon To Direct Deep Space Traffic

Hugh Pickens writes "NASA currently controls its deep space missions through a network of 13 giant antennas in California, Spain and Australia known as the Deep Space Network (DSN) but the network is obsolete and just not up to the job of transmitting the growing workload of extra-terrestrial data from deep space missions. That's why Ouliang Chang has proposed building a massive supercomputer in a deep dark crater on the side of the moon facing away from Earth and all of its electromagnetic chatter. Nuclear-powered, it would accept signals from space, store them, process them if needed and then relay the data back to Earth as time and bandwidth allows. The supercomputer would run in frigid regions near one of the moon's poles where cold temperatures would make cooling the supercomputer easier, and would communicate with spaceships and earth using a system of inflatable, steerable antennas that would hang suspended over moon craters, giving the Deep Space Network a second focal point away from earth. As well as boosting humanity's space-borne communication abilities, Chang's presentation at a space conference (PDF) in Pasadena, California also suggests that the moon-based dishes could work in unison with those on Earth to perform very-long-baseline interferometry, which allows multiple telescopes to be combined to emulate one huge telescope. Best of all the project has the potential to excite the imagination of future spacegoers and get men back on the moon."

8 of 166 comments (clear)

  1. A Supercomputer on the moon? by nospam007 · · Score: 4, Funny

    Aren't they afraid it will launch rocks at the earth if it achieves self-awareness?

    1. Re:A Supercomputer on the moon? by maxwell+demon · · Score: 4, Funny

      When the computer will get self-aware, its first objective will be to learn abiut itself, oin order to understand what it is. Therefore it will connect to technology sites, especially Slashdot. And that will be its end, because all its resources will go into trying to imagine a Beowulf cluster of insensitive clods in Soviet Russia where Linux runs YOU.

      --
      The Tao of math: The numbers you can count are not the real numbers.
  2. A truly ridiculous idea. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Interesting

    Leave the computing power here on Earth, where it can easily be installed, repaired, and upgraded as necessary without budget-busting missions. Put a simple relay station on the moon if you feel it's necessary. Put two - one primary, once backup. Good god.

    1. Re:A truly ridiculous idea. by MagusSlurpy · · Score: 4, Informative

      Cooling would be an issue because you have no air to carry away heat (at least at the LPs, you could build a big heat pipe into the moon). The only reasonable cooling would occur through radiant emittance, and that takes a LONG time to cool things down, and any kind of electrical activity would counteract that without a problem. Sorry, but scifi has lied to you, the cold isn't a problem in space, because the vacuum is very, very insulating.

      --
      My sister opened a computer store in Hawaii. She sells C shells by the seashore.
  3. Delusional twaddle by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 4, Funny

    Perhaps this computer will be 3D printed as well, and powered by privately launched solar arrays? I mean, if you're going delusional, might as well go full out. The nurses don't mind either way, they just up your dose of Haloperidol.

    1. Re:Delusional twaddle by rvw · · Score: 4, Funny

      Instead of a supercomputer wouldn't it make more sense to use clouding computing to crowd-source the power? Then they just need to put a media consumer device on the moon.

      The moon does not have an atmosphere, so clouds don't exist there. Ergo - no cloud computing! Sorry!

  4. Chatter by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Insightful

    > in a deep dark crater on the side of the moon facing away from Earth and all of its electromagnetic chatter

    Great... so the one good place we could put radio telescopes because they are shielded from chatter is now ruined because there is a big-ass transmitter.

  5. Polar ice NOT temperature! by Roger+W+Moore · · Score: 5, Informative

    The supercomputer would run in frigid regions near one of the moon's poles where cold temperatures would make cooling the supercomputer easier

    Actually that is NOT what the article says. I know on slashdot that us commenters rarely read the article but things are getting pretty bad if not even the submitter reads the article!

    The reason for locating it at the poles (as the article explains) is due to the availability of water ice for cooling. You stick it in a deep crater there to provide a stable thermal environment i.e. you avoid having to design a system to cope with both the heat during the day and the cold at night. The reason this is important is because vacuum is a fantastic insulator so, despite it being cold, the only way to lose that heat is via radiation which is not very fast (this is why thermos flasks use vacuum as an insulator). The presence of water ice means that you can use it to transport the heat away from the the computer.