Slashdot Mirror


Massachusetts May Soon Change How the Nation Dies

Hugh Pickens writes "Lewis M. Cohen reports that this Election Day, Massachusetts is poised to approve the Death With Dignity Act, a modernized, sanitized, politically palatable term that replaces the now-antiquated expression 'physician-assisted suicide.' Oregon's Death With Dignity Act has been in effect for the past 14 years, and the state of Washington followed suit with a similar law in 2008. But the Massachusetts ballot question has the potential to turn death with dignity from a legislative experiment into the new national norm, because the state is the home of America's leading medical publication (the New England Journal of Medicine), hospital (Massachusetts General), and four medical schools (Harvard, Boston University, University of Massachusetts, and Tufts). If the act passes in Massachusetts, other states that have previously had unsuccessful campaigns will certainly be emboldened to revisit this subject. The initiative would allow terminally ill patients with six months or less to live to request from their doctor a prescription for a lethal dose of a drug. Doctors do not have to offer the option at all, and patients must make three requests, two verbal and one written. They must self-administer the drug, which would be ingested. The patients must be deemed capable of making an informed decision. 'It's all about choice,' says George Eighmey, a key player in instituting the Oregon law, defending it against repeal and shepherding it into reality. 'You decide. No one else can decide for you. No can can force you into it, coerce you into it or even suggest it to you unless you make a statement: "I don't want to live like this any more" or "I'm interested in that law out there, doctor, can you give me something to alleviate this pain and suffering."'"

6 of 439 comments (clear)

  1. Re:Question: by mcgrew · · Score: -1, Troll

    Is it really that difficult to acquire a lethal dose of a drug without doctor assistance?

    You said "no", I call bullshit. You can overdose from alcohol; people do it all the time. They call it "alcohol poisoning." Others overdose on heroin and other opiates. Others, barbituates. In fact, almost every "downer" drug can be lethal, even the over-the-counter drugs like alcohol.

    You got the second question right, though.

  2. Stupid Law by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0, Troll

    This is idiotic. People figure this out all the time, they don't need gov't to help them.

    Next, we'll have ObamaCare demanding that the Catholics offer this option.

  3. killing by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0, Troll

    why are liberals always trying to kill people? the unborn, the elderly, the sick....
    very strange indeed...

  4. Why not? It worked so well in Germany in 1939 by Andy+Prough · · Score: -1, Troll

    Germans needed the "right to die", and were given "mercy killings" beginning with the parent-approved (and Hitler-approved) death of blind, limbless, convulsing infant Gerhard Kretschmar in July, 1939. How easily we forget that this led to 300,000 "mercy killings" of physically disabled and psychiatric patients (including thousands of children and elderly nursing home residents). The patients were selected by their kindly physicians and psychiatrists for death, and this program was actually the precursor to the mass killings of the Jewish concentration camp prisoners. I highly recommend that you DO NOT read the fascinating chapter on the Nazi killing of disabled children, "The Geranium in the Window", in Fredric Wertham's omnibus review of human violence, "A Sign for Cain" (http://www.amazon.com/Sign-Cain-Exploration-Human-Violence/dp/0026259702). It will give you nightmares for decades.

    1. Re:Why not? It worked so well in Germany in 1939 by Andy+Prough · · Score: -1, Troll

      Choosing to kill yourself and killing others is quite different. If you cannot see that you are beyond help.

      Exactly how it was sold to the German people. Clinging to dogmatic beliefs about euthenasia won't save you from the wolves who would gladly use it against you to grab your property - precisely what the Nazi's were using it for.

  5. Re:Death with Dignity. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0, Troll

    Imagine that I'm paralyzed down half my body, can't breath without oxygen,

    Imagine that you can't even spell the word breathe.