Slashdot Mirror


Britain Suspends Exploratory Drilling of Antarctic Lake

A British plan to blast a path through more than two miles of ice to reach an Antarctic lake has been suspended because of technical problems. From the article: "In a move that clears the way for U.S. and Russian teams to take the lead, Professor Martin Siegert said technical problems and a lack of fuel had forced the closure on Christmas Day of the 7-million-pound ($11 million) project, which was looking for life forms and climate change clues in the lake-bed sediment. 'This is of course, hugely frustrating for us, but we have learned a lot this year,' said Siegert of the University of Bristol, principal investigator for the mission, which was headed by the British Antarctic Survey (BAS). 'By the end, the equipment was working well, and much of it has now been fully field-tested,' he said on the BAS website."

20 of 37 comments (clear)

  1. Re:Now that the equipment has been shown to work.. by Fusselwurm · · Score: 4, Insightful

    abandoning != suspending

  2. Re:Now that the equipment has been shown to work.. by squidtron · · Score: 1

    They say it will be unique per lake maybe true maybe not we shall see

  3. Triple Redundancy by mutantSushi · · Score: 2, Insightful

    Given that one of the major controversies here is the danger of contamination of the lake (both for negating the scientific value, and the lake ecosystem itself)... Isn't the pursuance of 3 independent, parallel drilling projects solely in the name of national egos, a minor outrage?

    1. Re:Triple Redundancy by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

      They are drilling into different lakes...

    2. Re:Triple Redundancy by DerekLyons · · Score: 1

      Given that the lakes have not only been isolated from the rest of the terrestrial environment for eons, and from each other... no, it's not a minor outrage. It's good science to see how evolution has proceeded in each and how they are different from one another.

      Don't mistake the media's preoccupation with "firsts" for the reasons behind the drilling.

  4. What a crappy article by TubeSteak · · Score: 1

    The British scientists decided to abandon the mission after trying for 20 hours to connect two holes in the ice that were needed for the hot-water drill to work, said a BAS spokeswoman.

    Without a connection between the two holes, the hot water would seep into the porous surface layers of ice and be lost, reducing the pressure and rendering the drill ineffective

    I RTFA and all I can say is "Huh?"

    --
    [Fuck Beta]
    o0t!
    1. Re:What a crappy article by jandar · · Score: 1

      The British scientists decided to abandon the mission after trying for 20 hours to connect two holes in the ice that were needed for the hot-water drill to work, said a BAS spokeswoman.

      Without a connection between the two holes, the hot water would seep into the porous surface layers of ice and be lost, reducing the pressure and rendering the drill ineffective

      I RTFA and all I can say is "Huh?"

      The next sentence explains it, they have not enough water in reserve to compensate:

      The team tried to melt and dig more snow to compensate for the water loss, but without success.

    2. Re:What a crappy article by Sulphur · · Score: 1

      The British scientists decided to abandon the mission after trying for 20 hours to connect two holes in the ice that were needed for the hot-water drill to work, said a BAS spokeswoman.

      Without a connection between the two holes, the hot water would seep into the porous surface layers of ice and be lost, reducing the pressure and rendering the drill ineffective

      I RTFA and all I can say is "Huh?"

      A case of hole overrun. They tried to sink 7 million pounds and couldn't ... oh wait, they could.

  5. Re:If you want to manufacture something right, by Taco+Cowboy · · Score: 3, Funny

    The Germans would give you a highly sophisticated hole, while China would copy that hole and sell millions of cheap holes in the market

    --
    Muchas Gracias, Señor Edward Snowden !
  6. Re:Let me guess by CodeheadUK · · Score: 1, Funny

    Taking flamethowers on a scientific jaunt just isn't cricket old boy.

  7. Re:Let me guess by ankhank · · Score: 2

    > What do you expect ....?

    "... They're afloat in a bubble of pressurized air wedged against the underside of the Antarctic ice sheet: below them stretch the still, supercooled waters of Lake Vostok.
    They're waiting for a rendezvous...."

    A Colder War
    a novelette by Charles Stross
    http://www.infinityplus.co.uk/stories/colderwar.htm

  8. Wiring by Lucas. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

    'nuff said.

    1. Re:Wiring by Lucas. by plover · · Score: 1

      The Prince of Darkness is now the Archfiend of Antarctic Drilling.

      --
      John
  9. Re:If you want to manufacture something right, by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

    The Chinese hole would also collapse upon itself after 50 hours of use while proponents of Chinese outsourcing let on that bringing all our money to China for poor quality goods is sustainable and desirable.

  10. What really happened by nevillethedevil · · Score: 1

    They were probably digging near a certain mysterious and terrible mountain range. Upon breaking through into a large underground cavern, the team was set upon by some 4 foot albino penguins and a shoggoth.

    --
    Be gone from my sight or prepare to feel my flaming wraith!
  11. Re:Now that the equipment has been shown to work.. by OolimPhon · · Score: 3, Informative

    They are abandoning the project because they don't have enough fuel on site to be able to drill down to the lake.

    This is because they are using hot water to melt their way downwards, which is fine, but much of the water is escaping sideways into cracks in the ice. This means they needed more water to reach their objective. The water has to be melted from ice collected on the surface, and that takes fuel. Not enough fuel: stop wasting everybody's time and money.

  12. Re:Let me guess by robthebloke · · Score: 2

    Nothing that sinister, they just wanted to be back in time for Eastenders.

  13. Re:Typical underfunding. by ahabswhale · · Score: 1

    Eddie Izzard does a good bit about that in his Dressed to Kill show.

    Fortunately, there's always enough money for pretty horses and regalia for royal weddings.

    --
    Are agnostics skeptical of unicorns too?
  14. Re:Typical underfunding. by ciderbrew · · Score: 1

    There would be even more money for that crap if the investment money put into UK project was by UK companies and not US firms. I'd point to ARM in Cambridge to say that's how its done;but as Apple and VLSI are US based investors ... bugger.