Slashdot Mirror


Criticism Of Copyright Alert System Mounts

Dangerous_Minds writes "This last week, the Copyright Alert System was rolled out. Now that everyone is getting a better idea of what the alert system looks like, criticisms are building against the system. Freezenet says that the mere fact that ISPs are using a browser pop-up window opens the floodgates for fraudsters to hijack the system and scam users out of money. The EFF criticized the system because the educational material contains numerous flaws. Meanwhile, Web Pro News said that this system will also hurt small business and consumers."

2 of 172 comments (clear)

  1. Re:Why the hell are the pure ISps doing this? by kelemvor4 · · Score: 4, Informative

    Aren't they protected from liability as long as they act as "dumb pipes"? Doesn't his mean they are opening themselves up for liability? Yeah, I understand the ones that own media companies but what about the rest? Seems like a way to lose customers is all.

    Everyone should draw a crappy picture in paint, host it on something free like google sites, and spread links that bring people to a second page that says "You don't have permission to click this link" with a link to the picture itself. Then bring copyright complaints to all the ISPs of all the people who inevitably click that and hence download your copyrighted crap without permission. Flood the fuckers.

    They aren't going to be losing customers because in MOST markets there is no competition for a customer to choose. With very little risk to their market share they don't have a lot to lose.

  2. Re:What "education" by SteveFoerster · · Score: 4, Informative

    What a obviously stupid thing to say. The U.S. exported over $2 trillion worth of goods and services last year.

    --
    Space game using normal deck of cards: http://BattleCards.org