Slashdot Mirror
Orson Scott Card's Superman Story Shelved After Homophobia Controversy
An anonymous reader writes "A controversy has been brewing in the comic community for the past month. Orson Scott Card, author of Ender's Game and its many sequels, was tapped to write a story for the new Adventures of Superman comic. The controversy arose because Card has become an outspoken opponent of gay marriage, going so far as to say giving it legal recognition could mark 'the end of democracy in America,' and suggesting 'traditional' married people will eventually have to overthrow the government. Many fans of the series objected, and some retailers decided they wouldn't stock the issue Card's story appears in. Now, the illustrator for Card's story, Chris Sprouse, has walked away from the project, saying he wasn't comfortable with the media surrounding the story. Because of that, Card's story is being replaced in the Adventures of Superman anthology. 'The news has inspired speculation about whether or not this could mean that DC will quietly kill off the controversial Card story entirely, with some suggesting that the story remaining un-illustrated gives the publisher an "out" to avoid any potential breach-of-contract legal response.' Personally, I'm not sure what to think about this. I enjoyed Ender's Game as a kid, and it tarnishes the experience a little to know that its authors can say such hateful things. On the other hand, Card seems to have kept his personal views out of his fiction, and it's unlikely DC would let him put those views into a Superman comic even if he wanted to. It's a free country; people are free to believe stupid things. On the third hand, he is actively advocating his views outside his fiction, and what better way is there for readers to fight back than organizing a boycott and voting with their wallets? What do you think, Slashdot?"
I couldn't disagree more, one of his most popular series outside of Ender is pretty much a straight rip off of the Book Of Mormon. And for those who don't know that is the main religious text of his faith the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints. He is an outspoken douchebag verbally and in writing and I couldn't be more glad to see his work not get published,
Hold up, wait a minute, let me put some pimpin in it
Let us take it to the extreme then, and godwin this thread. If Hitler were still alive, and put out the best damn Superman comic book ever, and you bought it, you can try and justify it any way you want, but fact is, you are giving money to Hitler.
If I felt the urge to boycott artists for their personal views I'd have maybe three MP3s to enjoy, and four five minute clips from two movies.
Why don't all of you hypersensitive little panty waists quit looking for a witch to burn and just recognize a work of art for what it is: a work of art. Evaluate it on its merits and if it itself doesn't offend you, then shut the fuck up. Talent is talent, regardless of whether or not you dislike the person blessed with it.
If any of you PC fuckers had any talent we'd be awash in PC art to enjoy. But you don't, and we don't. Get it over it.
The problem is that he's using his fame achieved from his art to gain a larger audience for his message. That's when it's time to start to actively deny him his fame.
Tell that to Lady Gaga, and Madonna, and all the other liberal celebrities pushing their pesonal agenda, and flat out telling people who to vote for. Do you really think Obama could have been elected without 3/4th of the news and media outlets trying as hard as they possibly could to get him elected? And the same for far more than 3/4th of the movie stars and musicians?
Somehow various viewpoints and agendas in the United States have managed to be spun in such a way as to imply "if you are against this then you are full of hate". Just because someone doesn't agree that marriage should be redefined as a union between two people of the same sex does not mean they hate people that are homosexual. However at this time, that is the label now automatically applied to anyone who disagrees with that viewpoint.
Better known as 318230.