Slashdot Mirror
How Scientists Know An Idea Is a Good One
Physicist Chris Lee explains one of the toughest judgment calls scientists have to make: figuring out if their crazy ideas are worth pursuing. He says:
"Research takes resources. I don't mean money—all right, I do mean money—but it also requires time and people and lab space and support. There is a human and physical infrastructure that I have to make use of. I may be part of a research organization, but I have no automatic right of access to any of this infrastructure. ... This also has implications for scale. A PhD student has the right to expect a project that generates a decent body of work within those four years. A project that is going to take eight years of construction work before it produces any scientific results cannot and should not be built by a PhD student. On the other hand, a project that dries up in two years is equally bad. ... the core idea also needs to be structured so, should certain experiments not work, they still build something that can lead to experiments which do work. Or, if the cool new instrument we want to build can't measure exactly what I intended, there are other things it can measure. One of those other things must be fairly certain of success. To put it bluntly: all paths must lead to results of some form."
It is obvious that you're a mathematician. Your equation is dimensionally wrong.
Ancient Persians would debate ideas twice - once sober and once drunk. It had to sound feasible in both states to be a good idea.
It is obvious that you're a mathematician. Your equation is dimensionally wrong.
No, it's correct. Let's do the analysis: $= (time + obtanium) / desire * beer
time is in seconds
obtanium is in seconds (how long to obtain it)
desire is in seconds/liter (the longer you wait, the more you want)
beer is in dollars/liter
so we have (seconds + seconds)/(seconds/liter) * (dollars/liter) = dollars
Q.E.D.
I feel sorry for people that don't drink, because when they get up in the morning, that's as good as they're gonna feel
read the article, maybe?
No time! I need to post within an arbitrary slashdot timescale that fits with getting modded up!