Slashdot Mirror


German Court Rejects Apple's Privacy Policy

redletterdave writes "A German court rejected eight out of 15 provisions in Apple's general privacy policy and terms of data use on Tuesday, claiming that the practices of the Cupertino, Calif. company deviate too much from German laws (Google translation of German original). According to German law, recognized consumer groups can sue companies over illegal terms and conditions. Apple asks for 'global consent' to use customer data on its website, but German law insists that clients know specific details about what their data will be used for and why."

3 of 124 comments (clear)

  1. Re:better idea by mondovoja · · Score: -1, Troll

    Why should it be on the people? If the company doesn't want to follow their laws, they shouldn't sell their stuff in that country.

    It should be "on the people" because some people may not have a problem with policies and may want to do business with Apple anyway.

    By choosing to operate in Germany, they have to follow German laws for products sold in that country. Don't like it, decide not to sell there.

    The injustice here isn't to Apple, it's to other potential customers. One group of people is needlessly imposing their views of privacy on another group; instead of saying "I don't like Apple's privacy terms, so I don't use them", they say "I don't like Apple's privacy terms, so I am going to prevent you from using them as well".

    And what's behind this? Most likely not any real concern about privacy, but attempts to kill business models that German publishers and their buddies in politics don't like.

  2. Local laws vs. international standards by DNS-and-BIND · · Score: 1, Troll

    I'm experiencing cognitive dissonance; can anyone help me out? This seems to be cheered by posters who say that national laws are a good thing and foreigners should be forced to bend their knees whenever there is a conflict. However, in previous stories I have heard precisely the opposite: local standards are for ignorant redneck bullies who are too stupid to realize that their hillbilly local ordnances should be harmonized with international standards. Please reconcile.

    --
    Shutting down free speech with violence isn't fighting fascism. It IS fascism!
  3. Apple do no Evil by tuppe666 · · Score: -1, Troll

    Simply evil