More Encryption Is Not the Solution

CowboyRobot writes "Poul-Henning Kamp argues that the 'recent exposure of the dragnet-style surveillance of Internet traffic has provoked a number of responses that are variations of the general formula: "More encryption is the solution." This is not the case. In fact, more encryption will probably only make the privacy crisis worse than it already is.' His argument takes a few turns, but centers on a scenario that is a bit too easy to imagine: a government coercing software developers into disabling their encryption: 'There are a whole host of things one could buy to weaken encryption. I would contact providers of popular cloud and "whatever-as-service" providers and make them an offer they couldn't refuse: on all HTTPS connections out of the country, the symmetric key cannot be random; it must come from a dictionary of 100 million random-looking keys that I provide. The key from the other side? Slip that in there somewhere, and I can find it (encrypted in a Set-Cookie header?). In the long run, nobody is going to notice that the symmetric keys are not random — you would have to scrutinize the key material in many thousands of connections before you would even start to suspect something was wrong.'"

Comments

Re:Passwords don't work either

[interval1066]

All too true, people don't want to bother with any effort for a return they really can't see. Its hard to appreciate encryption when the effects of opentext on their private lives is difficult to impossible to gauge. Until they get hit. After a small dns server I ran got hit, I didn't really pay much attention to it either. 10 years on I still cover my tracks whenever possible, encrypt my drives (linux and truecrypt make this pretty easy), prefer encrypted smtp providers, and ask people I correspond with for their public encryption key. If they ask me what that is I explain it to them. If they say they don't care then I move on, but if they express interest I help them set up. If they say "no one uses that" I show them that I do, many of my friends do, and to look at the news lately. Its in everyone's interest to manage their privacy. If you are into managing your life like a business then its just another procedure to add to your list. If not, well, I wouldn't want to be you.