Slashdot Mirror
New Jersey Congressman Seeks To Bar NSA Backdoors In Encryption
Frosty P writes "Congressman Rush D. Holt, a New Jersey Democrat, has proposed legislation (summary, full text) that would prohibit the agency from installing 'back doors' into encryption, the electronic scrambling that protects e-mail, online transactions and other communications. Representative Holt, a physicist, said Friday that he believed the NSA was overreaching and could hurt American interests, including the reputations of American companies whose products the agency may have altered or influenced. 'We pay them to spy,' Mr. Holt said. 'But if in the process they degrade the security of the encryption we all use, it's a net national disservice.'"
A law to stop the NSA? Yeah, that oughta do the trick. *rolls eyes*
"Tell me doctor, with all of your defenses, are there any provisions for an attack by killer bees?"
If the NSA can get through a Backdoor, how do you know if a competitor or enemy is not getting in though the same backdoor?
but if you're worrying about the reputation of US companies, you're too late.
Is he permitted to hold his seat in Congress if he is in Gitmo?
Undetectable Steganography? Yep, there's an app fo
If you want an example of how getting a reputation for even the potential of embedded backdoors in your products can bite you, recall the ban imposed on Huawei network products by the US and Australia's National Broadcast Network. These revelations about the NSA's activities and US companies who roll over for them will definitely hurt sales of US products. I'll bet there are some marketing campaigns already being mulled over that would say, "Unlike our US competition, we aren't subject to demands from the NSA, and if they ever approach us, we'll tell them where to stick it." At least, that's what I'd be considering if I were a foreign telecom manufacturer.
Thanks for your efforts. But please remember that you have other, more effective tools at your disposal. The NSA has shown themselves a master in creative interpretation of law. Any new law will be twisted to their purposes. Then there will be years of appeals in the courts. Before you attempt new laws, you should immediately reassert Congress's most basic and irresistible power: The power to control the purse.
Your first act should be to slash the NSA's budget in half.
It is like working with a mule. First, you have to get their attention. As you slash their budget, explain that many of the NSA's actions have been dishonest. They have created long term problems for the rest of the country. And they have been spending their budget in ways that congress does not approve.
After you slash their budget, ask them to give the complete Congress a full accounting of how they intend to spend their remaining budget. Give them a week.
If they waffle or present an incomplete accounting, then cut their remaining budget in half.
Don't worry about the NSA. They have tens of billions of budget. You can cut their budget in half several times and they will still be able to support their best analysts. Their hardware is cheaper and more powerful than ever before. Even after the cuts, they will be as effective as any time in the past few decades. But, the cuts will remove their ability to dominate entire industries. And they will not be able to use that support to justify their illegal and unethical acts. And that is a good thing.
Above all, don't let the executive branch deter you. Controlling budget is your natural, constitutionally mandated role. Congress has been shirking their duties lately. The Black Budget has been a shameful abrogation of your responsibilities. Controlling the budget of the executive branch is your job. Don't let anybody talk you out of it.
It may take several rounds of budget cuts, but eventually they will come back in line. Then you can use law to guide them.