Slashdot Mirror
Ask Slashdot: Which Encrypted Cloud Storage Provider?
An anonymous reader writes "Almost three years ago, I started looking for a cloud storage service. Encryption and the "zero-knowledge" concept were not concerns. Frankly, after two weeks testing services, it boiled down to one service I used for almost 2 years. It was perfect — in the technical sense — because it simply works as advertised and is one of the cheapest for 500GB. But this year, I decided changing that service for another one, that would encrypt my files before leaving my machine. Some of these services call themselves 'zero-knowledge' services, because (as they claim) clear text does not leave your host: they only receive encrypted data — keys or passwords are not sent. I did all testing I could, with the free bit of their services, and then, chose one of them. After a while, when the load got higher (more files, more folders, more GB...), my horror story began. I started experiencing sync problems of all sorts. In fact, I have paid for and tested another service and both had the same issues with sync. Worse, one of them could not even handle restoring files correctly. I had to restore from my local backup more than once and I ended up losing files for real.
In your experience, which service (or services) are really able to handle more than a hundred files, in sync within 5+ hosts, without messing up (deleting, renaming, duplicating) files and folders?"
Indeed. Mostly give up the idea of having the host encrypt files for you. You never know if they have a backdoor of some sort. Find/write software (I use Arq) to encrypt files and then send the encrypted files to a host like Amazon S3. It's really the only way for the host to have the "zero-knowledge" you desire.
I use Truecrypt's encrypted drive containers in my local Dropbox folder. The file sync'd to Dropbox is encrypted when the sync occurs, so that is all they ever see. Because Dropbox does a binary diff of the file and only uploads the differences which makes syncing large encrypted files feasible.
I've seen some chatter that Truecrypt may have been compromised - Bruce Schneier and Snowden use it so I'll trust in their judgement.
"In the end, there is simply no weapon more devastating than the truth, delivered in just the right way." - tnk1
I've found Seafile to be quite good and reliable. It's a multiplatform, free software, self-hosted Dropbox alternative that provides file syncing, sharing, a web interface, and tools for team work. Libraries can be encrypted server-side.
I use it for several months now and it is both fast and reliable (much more than the owncloud versions I tested previously). It handles my whole pictures collection (about 90GB) very easily. You can install your own Seafile server (there's even a raspberry pi version), or buy storage space from them. Clients are multiplatform (Windows, Mac, Linux, Android, iPhone/iPad).