Slashdot Mirror
Ubuntu Wants To Enable SSD TRIM By Default
jones_supa writes "During the first day of the latest virtual Ubuntu Developer Summit, Canonical developers finally plotted out the enabling of TRIM/DISCARD support by default for solid-state drives on Ubuntu 14.04. Ubuntu developers aren't looking to enable discard at the file-system level since it can slow down delete operations, so instead they're wanting to have their own cron job that routinely runs fstrim for TRIMing the system. In the past there has been talk about the TRIM implementation being unoptimized in the kernel. Around when Linux 3.0 was released, OpenSUSE noted that the kernel performs TRIM to a single range, instead of vectorized list of TRIM ranges, which is what the specification calls for. In some scenarios this results in lowered performance."
TRIM makes your new flash toys go weeeeeeeee, instead of them going only wee
More like Linux doesn't follow the best practice recommendations of the standard when it wouldn't be all that hard to do so.
Solid-state drives (SSDs) are an alternative to hard disk drives using flash memory instead of spinning platters. This greatly improves read speeds but doesn't do quite as much for write speeds. One reason is that each sector on a solid-state drive can only be erased a finite number of times before it starts failing. For this reason, the microcontroller in an SSD perform wear leveling to spread writes across more physical sectors. TRIM is a feature that an operating system can use to notify a drive that a range of sectors has become unused, which helps wear leveling run more efficiently. A cron job is a program that runs periodically in the background, and Canonical (the publisher of Ubuntu, a distribution of the GNU/Linux operating system) wants to add a cron job that scans attached drives for unused sectors and sends TRIM commands for these sectors. It's possible for an operating system kernel to send a TRIM command for multiple ranges of sectors, but the current version of Linux doesn't know this and instead sends one range at a time. This slows down deleting files because the kernel has to notify the drive of each sector range as the file is deleted. To work around this missing feature of Linux, the cron job will TRIM when a drive isn't busy doing something else.
"As long as that SSD doesn't stall trying to pull blocks off the top of that queue, it really doesn't matter how deep it is. So if you have 10GB of free space on your partition, you only need to call wiper.sh / fstrim once every 10GB worth of file deletions."
This isn't necessarily true. Earlier Trim will improve the performance of the SSD drive because the drive knows more free space -- more free space allows the drive to 1) pre-emptively erase flash 2) coalesce fragmented blocks 3) more efficiently combine write blocks 4) perform wear levelling operations with less overhead.
Early trimming can have a similar effect to the manufacturer increasing slack space which increases performances on nearly all SSD's.
Quick terminology note: Flash storage is divided into large blocks, commonly called pages (to avoid confusion with disk blocks). Each page contains many disk blocks.
Flash storage has an interesting property in that you can change individual bits in only a single direction (either from 0 to 1 or 1 to 0, depending on the flash type). To change it in the other direction, you must wipe an entire flash page, which means rewriting the contents of a large number of blocks. To avoid a high risk of a power failure causing the loss of data that wasn't even changing at the time, the flash controller does not do the erase and rewrite in place. Instead, it rewrites the entire page in a different physical location (with an updated copy of the changed block or blocks), and then atomically changes the block or page mapping so that the blocks are now associated with the new physical page. It then erases the original page so that it can be reused during a subsequent write operation.
This need to erase and rewrite has a side effect, however. As the flash drive gets more and more full, it eventually runs low on pages that can be erased ahead of time, because eventually every block on the disk has had something written to it at some point in the past, even if that block is no longer actively being used by any actual file. The disk does keep some spare pages around, but that only goes so far towards fixing this problem. This means erasing pages during the write operation itself, which is a much slower operation than writing to a pre-erased page. Many of those pages, however, may contain only data that is no longer relevant—blocks from files that were deleted a long time ago. Therefore, if the flash controller could somehow know that it is safe to pre-erase those pages ahead of time, they could be ready to go when you need to write data to them.
Unfortunately, it isn't practical for a flash controller to understand every possible file system, which makes that somewhat difficult. To solve this problem, they added a new ATA command, called TRIM. The operating system sends a TRIM command to tell the flash controller that the blocks within a certain range are no longer in use by the filesystem, which means that the flash pages that contain those blocks can be pre-erased for fast reuse.
Check out my sci-fi/humor trilogy at PatriotsBooks.
This is not so simple.
The original TRIM command is non-queued. It can kill drive performance on servers, so enterprise drives are designed to work well without TRIM. If you want better, and more importantly consistent performance then you should overprovision the drive. Overprovisioning means that you do not partition 20-40% of a new drive (or a used drive, after a secure erase). Those blocks will never be used, therefore the drive always have plenty of free space, so there is no need for trim.
Queued TRIM command appeared only in the SATA 3.1 specification, so only new drives support it.
Of source it doesn't implement the standard because it's a OS kernel, not a hard drive.
The drives implement TRIM, Linux just doesn't take full advantage of its capabilities.
The drive does shit (shit that you don't get to know the details about) when issued a TRIM command.
The OS is responsible for sending that TRIM command.
TRIM tells the drive when data is deleted, allowing the drive to do whatever it thinks is best when writing pages of data or erasing blocks of data.
Without TRIM, the drives considers all previously written data to be valid because it doesn't know about deletions (they're done at the logical level within the file system).
TRIM enables your drive to have much more flexibility when writing (and overwriting) data, and when load balancing and garbage collecting. It also reduces the need for load balancing and garbage collecting.
All decent modern SSDs support TRIM for good reason. All decent modern OSs should as well.
Now if I could just get Intel to enable TRIM on RAID 0 for my chipset (1 generation behind the cutoff), I'd be set.
Linux fully supports TRIM and failure to enable it will not damage the device in any way. What will happen is the device will slow down and spend more time freeing blocks as-needed if the drive is increasingly full.
Of course, if your SSD is your boot drive and you have /home elsewhere, chances are you aren't going to suffer and current drives are significantly faster than older ones (and at their worst, still significantly faster than rotating media.)
Those blocks will never be used, therefore the drive always have plenty of free space, so there is no need for trim.
It's not quite that simple either.
SSDs write in pages, but erase in blocks of pages. When a page is changed it gets rewritten to another block. The original page is marked as free, but it can't be erased until the whole block is free. Therefore the SSD performs garbage collection of free pages, re-packing them into complete blocks.
On its own the SSD only knows which pages it freed during rewrites - it doesn't know about pages that COULD be freed because they're deleted. Overprovisioning prevents blocking when there are no free pages (that's a huge win), but the drive still wastes lots of time and wear-life moving deleted data around during GC. TRIM provides the necessary hint to prevent that waste.