Slashdot Mirror


Fearing Government Surveillance, US Journalists Are Self-Censoring

binarstu writes "Suzanne Nossel, writing for CNN, reports that 'a survey of American writers done in October revealed that nearly one in four has self-censored for fear of government surveillance. They fessed up to curbing their research, not accepting certain assignments, even not discussing certain topics on the phone or via e-mail for fear of being targeted. The subjects they are avoiding are no surprise — mostly matters to do with the Middle East, the military and terrorism.' Yet ordinary Americans, for the most part, seem not to care: 'Surveillance so intrusive it is putting certain subjects out of bounds would seem like cause for alarm in a country that prides itself as the world's most free. Americans have long protested the persecution and constraints on journalists and writers living under repressive regimes abroad, yet many seem ready to accept these new encroachments on their freedom at home.'"

15 of 376 comments (clear)

  1. Deluded ... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Surveillance so intrusive it is putting certain subjects out of bounds would seem like cause for alarm in a country that prides itself as the world's most free

    Continuing to believe that is a sign you're delusional, not 'free'.

    1. Re:Deluded ... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Interesting

      I normally choose odd pictures as my avatar on Facebook. Yesterday I was about to zero in on one of the spies from Mad Magazine's Spy vs. Spy holding a bomb, and I decided against it. I'm middle eastern and live in the U.S. I shouldn't have to worry about such things, yet worries of surveilance coupled with my background swayed me otherwise.

    2. Re:Deluded ... by AIphaWolf_HK · · Score: 5, Informative

      Not get molested at airports. Protest without being required to have a permit or sent off to a free speech zone. It's not something I'd personally like to do, but there are many drugs that are illegal. The fourth amendment is being consistently ignored. There are constitution-free zones around the border. Those are just some things that are a problem at the moment. You obviously didn't try very hard if you couldn't think of one problem.

      I'd also like to not have my communications spied on by the government.

    3. Re:Deluded ... by mwehle · · Score: 5, Interesting

      I'm old enough to remember what living in "FREE AMERICA" was like.

      Uh, just how old is that? I'm old enough to remember Kent State, being kicked by a middle-aged stranger because I didn't stand for the national anthem at a 4th of July fireworks display, and discussions with the school principal about my right to refuse swearing fealty to the US flag. I'm old enough to remember Eugene McCarthy and the Chicago police riot. Are you old enough to remember Joe McCarthy? HUAC? The Palmer Raids? When exactly were you living in "FREE AMERICA"? What was it like?

      --
      Wir sind geboren, um frei zu sein - Rio Reiser
    4. Re:Deluded ... by SirGarlon · · Score: 5, Informative

      Carry a pocket knife into a government building. Ride the subway without being searched. Keep my fucking shoes on at the airport. Apply for a job without having to prove my citizenship. Not buy health insurance. Go to Canada without having to carry my passport like we could do for 99% of American history. Write DRM-cracking software. Smoke a joint if I feel like it (I don't actually want to do that, but many do, and who am I to deny them?)

      Shall I go on?

      --
      [Sir Garlon] is the marvellest knight that is now living, for he destroyeth many good knights, for he goeth invisible.
    5. Re:Deluded ... by EdIII · · Score: 5, Insightful

      How about the simplest and yet most important one?

      Being able to have a conversation with a couple of people about highly controversial topics without fear of the government recording your conversations, creating files on all of you, and adding you to watch lists that strongly curtail your freedom of movement?

      I seem to remember the Founding Fathers being pretty fucking excited about getting that one into the framework of the country....

    6. Re:Deluded ... by Runaway1956 · · Score: 5, Informative

      Unless you are a few years older than I am, I doubt that you remember living in a "FREE AMERICA". During the McCarthy days, you were "free" to associate with card carrying communists, of course, but the moment any of the McCarthyites found out about it, you would be dragged through an ugly media trial. After your character had been thoroughly destroyed, you were then free to actually join the party. A lot of black folk might chime in here, to remind you of the many ways that they were "free". In my lifetime, black people were denied service in white restaurants, denied seating at the front of buses, and denied access to necessary public spaces such as restrooms.

      I believe that what you actually mean is, you can remember a time when you were completely unaware of civil rights violations all around you. I also remember such a time. Life was wonderful when I was five years old, and my greatest achievements included learning to ride a two-wheeled bike, and passing the test to get into first grade.

      --
      "Windows is like the faint smell of piss in a subway: it's there, and there's nothing you can do about it." - Charlie Br
  2. American talk a big game when it comes to freedom by DontBlameCanada · · Score: 5, Insightful

    ... but their actions tend to contradict what they say.

    Torture and the taking of political prisoners are touted as flaws of third world dictatorships and communists v. waterboarding, Guantanamo Bay and attempts to arrest Snowden and others who have taken a political stance they don't like.

  3. Watching watchers by mrex · · Score: 5, Insightful

    The other three out of four were too fearful of their survey answers being logged by the NSA...

  4. Suggested Slashdot Poll by cervesaebraciator · · Score: 5, Funny
    Have you ever self-censored a comment on Slashdot due to fear of government surveillance:

    1) Yes. I wanted to share my improved tin foil hat design but fear that it might be compromised if it goes public.

    2) No. I have nothing to hide and I'm quite certain that the shadowy government agencies spying on me are sufficiently restrained by secret and democratically unaccountable courts. They all have my best interests in mind.

    3) I choose to self-censor this response.

  5. Come to the UK and learn about real journalism by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Informative

    Tell them to come to the UK and they can see _real_ journalism in action.

    In America, you have Ferengi style capitalism and call it "freedom".

    In the UK, we are certainly not perfect, but we also have capitalism, but with a social conscience, because we understand that in the long run, our way of doing things leads to more freedom for a greater number of people

    We also have a habit of telling people who would harm us to go and procreate with themselves. In America, a few thousand people are sadly killed and you cower in terror and throw away everything which made you so respected.

    In the UK, we have 7/7/2005 and then the citizens of London rode the tube in a large display of defiance sending a giant f***-you to the terrorists. Your journalists need to come over here and experience _our_ way of life.

    Oh, and Edward Snowden, a true American hero, trusted a _British_ newspaper to reveal the truth.

    That fact makes me proud to be British.

  6. Done their job in the first place by Bodhammer · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Maybe if the so-called press had done their job in the the first place over the last 20 years we would be in this mess.

    --
    "I say we take off, nuke the site from orbit. It's the only way to be sure."
  7. [DISPLAY OF GRATITUDE] by doctor+woot · · Score: 5, Funny

    Man, this is some [GOOD NEWS]. I hope congress quits [WORKING TOO HARD FOR THEIR OWN GOOD], pulls their [HARD WORK AND COURAGE] out of their own [LOVE FOR THEIR COUNTRY AND ITS PEOPLE] and finally [TAKES THAT PAID VACATION THEY ALL WELL DESERVE].

  8. Stop it. by AndyAndyAndyAndy · · Score: 5, Insightful

    Once again, you're plowing your way though the comments with a reckless lack of perspective. There's no need to run a police state in order to institute universal healthcare, expand education programs, or build on welfare mechanisms. Nor does running a progressive agenda inevitably give way to the construction of a police state. There is nothing inextricable about the two ideas, and as usual, you don't even attempt to back up your flamebaiting claim. Knock it off.

    --
    It's always confirmation bias!
  9. Re:American talk a big game when it comes to freed by ewieling · · Score: 5, Insightful

    When I was growing up we were told some of the reasons the Soviets were so terrible is because people could not travel without "their papers", the Soviet government spied on its own citizens, the Soviets put people in secret prisons, the Soviets put people in prison without trial. Sounds a lot like the USA today. In the USA today these bad things seem mostly to be limited to "special circumstances", but they set a scary precedent. There are many great things about the USA, but pretending the bad stuff doesn't exist doesn't help the country, it undermines it.

    --
    I really shouldn't have used someone else's email address for this account.