Slashdot Mirror

← Back to Stories (view on slashdot.org)

Americans To FCC Chair: No Cell Calls On Planes, Please

Posted by Soulskill on from the we-only-want-what-we-can't-have dept.

jfruh writes "Who says Americans are politically apathetic? The FCC's proposal to allow cellular data — and, if the airline allows it, voice calls — on airplanes unleashed a flood of responses even before the official comment period began this week. The sentiment was overwhelmingly opposed to people talking on phones in flight. Some correspondents spun terrifying hypotheticals about yapping teens, some accused FCC chair Tom Wheeler of flying on private planes and being out of touch with the full-on horror of in-flight chatter, and one person concluded their letter with the word 'no' with letter 'o' repeated 213 times."

10 of 340 comments (clear)

  1. FCC Shouldn't Ban It, But Airlines Should by jratcliffe · · Score: 5, Insightful

    While I find the idea of being trapped next to someone making a phone call on a plane loathsome, the FCC really shouldn't be in the position of banning things just because they're annoying. If there's no technical/safety reason to ban the calls, allow them. The AIRLINES, on the other hand, really SHOULD ban these calls, and most have already said that they would.

    1. Re:FCC Shouldn't Ban It, But Airlines Should by Richard_at_work · · Score: 3, Insightful

      I also don't see how a US government organisation can ban the act of speech for a non-safety related reason - surely that would violate freedom of speech?

      Once the FCC and FAA concluded it was no longer a safety concern, their remit for control of it expired and the only entities that could ban it on "annoyance" grounds would be the airlines that operate the aircraft.

    2. Re: FCC Shouldn't Ban It, But Airlines Should by Scowler · · Score: 4, Insightful

      Public libraries often ban talking on cell phones, and not on any safety grounds.

    3. Re: FCC Shouldn't Ban It, But Airlines Should by Dan+East · · Score: 3, Insightful

      Yes, but individual public libraries aren't the federal government banning them wholesale across an entire swath of private property. Individual libraries have the right to make that decision for themselves. Perhaps they would want to provide specific areas where people could use cell phones, thus people that don't want to be around them can simply stay away from that area. Similarly, why couldn't airlines sell seats in specific sections of the plane (the back perhaps?) where cell phone calls were allowed? That shouldn't be up to the FCC since cell phones have been proven to not crash airplanes through their EMF emissions.

      --
      Better known as 318230.
    4. Re: FCC Shouldn't Ban It, But Airlines Should by Ol+Olsoc · · Score: 3, Insightful

      "But I'm not sure that is banning "speech" as it is about banning "speaking"."

      There are probably think-tanks that would pay to have someone with your ability to contort logic into previously unthinkable directions. Also have you considered becoming a corporate attorney?

      Doesn't matter. Free speech isn't anything you folks are arguing about. Free speech is not being arrested by the Government for expressing your opinion. Even then, good luck threatening to kill someone, or the famous "Yelling FIRE! in a crowded theater".

      Free speech was never about a person's unadulterated right to say whatever they want, whenever they want to, and no response from anyone else allowed.

      All of which is to say that if some asshat starts talking on their phone in the plane, and the other passengers beat the bejabbers out of him, the asshat can have them arrested for assault, but his freedom of speech has not been abridged.

      No corporate attorney duplicity needed.

      --
      The shepherds did so well protecting the flock that the sheep no longer believed that wolves existed.
  2. Re:Allow it... by Penguinisto · · Score: 3, Insightful

    Nice compromise, but seating space is already at cattle-car tightness now. I can only imagine what it would squeeze everyone down to if you had to accommodate a frickin' room with soundproofing.

    Personally, and as a guy who travels on business a lot, I MUCH prefer that cell phone usage remain banned (data usage okay, but no cell usage).

    Why? Two reasons:

    1) people are annoying enough - imagine 100-200 of them in a tiny cabin practically yelling into their cell phones.

    2) I love not having to answer emails or phone calls while in-flight.

    --
    Quo usque tandem abutere, Nimbus, patientia nostra?
  3. Imagine by Rik+Sweeney · · Score: 5, Insightful

    A night flight. The plane is quiet.

    Suddenly,

    "Yeah, I couldn't sleep... No, they've fed us.... HA HA HA HA HA!!! Yeah, that's right! HA HA HA HA HA!!! I know what you mean and there's that.... HA HA HA HA HA!!!! Do you remember that?... HA HA HA HA HA!!!"

    --
    Summation 2
  4. Re:Allow it... by lagomorpha2 · · Score: 5, Insightful

    " (data usage okay, but no cell usage)."

    The FCC's job here is to create rules to promote safety. If it's an annoyance issue then the airlines should be the ones making rules about it. We don't need the FCC legislating cell phone use in movie theaters and cell phone use in planes can be dealt with the same way - anyone who won't stop talking on their phone in the theater/plane will be made to leave.

  5. cell phone conversations are allowed on trains by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Insightful

    and i don't find them the least bit annoying.

    i think it would be very similar for airplanes.

  6. It's a bit sketchy, but I think you can by monkeyhybrid · · Score: 3, Insightful

    I've never tried to make a call but I have happily sent texts during a flight before. I can't say I paid much attention to it at the time, but I'm pretty sure I had a good bar or two of reception, at least whilst over land, so I'm guessing a call could have worked ok too. I'm sure the sitting-in-a-metal-tube thing won't help but presumably the windows allow enough RF to pass through.

    Also, some of the passengers of 'flight 93' made calls to their loved ones during the 9/11 hijackings.