Slashdot Mirror


Amputee Is German Long Jump Champion

hweimer (709734) writes "German long jumper Markus Rehm has written sports history yesterday, becoming the first disabled athlete to win a national able-bodied championship. His jump to 8.24 meters put him on the 9th place of the current season rankings and make him egligible to compete in the upcoming European championships, further sparking the debate whether his prosthetic leg provides him with an unfair advantage."

6 of 175 comments (clear)

  1. No, no unfair advantage at all... by BitZtream · · Score: 4, Insightful

    From TFA

    Rehm runs and jumps with a specially designed blade that is 15 inches longer than his other leg

    I can't imagine why anyone would accuses him of 'cheating' ...

    The device is like a spring, so it stores energy as well as having extra length and mechanical advantage, and better still its far stronger and requires much more force to break.

    I'm sorry he lost his leg, but there is no why this is 'fair' by any sense of the word.

    --
    Persistent Volume manager for Kubernetes - https://github.com/dwimsey/openshift-pvmanager
  2. Different equipment, different categories by pmontra · · Score: 3, Insightful

    Eventually prosthetics will get so good that they'll let athletes achieve much better results than any unmodified human. When it happens everybody will see that the only way to go is different categories for different equipments. We are bound by compassion and politically correctness until we get to that point, so how to address this problem now? Call me hard hearted but I'd still apply my reasoning and enforce different categories right now even if we are in doubt of who's getting an advantage at the moment.

  3. Re:Body integrity identity disorder by K.+S.+Kyosuke · · Score: 1, Insightful

    Allegedly gave his two cents. I see people even today saying "this is not a legal advice, hire a lawyer" like all the time. I'm pretty sure it applies to ancient prose even more.

    --
    Ezekiel 23:20
  4. Re:Body integrity identity disorder by alvinrod · · Score: 4, Insightful

    That is quite possibly the worst interpretation of scripture that I've seen in a while. Even people who don't buy into it are quite capable of realizing that what you're suggesting the passage means has nothing to do with what it was intended to mean.

    I'm not sure if this is just ignorance, a failed attempt to be funny, or a troll. If it's the latter, bravo to you as it appears as though it's worked rather well.

  5. Re:Body integrity identity disorder by wonkey_monkey · · Score: 4, Insightful

    One thing that keeps runners from "opting into" this prosthetic is that mainstream surgeons are forbidden to perform elective amputations.

    I'd think that the main thing that keeps runners from "opting into" prosthetics is that most people don't want their fucking legs cut off.

    --
    systemd is Roko's Basilisk.
  6. Re:We need different divisions by Wycliffe · · Score: 3, Insightful

    Oh, gimme a freakin' break. Appendectomy, really? Polio victims are crippled and won't pass the qualifying rounds. Or did you just come up with ridiculous examples for some unclear end?

    The point of these "ridiculous examples" is to show that very few people now days are "unmodified".
    Where do you draw the line? Olympic bicyclists have one leg larger than the other. Many other
    professionals like weight lifters, etc... are similiarly deformed. Weird protein shakes and specialized
    diets are the norm. Reinjecting your own blood right before game time is pretty common in some sports.
    It's not a drug or enhancement but clearly is not something that should be allowed. How do you
    regulate these things? What about someone who has a medical condition and needs to take steroids
    or some other drug like an antidepressant that has a side effect of enhanced performance.
    Professional sports for the most part are already twisted into a sport for only accidental freaks of nature
    who in addition to having some lucky physical trait also train round the clock 24/7 with specialized diets
    and specialized exercise routines. We all might be better off if we just say anything goes and see exactly
    how far we can push technology and the human body instead of pretending that all athletes are normal
    human beings that just walked in off the street.