Slashdot Mirror


BBC and FACT Shut Down Doctor Who Fansite

An anonymous reader writes with this report from Torrentfreak, excerpting: In just a few hours time the brand new season of Doctor Who will premiere, kicking off with the first episode 'Deep Breath'. There's been a huge build up in the media, but for fans who prefer to socialize and obtain news via a dedicated community, today brings bad news. Doctor Who Media (DWM) was a site created in 2010 and during the ensuing four and a half years it amassed around 25,000 dedicated members. A source close to the site told TF that since nothing like it existed officially, DWM's core focus was to provide a central location and community for everything in the 'Whoniverse,' from reconstructions of missing episodes to the latest episodes, and whatever lay between. But yesterday, following a visit by representatives from the BBC and Federation Against Copyright Theft, the site's operator took the decision to shut down the site for good.

6 of 186 comments (clear)

  1. Re:So much for fair use by 91degrees · · Score: 5, Informative

    Yes it does. It's called fair dealing. But it doesn't allow you to offer complete episodes of a TV show.

  2. Re:Anyone know what, exactly, was the issue? by Frosty+Piss · · Score: 4, Informative

    They were hosting full episodes. If the guy had taken them down, the forum could have gone on, but people mostly went there for the episodes, so that would have killed the site.

    Also, 25000 users is "huge"?

    --
    If you want news from today, you have to come back tomorrow.
  3. Re:Don't worry by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Informative

    It would have also avoided most of its audience.

  4. Shot themselves in the foot there by malacandrian · · Score: 1, Informative

    That site was doing nothing except positives for the Doctor Who show. If they wanted to exercise more control over their brand, they could have at least tried to work with the site first, or even take it over and let the same people continue to run the site under their oversight. Fuckwits.

    From the summary:

    DWM's core focus was to provide a central location and community for everything in the 'Whoniverse,' from reconstructions of missing episodes to the latest episodes, and whatever lay between.

    The purpose of the site was not to let fans discuss their favourite episodes, it was to store and distribute copyrighted material without licence. This is precisely what copyright laws were designed to tackle. This isn't news, this isn't relevant to any serious discussion about copyright reform, this is the system working as intended.

  5. Re:This copywrite shit is getting pathetic by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Informative

    "The purpose of the site was not to let fans discuss their favourite episodes, it was to store and distribute copyrighted material without licence. This is precisely what copyright laws were designed to tackle. This isn't news, this isn't relevant to any serious discussion about copyright reform, this is the system working as intended."

    You are completely full of shit and I would like to know why you feel it is okay to come in here and just lie? They did not "store and distribute copyrighted material without licence".

  6. Re:Anyone know what, exactly, was the issue? by Teun · · Score: 2, Informative

    Nothing to do with taxpayers, it's licence payers that finance the Beep.

    --
    "The likes of Facebook and WhatsApp are free to those whose privacy is of zero value."