Tiny Wireless Device Offers Tor Anonymity

Lucas123 writes: The Anonabox router project, currently being funded through a Kickstarter campaign, has surpassed its original $7,000 crowdfunding goal by more than 10 times in just one day. The open source router device connects via Wi-Fi or an Ethernet cable making it harder for your IP address to be seen. While there have been other Tor-enabled routers in the past, they aren't small enough to fit in a shirt pocket like the Anonabox and they haven't offered data encryption on top of the routing network. The device, which is being pitched as a way for consumers to securely surf the web and share content (or allow businesses to do the same), is also being directed at journalists who may want to share stories in places where they might otherwise be censored.

Comments

I wonder how much we can trust it

[PhrostyMcByte]

Making Tor dead simple to use is great, but this is such a nice device for three-letter agencies to target inserting a backdoor into.

Re:I wonder how much we can trust it

[Sqr(twg)]

The three-letter agencies don't need to insert a backdoor. All they need to do is operate a bunch of Tor exit nodes.

As soon as you use Tor for everyday activities you are effectively not anonymous anymore.

Example: You set up the WiFi router and start doing your secret stuff. The bad guys have no idea who's behind the connection.
Then the jogging app on your iPhone connects over the same Tor tunnel. It opens an unencrypted connection to a "share my run" server, and now the bad guys know your email address, weight, and the GPS coordinates of the route you ran this morning. They don't even have to tap your or the server's connection. They get the information directly from their own exit node. (I.e. easier than if you had not been running Tor. Anyone can do this. Not just the three-letter agencies.)

Want anonymity? Install the Tor Browser. Then only use it for the anonymous stuff. Never visit any of the sites you ordinarily frequent.

Re:I wonder how much we can trust it

[fuzzyfuzzyfungus]

Making Tor dead simple to use is great, but this is such a nice device for three-letter agencies to target inserting a backdoor into.

While that is a possibility(albeit one that could theoretically be ameliorated, barring hardware-level backdoors, by 'here's how to build Tor from mainline and replace our firmware' documentation), I'd be more worried about the fact that Tor isn't dead simple.

The project itself has a list of handy warnings concerning What Not To Do on Tor and expect the anonymity to keep working, even assuming there are no unknown attacks and vulnerabilities at play. Tor has no magical ability to scrub dangerously identifying information from the assorted dumb, lazy, or just plain user-hostile chatter generated by various programs on your computer. It also, as a necessary side effect of its design, exposes some traffic to the exit node, which requires that you be careful about SSL/TLS for anything that the exit node shouldn't see.

That's what makes me nervous about the projects(hardware or software, boxes like this or Android VPN plugins, or whatever) that make it dead easy to route all traffic through Tor. Unless you know exactly what you are doing, that probably isn't what you want. Your day-to-day OS is very likely to be far too dangerously chatty(which means that you really shouldn't use it at all, unless booted to a liveCD; with the Tor browser bundle, that passes only traffic from the Tor browser as a distant second best); but you definitely shouldn't just plug it into the magic Tor box. Some applications you just don't want going through Tor at all. If the traffic is intrinsically personally identifying the best case is that you'll gain nothing and the worst case is that you'll be less secure than you were.

Things that keep people from running the browser bundle on their poxed XP machines and expecting anonymity are good; but Tor simply isn't easy to use, even if it is made easy to set up, and that can bite you in the ass.

Not secure

[BitcoinBenny]

Its a cool idea. There are things that are problematic about it though, like the fact that the browser itself hasn't been properly anonymized. The Tor browser package tries to disable plugins and third party software that might inadvertently reveal your identity or cause other information leakage. There is no such guarantee in this instance, which is a bit of a false sense of security. Tor isn't a panacea for all anonymity issues, and you wouldn't want to route most of your traffic over it.

I'm personally more interested in the hardware, any specifics on that? I think it would be a nice platform for a lot of interesting projects, hardware based firewalling etc.

Re:Not secure

[tlhIngan]

Its a cool idea. There are things that are problematic about it though, like the fact that the browser itself hasn't been properly anonymized. The Tor browser package tries to disable plugins and third party software that might inadvertently reveal your identity or cause other information leakage. There is no such guarantee in this instance, which is a bit of a false sense of security. Tor isn't a panacea for all anonymity issues, and you wouldn't want to route most of your traffic over it.

And therein lies the problem Well, one of several.

First, the users have to actually want to be anonymous. There's no magic "make me anonymous" magic pixie dust that can be applied - I mean, what's the point of using Tor if you're going to log into your Google, Facebook, Amazon, Twitter, or whatever else account? You've not only gave your anonymity up a long time ago, you've just defeated all the anonymity you're going to get because all those ad networks now will be able to re-link your Tor usage to you.

Additionally, Tor is not magic. Using it doesn't make you invisible. Especially if you're going on about "black helicopters" and such because the likes of the NSA have revealed to be running the largest number of high-speed exit nodes, and those who control exit nodes on Tor control it all. Either keep your traffic within the Tor network on Tor-specific sites, or realize that where ever your traffic exits, the exit node may be screwing with you.

Sure you may get certificate errors and such, but I'm sure most users will click through them anyways.

Hell, it almost seems all the spies want users using Tor because by making it magic box, they'll do the same old stupid shit over it and not only be really easy to track and monitor, but the users will think all is well, at that.