Slashdot Mirror
First Evidence of Extrasolar Planets Discovered In 1917
KentuckyFC writes: Earth's closest white dwarf is called van Maanen 2 and sits 14 light-years from here. It was discovered by the Dutch astronomer Adriaan van Maanen in 1917, but it was initially hard to classify. That's because its spectra contains lots of heavy elements alongside hydrogen and helium, the usual components of a white dwarf photosphere. In recent years, astronomers have discovered many white dwarfs with similar spectra and shown that the heavy elements come from asteroids raining down onto the surface of the stars. It turns out that all these white dwarfs are orbited by a large planet and an asteroid belt. As the planet orbits, it perturbs the rocky belt, causing asteroids to collide and spiral in toward their parent star. This process is so common that astronomers now use the heavy element spectra as a marker for the presence of extrasolar planets. A re-analysis of van Maanen's work shows that, in hindsight, he was the first to discover the tell-tale signature of extrasolar planets almost a century ago.
Indeed, so some criteria are needed to established who is the discoverer. As far as I know, one of those criteria is knowing what's being discovered.
At what point would you say that one "knew" what America was. We know that Columbus didn't know it. Was it when the west coast was discovered, or would one have to find both Alaska and the southern tip of Chile as well?
Perhaps we can conclude that America has yet to be discovered?