Slashdot Mirror

← Back to Stories (view on slashdot.org)

Innocent Adults Are Easy To Convince They Committed a Serious Crime

Posted by timothy on from the well-you-did-you-know dept.

binarstu (720435) writes "Research recently published [link is to abstract only; full text requires subscription] in Psychological Science quantifies how easy it is to convince innocent, "normal" adults that they committed a crime. The Association for Psychological Science (APS) has posted a nice summary of the research. From the APS summary: "Evidence from some wrongful-conviction cases suggests that suspects can be questioned in ways that lead them to falsely believe in and confess to committing crimes they didn't actually commit. New research provides lab-based evidence for this phenomenon, showing that innocent adult participants can be convinced, over the course of a few hours, that they had perpetrated crimes as serious as assault with a weapon in their teenage years."

2 of 291 comments (clear)

  1. Re:The (in)justice system by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 5, Informative

    It's one of the few things that are quite black and white, either someone committed a crime or he did not.

    A plea bargain is not someone saying they partially committed a crime, it is them admitting full guilt to a crime. The law frequently gives a range of punishments, e.g. upper and lower limits for fines or jail time, and the judge can pick something lower if the defendant saves everyone a bunch of time by just admitting it. Some laws also allow judges to remit or change the charges to a lesser crime depending on the circumstances too, especially if part of the plea bargain involves helping them catch other people. It has nothing to do with partly committing a crime, but what amount of punishments and exactly what charges are used. That said, it can pressure innocent people in tough situations to just accept guilt.

  2. Re:The (in)justice system by quenda · · Score: 5, Informative

    Or you've spent 5 years in an illegal prison without valid charge, and subject to torture.
    Finally, prosecution says you can go home tomorrow if you plead guilty to this new retrospective crime we just made up.

    And there you have the confession and first conviction of a Gitmo detainee! (Five years later, the US Court of Appeals ruled the conviction invalid.)

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/D...