Slashdot Mirror
Pakistan Builds Nuclear Reactors In Karachi, Sparking Fears of Disaster
schwit1 writes World leaders have fretted for years that terrorists may try to steal one of Pakistan's nuclear bombs and detonate it in a foreign country. But some Karachi residents say the real nuclear nightmare is unfolding here in Pakistan's largest and most volatile city. Of all places to locate a nuclear reactor, they argue, who could possibly make a case for this one — on an earthquake-prone seafront vulnerable to tsunamis and not far from where al-Qaeda militants nearly hijacked a Pakistan navy vessel last fall.
Glad to see a mod on her toes in modding thearent trol!
After all, Bin Laden had a nice urban apartement in Pakistan, was all reformed and the Pakistan governement knew thus and wanted him to get a break.
but no. Those war mongering Americans had to go and shoot that poor man just because he allegedly was some sort of terrorist mastermind.
This must be the most moronic article I've read in a long time.
3/4 of the way down the text it says the only relevant piece of information: "Minhaj said concerns about the effect of a tsunami are also overblown because the new reactors are being built on a rock ledge about 39 feet above sea level."
That's 12m above the sea. The tsunami generated by a mag 9.0 earthquake is expected to be between 0.9m and 7m high - so the plant will have 5m margin ABOVE THE WORST CASE.
Shut up everyone, you've been lied to.
new orleans
Population (2013)[1]
City and Parish 378,715 (US: 51st)
Metro 1,240,977 (US: 45th)
karachi
Population (2013)
Total 23,500,000[1]
Rank 1st (Pakistan), 2nd (World)
new orleans is a cute little rural suburb compared to karachi
having driven to new orleans a number of times, i've seen myself that 20 miles out from new orleans it is nothing but scrub and mangroves. i can understand within new orleans itself you feel like you are in a dense city, because there's nothing else around, and you're the center of that area of the country. but this is a provincial judgment
world cities are mind blowing compared to american cities
here in new york city, a huge fucking megacity by usa standards but a puny light weight by world standards, 20 miles out is still dense and urban
Population (2013)[5]
Total 8,405,837[1]
Rank 1st, U.S., 24th (World)
so: 20 miles from the city center of karachi is still pretty much in the middle of dense giant fucking karachi
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/L...
intellectual property law is philosophically incoherent. it is your moral duty to ignore it or sabotage it
so: 20 miles from the city center of karachi is still pretty much in the middle of dense giant fucking karachi
You use a lot of fancy numbers but really all you needed to do was look at a map. These reactors are being built in the middle of nowhere (or rather the edge of nowhere since it's on the waterfront). The reactors are not 20 miles from the city centre rather they are actually about 15 miles from the boundary.
Better still these nice modern reactors with all their modern safety standards and passive safety systems and an inherently safer design are being built in an existing complex next to a set of existing 1970s era reactors. The article even has a picture of the existing plant.
This is colossal FUD, and they should be welcoming the addition of GenIII reactors so they can eventually transition away from the older ones which actually may be a problem if something seriously goes wrong.
There has already been a nuclear reactor plant in Pakistan Karachi since the 1972, supplied by the Canadian Gov; it's called the KANUPP-I and it's still in operation, but only generating 85MW of power (max power = 140MW), while the new reactor will generate up to 1000MW.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Karachi_Nuclear_Power_Complex#KANUPP-I
It is safe. But just like a lot of other safe thing, you have to be somewhat inteligent in using it. It is still not a good idea to run with safety scissors just like its not a good idea to walk around the shady parts of nyc showing everyone you pass a wad of cash while asking them where you can find some crack cocaine.