Slashdot Mirror


Verizon Tells Customer He Needs 75Mbps For Smoother Netflix Video

An anonymous reader writes: Verizon recently told a customer that upgrading his 50Mbps service to 75Mbps would result in smoother streaming of Netflix video. Of course, that's not true — Netflix streams at a rate of about 3.5 Mbps on average for Verizon's fiber service, so there's more than enough headroom either way. But this customer was an analyst for the online video industry, so he did some testing and snapped some screenshots for evidence. He fired up 10 concurrent streams of a Game of Thrones episode and found only 29Mbps of connection being used. This guy was savvy enough to see through Verizon's BS, but I'm sure there are millions of customers who wouldn't bat an eye at the statements they were making. The analyst "believes that the sales pitch he received is not just an isolated incident, since he got the same pitch from three sales reps over the phone and one online."

14 of 170 comments (clear)

  1. uh... by retchdog · · Score: 3, Insightful

    since they just throttle the connection into tiers so as to maximize profit, isn't it at least possible that the higher tiers also have lower latency or higher prioritization (among the ISP's users, not necessarily of youtube)?

    --
    "They were pure niggers." – Noam Chomsky
    1. Re:uh... by Stewie241 · · Score: 4, Insightful

      Latency is generally not important at all for Netflix. For Skype or video chatting, maybe, but with Netflix, you can have 5 second ping and still have a good video watching experience.

    2. Re:uh... by angel'o'sphere · · Score: 5, Insightful

      so Verizon is technically correct
      No they are not.

      For watching a video that needs something like 1.5 Mbps bandwidth, on a line that already has 50 Mbps increasing that to 75 makes no difference at all.

      --
      Cost free eBook I read (by iBook/Kobo/Amazon/ObookO/Gutenberg etc.): "The Green Odyssey" by Philip Jose Farmer.
    3. Re:uh... by WarJolt · · Score: 3, Insightful

      increasing that to 75 makes no difference at all.

      Unless you're sharing your bandwidth with some annoying roommates.

    4. Re:uh... by ShanghaiBill · · Score: 4, Informative

      So in real life, a faster data connection really does create a better viewing experience

      No. This would only be true if the people at Netflix were complete morons. They measure the latency, and adjust the buffer. So as long as your bandwidth is good enough, and the latency is reasonably consistent, you are fine.

      so Verizon is technically correct

      No they aren't. They are flat out lying.

    5. Re:uh... by abies · · Score: 3, Interesting

      I understand your idea, but I think this is not true with TCP/IP. Latency IS affecting throughput considerably.
      a) There is a limit of un-acked bytes which can be pushed, so there is guaranteed limit depending on distance (and with 5 seconds it is going to be very visible)
      b) With any kind of packet loss, which is to be expected, window size will reset, slowing it even more

      Only info I was able to find about that was quite old and metioning various workarounds which will be implemented for that in 2010 or so ;) Does anybody know how it looks like these days on majority of internet? What will be expected maximum throughput over TCP/IP with 5s ping, with 0% packet loss, 0.1% packet loss and 1% packet loss?

  2. Re:Seriously? by desdinova+216 · · Score: 3, Funny

    no the ones who score high on sociopathy tests get put into executive training programs.

  3. Sales will always be sales by zazenation · · Score: 4, Insightful

    This tactic has been used in auto sales for years.
    Selling customers at closing "undercoating, rustproofing and fabric protection" that are already part of the car, but get people to shell out extra coin for. Extended warranties fall into the same category. Just extra profit if nobody questions it.
    I guess all those unemployed car sales-bodies have to take a job somewhere.

  4. Did he test with the proper equipment? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 3, Funny

    He may not be able to see the difference if he doesn't have this.

  5. Re:Seriously? by bobbied · · Score: 3, Insightful

    I think they deliberately fill their storefronts with toxic twerps who score the highest on sociopathy tests.

    No, they pick their sales people from the stock of minimum wage skilled who fancy themselves tech savvy and then bonus them on how much they manage to sell (up sell) customers. In the words of a famous manger, you get what you bonus. Of course they will suggest you buy MORE from them because they likely get a bonus for this. Verizon KNOWS that 75mbs is pointless, that nobody is going to flood that for very long, that you are likely only ever going to need maybe 25mbs, but that doesn't mean they won't be happy to take an extra $40/month from you so your speed testing shows 75mbps.

    Verizon does seem to be well stocked with these types though. I recently spent a number of hours trying to fix my FIOS internet connection with a number of them on the phone... After beating around the "Yes, I've rebooted the router" and "No, I won't directly connect my laptop up to the internet for love or money" with multiple techs over multiple hours, it turns out that they switched my connection from PPPoE to DHCP and didn't bother to tell me to change. I don't figure the first level support guys had any clue, they just read from the cue cards and if you go off script, they are helpless.

    --
    "File to fit, pound to insert, paint to match" - Aircraft Maintenance 101
  6. Let's read the transcript exactly by Dutch+Gun · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Dan: Plus when I called in...
    Dan: They told me if I go from 50 mbps to 75 mbps i will get better netflix streaming. is that true?
    Dan: Will it improve?
    Robert: Yes it you have more bandwidth you will have smoother video viewing.
    Dan: But isn't 50 mbps already enough?
    Robert: yes it is enough. 75 will just be smoother.

    So, basically Dan baited the rep into talking up the improvements related to Netflix streaming. Note also the rep was actually honest that 50 mbps was enough to stream Netflix just fine. It sort of sounds like this guy was trolling for a story, and got the sales rep to overstate the benefits with a nice leading question. Ok, so Verizon should tell their sales reps to be a bit more honest, but... I'm having a hard time generating any outrage here. Are people equally outraged when salespeople sell 4K TVs to customers who will likely never see the difference between that and a good 1080p screen at their TV size and viewing distance?

    Sales rep overstates benefits of top-tier package. News at 11.

    --
    Irony: Agile development has too much intertia to be abandoned now.
    1. Re:Let's read the transcript exactly by sjames · · Score: 5, Insightful

      No, since the correct answer is "Really 50Mbps is all you need. Going to 75 won't matter". Really, even 50 is WAAAAAAAAAYYYYYYYY overkill for a 3Mbps stream.

      In a just world, they'd let the people in jail for possession of pot go to make room for the lying pack of jackles that is sales and marketing. Although rarely enforced at all, it is actually against the law to lie to potential customers. Many times they get around it on technicalities or dismissing statements as mere puffery but this is just a straight up lie.

  7. Re:Is this news? by Minwee · · Score: 4, Funny

    Should that 4000Mbps be 4Mbps? Even that seems high, as I believe that 1080p = 5Mbps, but 4Gbps seems way overboard.

    And this is why you don't work for Verizon.

  8. Verizon runs a number of scams... by bobbied · · Score: 4, Interesting

    Yea, they will happily sell you more bandwidth than you will likely ever use outside of running a speed test, but they will sell you *anything* to make more cash from you.

    It's worse too if you are an established customer with them. All those advertised prices you see? GARBAGE... They DON'T apply to you as an established customer. The ad price for the services I get is $75/month and the actual price I pay is $130! How's that? Well, let's see, there is a bunch of things NOT in the advertised price. Equipment Rental $25 for a DVR set Top box, and I have two, $10 for the router, then there is the regional sports fee (because I pay for ESPN non the less) for $7, add in tax and FCC mandated fees and it's $130 or so. It's a racket, but I'm sure Verizon isn't the only provider that does this kind of thing. TWC does similar stuff too.

    Then, you know what happens after your contract term is up, they do away with the service you used to pay for. I had just internet with them for years, starting at 10mbs, that plan went away eventually and I got automatically bumped up. Over time I went from $50/month to nearly double that with not nearly a double in speed. We where at $100/moth for 25/25 by the end of 6 years. However, you call them and they are all about "we don't raise your rates like the other guys!". I told one of their sales people that it as a boldfaced lie to say they don't raise rates, I'd been a customer for YEARS and they surely did raise my rates during that time, multiple times.

    But what really frosted me was the "Oh the advertised rates are for NEW customers only!" line. Come on Verizon, I've been your customer for 6 years, never a late bill payment, no changes in my service, not even a technician visit to my home to fix something. You are going to give the guy up the street you don't know is really going to pay you a better deal then me? You people are NUTS..

    --
    "File to fit, pound to insert, paint to match" - Aircraft Maintenance 101