Slashdot Mirror


The Uber Economy Needs a New Category of Worker

An anonymous reader writes: Uber headlines a new group of companies building out the so-called "sharing economy," in which people can easily hop in and out of employment modes. Somebody can suddenly start hiring out his driving services to others, taking breaks and setting hours as he prefers, and then just as quickly stop participating forever. An article at NY Magazine says we need to define a new class of worker to fit Uber drivers and similar at-will employees. "According to American employment law, though, our driver must be one or the other, a 1099 contractor or a W2 employee. And the gulf between the two in terms of mandated government protections and benefits is as wide as the line between them is blurry. As such, thousands of on-demand-economy employees and scads of lawyers are at war in court to determine what camp our average driver should fall into. ... It might be time for a new standard that splits the difference between the two — a 'dependent contractor,' as some labor experts call it — that would be better for businesses, consumers, and all those workers themselves."

2 of 273 comments (clear)

  1. Control by rahvin112 · · Score: 4, Interesting

    1099 Contractors can't be controlled like a regular employee. You can't train them and you can't direct their behavior (such as work hours, etc) while working. Companies don't like this, as in some of these internet companies are pulling their 1099 employees in as W2 employees so they can control them better. What these finance guys want is a new category where they can control you like a W2 employee but don't have to give you benefits like a 1099. The employer gets the best of both worlds and the employee gets bent over and taken.

    I'm sure the people suggesting this would like to see the minimum wage dropped to zero as well so they can make more cash exploiting people.

    1. Re:Control by blue9steel · · Score: 3, Interesting

      I'm sure the people suggesting this would like to see the minimum wage dropped to zero as well so they can make more cash exploiting people.

      Which would be a great idea if we coupled it with a guaranteed basic income. Lose the threat of starvation and homelessness and you put the labor negotiation back on fair footing.