Slashdot Mirror


Keyboardio is a Hackable 'Artisanal Keyboard' That's Already Kickstarted (Video)

I bumped into Jesse Vincent and his keyboard project called Keyboardio at last year's Solid conference. Then, it was a developing project with a lot of literally rough edges, but since I'm a bit of a keyboard enthusiast, it grabbed my attention. In the time since, his plan to bring a truly hackable keyboard to the world has gained momentum, and the dozens of layouts and material combinations that he and partner in design Kaia Dekker have considered have been boiled down into one nearly-ready final version. The result is a compact split keyboard housed in an "heirloom quality" wooden case. It has some features you might consider overwrought -- like an RGB LED beneath each key, a precision mouse feature via WASD keys, and the ability, theoretically, to put more than a dozen feet between each half of the board. But if you're designing a keyboard from scratch, why not?

Vincent and Dekker put their project onto Kickstarter, then spent weeks on a road trip showing it at hacker and maker spaces around the U.S.; the project updates make a nice travelogue about just how widespread and varied is the world of DIY culture. I caught up with him in Colorado Springs, Colorado, on the road between some of those demo gigs, to talk about the long path from idea to (hopefully) shipping a product to backers. By the time we had this conversation, the project was well past fully funded, andI was impressed enough to order one myself; hopefully, the clicky keys will be worth the cost of a middlin' Chromebook, though Vincent admits they're not going to fool anyone looking for a buckling spring action. On the other hand, at least at the Kickstarter price, it beats some of the Maltron keyboards I've been eyeing for years. Plus, it comes with a screwdriver.

46 comments

  1. Woo Yay by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Insightful

    A video
    For a product
    With a kickstarter

    I sure am loving this new corporate slashdot, who needs to know about kernel bugs when we can pre-buy shit that was probably ready for market anyway, but the creators decided they wanted some free PR.

    1. Re:Woo Yay by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      It's pretty lame too. Even the keyboard built into my laptop is better.

    2. Re:Woo Yay by brantondaveperson · · Score: 1

      Not to mention hideous.

  2. They almost had me by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

    I was liking the idea until I saw that you cannot change the physical layout. I like my big, stupid rectangle. There is a reason that the ctrl and meta keys should be on both sides.

    1. Re:They almost had me by _anomaly_ · · Score: 1

      Maybe once they get off the ground they'll start offering orders of "rebranded" keys. I mean, if you didn't mind the layout of the keys themselves, but wanted to swap them around or replace them, I'd imagine it'd just require a minor software change. You'd just have to deal with having to remember that the "cmd" key is actually left alt, or whatever, without "rebranded" keys.

      Looks cool, and sounds like it'd be fun to play around with, but I'll probably just keep my old Microsoft Natural Keyboard Elite. Unless my financial situation changed, that is, and I had money to burn.

      --
      "I have no special gift, I am only passionately curious." - Albert Einstein
    2. Re:They almost had me by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

      No space on the left side! Tab isn't on the far left. Return isn't on the far right. Caps Lock is AWOL, but there is an Any key! Shift is under your thumbs, not your little fingers. And finally the awkward direction keys: Left is little finger on left, index finger on right. However right is middle finger on left, and little finger on right. Up is ring finger on left and right. But down is ring finger on left and middle finger on the right!

    3. Re:They almost had me by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Oh, and the keys are illuminated, presumably in case a touch-typist catches leprosy, or a non touch-typist is dumb enough to buy a split keyboard.

  3. Flash ... by John+Bokma · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Flash requirement on a "tech" website... Le Sigh

    1. Re:Flash ... by Roblimo · · Score: 1

      For some reason Flash seems to be the default, but I can watch /. videos on my Linux laptop that doesn't have Flash installed. The thing that irks me is that if we put two videos on one story the second one is always flash, period. Timothy and I have told the software engineers and management people that this isn't a good idea, and sooner or later maybe they'll get around to fixing the problem. Meanwhile, let me get the transcript for *this* video edited and uploaded - it came in late. Garg.

    2. Re: Flash ... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      It's not just hipsters who hate Flash; it's anybody who doesn't have their heads up their asses.

  4. Hackable! by pushing-robot · · Score: 4, Funny

    I see they're trying to encourage DIY by leaving the space bar as an exercise for the buyer.

    --
    How can I believe you when you tell me what I don't want to hear?
    1. Re:Hackable! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      It has a space key rather than a "bar".

    2. Re:Hackable! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Except on the left.

  5. Re:heirloom quality hipsters by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

    instead of a screwdriver, it should come with a fedora

  6. Wooden? by penguinoid · · Score: 3, Insightful

    I'm always suspicious of things that are made of wood and advertized as though that were epic quality in materials. I always suspect they're sacrificing quality and price for hipsterism. So, why wood?

    --
    Don't waste your vote! Vote for whoever you want, unless you live in a swing state it won't matter anyways
    1. Re:Wooden? by bigfinger76 · · Score: 1

      It's artisinal!

    2. Re:Wooden? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Easier to purchase and machine compared to titanium or other epic quality materials. :)

  7. Ugh, another pointless video by wonkey_monkey · · Score: 4, Insightful

    4 minutes of video and (as far as I can tell from skimming through it) not a single picture of the device in question? Just two talking heads with awful sound quality?

    We went from text-only summaries to text-with-video. Has it honestly never occured to anyone at Slashdot that images would, in some cases, be a much more preferable option? The old adage is an old adage for a reason.

    and the ability, theoretically, to put more than a dozen feet between each half of the board. But if you're designing a keyboard from scratch, why not?

    Because it's freakin' pointless, really. Anyway, why only a dozen? Why not 100m?

    --
    systemd is Roko's Basilisk.
    1. Re:Ugh, another pointless video by YrWrstNtmr · · Score: 1

      Please mod the parent to 11.

    2. Re:Ugh, another pointless video by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

      I've said this before and got modded down to hell for it, but it's the truth so I'll keep on saying it: GNU/Linux/FOSS/Hacker Society types are terrible at producing multimedia. From gaudy design choices to less than amateur production quality, a huge majority of the stuff they produce is awful shit.

    3. Re:Ugh, another pointless video by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Stop being such a fucking pointless and idiotic hater. The starting countdown of the video is over a picture of the device, plus there's the possibility of clicking the link to the actual kickstarter and checking it out while you listen to the boring talking heads.

      But you don't really want to learn about the project, do you?
      You just want to bitch about Slashdot on Salshdot, don't you?
      Here's a thing you might want to try: If you don't like something and it's not hurting anyone - Ignore it. Go do something useful. Don't post a half-assed bullshit complaint just to show everyone whose approval you disdain but secretly crave how superior you are.

      Yes, i do understand irony, but because i care about you and want you to stop failing at human, i'm giving you this very loving verbal kick in the pants.

  8. now everyone will own a 300 keyboard by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    so like if my hands are larger can I get a custom key layout?

    The only reason to ever spend more than $2 on a keyboard is if it is wireless and solar powered.

    1. Re:now everyone will own a 300 keyboard by aaaaaaargh! · · Score: 1

      There are plenty of good reasons to spend $80 or more on a keyboard, but that doesn't mean you should consider a wooden 'artisanal' keyboard. Try Unicomp or Cherry keyboards, for example, typing on one of those feels so great that you'll never want to go back to any cheap "mushy" keyboard.

  9. No tab, have to wait for Dvorak by cfalcon · · Score: 3

    They will at least support custom layouts, but not at launch. So I'll look into it then.

    But I will say this- the idea of holding a function key to get to the rest of the keyboard buttons is a terrible one. Chording has some purpose, but here it really seems bad. Do you want Alt + Tab to become Alt + Function + tilde?

    Nice design. If they add more keys to it natively later it might be worth looking into. Honestly, I'd love a keyboard that has good quality and doesn't enforce that ludicrous Qwerty stuff. Sure, sure, touch typing, but it would be great to have the keys do what they say instead of being all lies (unless you use a really old or featureless keyboard).

    1. Re:No tab, have to wait for Dvorak by mattventura · · Score: 3

      But I will say this- the idea of holding a function key to get to the rest of the keyboard buttons is a terrible one. Chording has some purpose, but here it really seems bad. Do you want Alt + Tab to become Alt + Function + tilde?

      It depends entirely on what keys we're talking about. Yes, I would much rather hit Ctrl-U/D than PgUp/PgDn, Ctrl-A instead of Home, and plenty of others, because anything outside the alphanumeric can easily end up taking more movement to hit than hitting two keys in the alphanumeric area.

      But the real issue I see with the keyboard is that the layout is so nonstandard that finding any third party keycaps will be a total PITA if not impossible, and very few keyboards actually come with good quality caps that won't wear down/shine. It looks like this thing is more expensive than an ErgoDox with very little advantage over it.

    2. Re:No tab, have to wait for Dvorak by CrashNBrn · · Score: 1

      With the ability to go in any direction they wanted, from a design perspective. I fail to understand why there aren't extra "programmable" keys, it would of interested a much wider audience.

  10. Artisanal keyboard by neminem · · Score: 2

    I'm with Jick on this one:

            It's "artisanal," which means it's more expensive than things that aren't "artisanal." Actually, that's a lie. "Artisanal" doesn't mean anything. Seriously. Look it up.

    (Incidentally, they later reused the same joke, with the random monster modifier effect "artisanal", which as you might guess, does nothing.)

    1. Re:Artisanal keyboard by twotacocombo · · Score: 2

      'Artisanal' is just a bait word to pique the interest of hipsters. And with just as much effect on society as a whole, it can be read 'art is anal'.

  11. No thanks... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

    I'm a gamer, I need access to the entire keyboard with a single hand. I don't just play CoD and LoL.
    And I'm not about to switch keyboard between gaming and typing all the time.

  12. Still not as good as my kinesis. by ezakimak · · Score: 1

    Yes, it has whizbang lights, and the split with thumb keys is moving in a better direction, but my 10-year old kinesis is still a superior layout and design.
    Wake me when they improve on *that* rather than not even catch up.

    1. Re:Still not as good as my kinesis. by ezakimak · · Score: 3

      To elaborate:
      Just looking at the layout I can already tell they haven't done a deep enough analysis. Comparing to my kinesis (which I'm typing on right now), in order to press enter requires radial flexion--so while it will still help, the kinesis requires virtually no radial flexion at all, and at most some ulnar deviation (and only to hit shift, one of the lesser-used, and not for any other key). 101-qwerty keyboards don't generally require any radial flexion at all, but incur a lot of ulnar deviation--so this much change in habit may feel better at first but may also just move symptoms around after a while for anyone with an existing injury.

      Furthermore, by default they require a modifier for F keys, thus to do a normal modifier+F-key combination is now a 3-key chord-- Ctrl-F5 is now Fn-Ctrl-F5, with both modifiers on the thumb--so now it takes either both hands or an awkward thumb motion pressing it down flat to hit both keys. This would make emacs an impossibility. Compare that to a kinesis with dvorak layout. Ctrl-X and Alt-X are nearly a pinching motion between the thumb and first finger--about the most natural motion our hands ever do, and perfectly comfortable to do all day long.

      I cannot make a judgement on the effectiveness of the depth of their keys, but it looks much shallower and likely to require curling the fingers more than the Kinesis does. My guess is the extra curl may become tiresome. The kinesis is "just right"--fingers completely relaxed just fall right on top of the home row, and the majority of keys are merely a single key away from home row. In addition, the keyboardio loses the bottom row, which makes it even less efficient for placement possibilities--requiring more keys to be only accessible via an additional modifier combination.

      Their thumb keys arguably align a little better with keeping the hand and wrist in a neutral position, but they wholesale miss the great opportunity of using a second row of thumb keys--it is one of the most agile digits we have. Kinesis gets this right by putting backspace, delete, enter, and space, four of the most used items as the main keys for thumb access, plus an additional row for modifier and navigation keys--put those thumbs to good use. (Compared to a 101-qwerty that relegates both thumbs to share the singular duty of one key... the space bar--WTF--why is it a full on giant key--as if our thumbs are so poorly coordinated they have trouble aiming?)

      I would definitely prefer one of these over a qwerty, but will continue to vote for kinesis until something even better comes along.

      For people that aren't so picky, or like the bling-bling flashy lights, or need the loud clicks to feel good about typing I say go for it and tell us how you like it.

    2. Re:Still not as good as my kinesis. by ezakimak · · Score: 1

      Correction: I've been using my kinesis for 18 years now. Zero complaints. Solid product--worth every penny--especially considering my livelihood depends on my hands and it's what they touch all day long.

  13. $300 by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Most high end gaming keyboards between 100-200 USD are not made of cheap plastic. I like the API aspect of their keyboard, but a software update for the alluminum body $135 K70 RGB is supposed to be out relatively soon that includes Lua scripting. Keyboardio's price point is just too high.

    1. Re:$300 by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Especially with the cheap wood they're using. At least give us some nice tiger or quilted maple instead of the plain stuff.

  14. Meh by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

    It's quite high. My current split keyboard (Microsoft Sculpt) is pretty flat with the table, so my mouse hand is about at the same height as the keyboard. That wouldn't be the case here.

    It's curved but vertically flat. You can tilt it, but that puts it even higher off the desk.

    There's no numpad. My keyboard has a separate numpad so my mouse can be nearer the centre of my desk. Guess you need to buy one for this?

    Why would I care about your use of maple? I'm really not a fan of the aesthetics, but I've never bought a keyboard for aesthetics and I assume most "uncompromising typists" value function over appearance as well.

    Is the butterfly a Win / Super key?

    I kind of like the idea of additional thumb buttons, so kudos for that. Would prefer having one space button for either thumb though, considering the use it gets.

    Why is there so much vertical variation in the button shapes? The Sculpt has pretty flat buttons, I barely need to lift my finger to move between them and I don't have any issues with mispressed keys.

  15. Two words: Kinesis Contour by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I've been typing on a Kinesis Contour for 14 years and wouldn't use anything else. Worth every penny of the $300 I paid for it.

  16. Tried it. by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

    I tried it at the highway 1 demo day. I was skeptical but I did like the experience, it's cool but I would have a hard time spending that much on one.

    If I was obsessed with keyboards then I'd buy one. For now I'll stick to my 7 year old apple keyboard or my standard dell one

  17. Glorified Ergodox? by burbilog · · Score: 2

    Is it just a clone of Ergodox in fancy wooden box and slightly different PCB?

  18. New meanings to words... by Shoten · · Score: 1

    It seems that these days, "artisanal" is now a clever way of saying "produced and valued by hipster douchebags." And now the word and that corresponding (actual) meaning have intruded into the tech sector.

    --

    For your security, this post has been encrypted with ROT-13, twice.
  19. Bespoke fucks given: not one by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    N/T