Saying "Wasted" On Facebook Can Affect Your Credit Score (ajc.com)

JustAnotherOldGuy writes: According to a recent report by the Financial Times (paywalled), some of the top credit rating companies are now using people's social media accounts to assess their ability to repay debt. "If you look at how many times a person says 'wasted' in their profile, it has some value in predicting whether they're going to repay their debt," Will Lansing, chief executive at credit rating company FICO, told the Financial Times. "It's not much, but it's more than zero." According to the Financial Times, both FICO and TransUnion have had to find "alternative ways" to assess people who don't have a traditional credit profile — including people who haven't borrowed enough to give creditors an idea of what kind of risk they pose.

Comments

I have no debt and a hefty savings account

[Anonymous Coward]

According to lenders this makes me a credit risk.

Re:I have no debt and a hefty savings account

[Anonymous Coward]

This entirely.

The credit systems is quite screwed up. I worked a shitty McJob full time during summer and part time during school (except for the last year where I decided to focus on my studies). Managed to be one of the very few people with a degree and no debt without Mom and Dad paying for it.. and was proud of this. Got a decent job, was still living at home so built up some decent savings, payed for most stuff with cash or debit. Eventually decided to get a credit card, and yup, had to deposit a chunk of cash that I couldn't touch for 6 months before they'd give me one. This would seem entirely reasonable to me, except by this point my sister was in university.. student loans (in her defense, her program was many times more expensive than mine..), and no income (she worked summers but not during the school year).. and banks (including mine, RBC) were practically throwing pre-approvals at her.

Fast forward about 10 years, I now own a house, have a mortgage, a line of credit, credit cards.. basically if I added up all the credit I have available to me it would be multiple times what I make in a year) .. and I get calls all the time from the big banks trying to give me even more.

There was a good(ish) documentary a few years called Maxed out on Debt... if you ignore the annoying drama stuff in the middle, there's some good frank interviews that explain a lot of it. They _want_ people who arn't completely broke but can't afford the credit so they'll keep making minimum payments forever. They want to load you down with more credit than you can afford so you get on that treadmill.

I'm kinda on the fence with regards to how I feel about this. One one hand, the banks are doing some shady stuff and directly trying to set people up for financial disaster for their own benefit. On the other hand, they arn't forcing people to use their credit cards beyond their means. Personally I've managed to never pay interest on any of mine. I guess it's gotta be a middle ground. Much as I hate nanny-state type stuff, I feel like this is one area we may need the government to come in and save people from themselves by restricting how much credit a person can hold based on income or something.

Re:I have no debt and a hefty savings account

[Anonymous Coward]

I used to do phone support for Capital One credit card and they determined that if the first transaction you make with your card is cash, it's likely you will max the card and not pay it back.

What happens is you get your new card, you go to the ATM, get declined, phone in then CS tells you it's for 'security reasons' to 'protect you from fraud' then asked you to fax in 3 or 4 pieces of ID to 'verify yourself'. After that, they tell you the information was illegible and that they can't reinstate your card.

I can understand them declining people who are a likely risk but literally telling them a bold faced lie is what kind of surprised me. They used to refer to Capital One as "Cap One" for short, I'm not sure if they caught how appropriate "Capone" was to describe the way they do business.

Re:I have no debt and a hefty savings account

[Aristos Mazer]

> On the other hand, they arn't forcing people to use their credit cards beyond their means.

If you look at a lot of the ads that they send us, those ads suggest strongly that they're making the offer because it *is* within your means. These people with advanced math degrees say you're a great person to get this credit... it's easy to start thinking they understand something about your finances that you've missed if you don't really grasp the terms "compound interest" and "APR" etc. I think the sales pitch often crosses the line into dishonesty. Not always, but frequently.

Re:I have no debt and a hefty savings account

[chipschap]

I too have 800+ credit scores, very good savings, and a paid-off home. Therein lies the problem. I don't have any debt any more, and while I use credit cards for nearly everything, I never carry a balance beyond the payment due dates. I've been retired for a while and have a steady pension income that is quite adequate.

So I asked for an increase in my credit card limit, and was turned down, with the EXPLICIT statement, "You don't have enough debt." Not "your credit isn't good enough"--- they as much as said my credit was just fine.

In other words they see that in their industry I am, and will remain, what is called a "deadbeat." This does not mean a non-payer, this means someone who PAYS and doesn't carry balances, thereby denying the banks the opportunity to collect interest at extortionate interest rates.

Is there something wrong with this whole system?

Re:I have no debt and a hefty savings account

[thoromyr]

A point of clarification: the credit card *never* loses money on a cardholder. Merchants have to pay the issuer for every transaction. This more than covers the issuers fixed costs.

However, consider two customers who buy exactly the same amount each month. Customer A earns the card issuer $5 in merchant processing fees, but because he pays off the amount at the end of the month there is no interest. Over the course of a year the issuer will only make $60.

Customer B also earns the issuer $5 in merchant processing fees, but only makes the minimum payment of $300 so there is an interest gain of $45. With the same credit limit and both maxing it out, customer B only manages an additional $1/month in merchant processing fees for the rest of the year, but the total take is over $556.

If customer A only earns you $60 and customer B earns you $556 -- which customer do you prefer?

Now comes the fun part. If you raise customer A's limit you will get only a marginal profit increase if they fully utilize it. If you double it from a $3000 limit to $6000 you have increased volume you only get another $60. But if you double customer B's limit then you get another $556.

And the funny thing is, people who max their card will max it out again soon after a limit increase. *And* they will usually keep making the (new, higher) monthly payments. Of course, there *is* a limit. Which is why an issuer won't double the limit, they use smaller increases instead. But getting near that limit is really good for the issuer. Not just from maximizing the minimum payment, but from fees.

Eventually, customer B will have a bad month and not make the minimum payment. Maybe they'll forget the payment, maybe a medical expense, maybe their car broke down. Whatever it was, it will be an unavoidable expense. So instead of only making $45 from accrued interest, they get another $50 from a late payment. Oh, but that bumped the card over the limit, which is another $50 fee.

For the issuer, this is a wonderful situation because they get all of the benefits of a higher monthly payment without any of the risk associated with a higher balance. If customer B gets caught up at some point then its time to increase their limit (if you haven't already speculatively done so) in order to make it easier for them to miss a payment.

Yes, numbers provided are not exact. But they are in the ball park. I used 18% APR, but I've seen cards with over 24%. I've seen low interest cards though I've never had one myself: I pay the balance off each month so I'm "high risk" for them ever seeing a profit and consequently only get offers for high interest/annual fee cards. But things will change if ever have trouble making payments....