Slashdot Mirror


Mysterious Gamma-Ray Burst May Be Linked To Gravitational Wave Find (latimes.com)

mdsolar quotes a report from Los Angeles Times: After a decades-long search, scientists announced early this year that they had detected gravitational waves probably coming from the merger of two black holes back in September. Now, a team of scientists using NASA's Fermi Gamma-ray Space Telescope say they spotted a brief flash of gamma rays that occurred less than half a second after that long-sought gravitational wave signal. The gamma-ray outburst, described at the American Physical Society's April meeting in Salt Lake City, has not been definitively linked to that first gravitational wave signal, and scientists weren't able to pinpoint its exact origin -- just that they came from the same general area. But if other astronomers begin to find a similar pattern, the results do raise the intriguing possibility that such high-energy events might not be quite as 'invisible' as we thought. The first gravitational wave signal rolled through the Laser Interferometer Gravitational-wave Observatory on Sept. 14, hitting the Louisiana detector first and then the one in Washington state seven milliseconds later, telling researchers that the signal must have come from the southern hemisphere.

2 of 76 comments (clear)

  1. More likely explanation by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Insightful

    I'm skeptical that gravitational waves have been detected. I'm a seismologist at a major west coast university and I've seen signals like this before. The most likely cause of the wave is a low amplitude s-wave moving north from seismic activity perhaps in the southern hemisphere. In the rush to find gravitational waves, it doesn't seem like the other, more plausible explanations have been ruled out.

    1. Re:More likely explanation by wonkey_monkey · · Score: 3, Insightful

      I had no idea seismology was such a covert field that you can't tell us which "major west coast university" you work at. Are you worried about receiving hate-mail from earthquake deniers?

      The most likely cause of the wave is a low amplitude s-wave moving north from seismic activity...

      ...at the speed of light?

      In the rush to find gravitational waves, it doesn't seem like the other, more plausible explanations have been ruled out.

      Just because they didn't explicitly state "oh, and by the way, it definitely wasn't s-waves, we checked", doesn't mean they haven't done their job. They'd be there forever if they had to list everything it definitely wasn't.

      --
      systemd is Roko's Basilisk.