Slashdot Mirror
Ask Slashdot: Should The DHS Designate Elections As Critical Infrastructure? (politico.com)
The Department of Homeland Security is reportedly looking at designating elections as critical infrastructure, on par with the electricity grid or banking system, to help protect against cybersecurity threats. DHS Secretary Jeh Johnson said during a breakfast with reporters on August 3rd, "We should carefully consider whether our election system, our election process, is critical infrastructure. There is a vital national interest in our election process, so I do think to consider whether it should be considered by my department and others as critical infrastructure." Demerara writes: I'm fascinated to hear the opinions of Slashdotters on the practical implications of any decision to designate "elections" as critical national infrastructure. For those of you who have worked on systems that are already under this regime: given that there are just over 90 days to the November elections, what can be achieved with respect to elections and in particular to electronic voting machines (whether direct-recording electronic (DRE), touch screen etc., or precinct ballot scanning machines)? What might the designation require of state and county boards (the buyers of these systems) and what would the vendors have to do?
then fix the difficulty in getting the ID,
It is not that simple. Getting the ID is only part of the problem. Losing it, and forgetting it on election day, are also problems. But Dems and Reps are equally likely to lose/forget, so that is a wash, right? WRONG. Democrats are significantly more likely to be dysfunctional people. This was clear in Florida in 2000 when Dems were more likely to fill out ballots incorrectly, thus invalidating their votes. Democrats are significantly more likely to lose/forget critical items, and voter ID cards systematically discriminate against them. You make be okay with that, and you may feel that we would be better off with fewer incompetent, dysfunctional people voting. But the bottom line is that voter ID laws skew elections toward Republicans and against the people at the bottom of the socioeconomic ladder.