Slashdot Mirror

← Back to Stories (view on slashdot.org)

Microsoft Weaponizes Minecraft In the War Over Classrooms (backchannel.com)

Posted by EditorDavid on from the better-than-Oregon-Trail dept.

Minecraft: Education Edition offers lesson plans like "City Planning for Population Growth" and "Effects of Deforestation," and a June preview attracted more than 25,000 students and teachers from 40 different countries. Slashdot reader mirandakatz writes: In the two years since Microsoft acquired Minecraft's parent company, it's discovered a brilliant new direction to take the game: it's turning it into a tool for education, creating both an innovative approach to classroom technology and an inspired strategy for competing with Google and Apple in the ed-tech market. 'I actually never believed there would be a game that would really cross over between the commercial entertainment market and education in a mainstream way,' says cultural anthropologist Mimi Ito—but Minecraft has managed to do just that.
In 2015 Chromebooks represented over 50% of PC sales for U.S. schools, while Windows PC accounted for just 22%, the article reports. But Minecraft is the second best-selling game of all time, behind only Tetris, and in the two years since Microsoft acquired it, "Sales have doubled to almost 107 million copies sold... If you were to count each copy sold as representing one person, the resulting population would be the world's 12th largest country (after Japan)." And as the article points out, "wherever Minecraft goes, Microsoft is there."

55 comments

  1. IT IS CALLED MINECRAFT by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    So to make it go BOOM! real good is by design!

  2. What a dumbfuck comment by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Dumbfuck comments like yours are ruining Slashdot. Please leave.

    1. Re:What a dumbfuck comment by JustBoo · · Score: 1

      Dumbfuck comments like yours are ruining Slashdot. Please leave.

      These are the Reddit Rejects (original poster) who think their little one-liners are the height of intellectual discourse. Further proof is wherever they post, they still think they are posting to reddit.

  3. Wut by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 2, Interesting

    How the fuck does Minecraft constitute ed-tech?
    Is anything ed-tech these days? Watching wall paint dry teaches me chemistry and thermodynamics about as much as Mincraft teaches me math, physics, programming, and chemistry.

    1. Re:Wut by 0100010001010011 · · Score: 3, Interesting

      You can build an 8-bit computer in minecraft. Red stone is basic logic gates. People have built fully automated tools and processes using very basic resources.

      I'd hire a top Minecraft builder to build my Simulink models over most Engineers I've seen that use it.

      I'm interested in what paint drying you're watching that teaches you that much about chemistry and thermo.

    2. Re:Wut by 0100010001010011 · · Score: 1

      You mean the way that's boring and doesn't get the students engaged in the learning? Yeah. We tried that. It doesn't work for a majority of students.

    3. Re:Wut by Pseudonym · · Score: 5, Insightful

      How the fuck does Minecraft constitute ed-tech?

      To be fair, if anyone can take all the fun out of Minecraft, Microsoft can.

      --
      sub f{($f)=@_;print"$f(q{$f});";}f(q{sub f{($f)=@_;print"$f(q{$f});";}f});
    4. Re:Wut by Plus1Entropy · · Score: 2

      You can play Minecraft in Creative mode, where you have unlimited access to all the resources and blocks, and can place/destroy them instantly.

      --
      Only crack the nuts that crack. You don't put the ones that don't crack in the sack.
    5. Re:Wut by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I've had the most boring physics professor in elementary school who made me hate physics, and then the most amazing and fun guy in high-school who brought physics back from the dead for me. He didn't need a fucking video game to engage me.

      It's not that you didn't try to engage students, but that you have the personality and creative capacity of pile of cow dung next to a road.
      So instead of introducing video games to distract students, maybe it is the teachers who should be taught to act more like humans and less like boring robots who need a computer to ironically replace the humanity they should possess.

    6. Re:Wut by 0100010001010011 · · Score: 1

      This Anonymous Coward learned one way in school so therefore all students will learn the same way. We've solved all of the educational issues because Anonymous Coward found the one way that they learned.

    7. Re:Wut by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Actually, Carl Sagan and a few others solved it. How to engage kids in various subjects. The starting point is not having such low cognitive standards as you do.

    8. Re:Wut by AthanasiusKircher · · Score: 3, Informative

      You can build an 8-bit computer in minecraft. Red stone is basic logic gates. People have built fully automated tools and processes using very basic resources.

      And frequently in rather unrealistic ways. Don't get me wrong -- I recognize Minecraft is a GAME and thus uses different logic from the real world. Like any game with some creative components, it allows users to figure out how to exploit the game rules to do interesting things.

      I'm interested in what paint drying you're watching that teaches you that much about chemistry and thermo.

      Hmm... well, let's see...

      10 THINGS MINECRAFT TAUGHT ME ABOUT CHEMISTRY AND THERMO:

      (1) Water comes in blocks and stays in blocks... sometimes. But when you carry it up a mountain in a round bucket and put a block of it on the ground, it spontaneously regenerates and can produce a giant waterfall.
      (2) If I have two water "blocks," I can make infinite water forever.
      (3) Water has a large enough viscosity that you can swim up a waterfall.
      (4) Torches have a magical fuel source that can burn forever.
      (5) For some reason, torches can't show light when you carry them, but will produce light forever when placed on a surface.
      (6) Cows are magically able to produce unlimited amounts of milk.
      (7) Weirdly, carnivorous diets are much more energy efficient than vegetarian diets. Animals somehow magically create more energy for consumption, the opposite of in the real world. (E.g., consider how many pieces of wheat it takes to breed a new cow (and how much energy/life you'd get by consuming that wheat) vs. how much energy/life you get when you slaughter the new cow and eat the meat.)
      (8) Obsidian is a weirdly strong material rather than in the real world where it's a brittle glass that fractures under stress relatively easily.
      (9) Chemistry of materials is apparently very sensitive to direction. If you let water flow in different directions toward molten rock (lava), you'll get at least four different outcomes.
      (10) If you want electricity, you have to go out and find this stuff called "redstone," which can be mined and produce infinite sources of power. (And it behaves in all sorts of irrational ways.)

      I could go on. And this doesn't even get into the nonsense "chemistry" of "potions", etc. in Minecraft, the fact that making anything is usually just a matter of some obscure placement of items in the correct positions (maybe roasting something in the oven), or the complete nonsense physics.

      Meanwhile, by observing paint drying, particularly with decent tools and meters, I may be able to get a more realistic perspective precipitate and solid formation, realistic viscosity, polymer chemistry, effects of thermodynamics on evaporation and mass transfer, changes in reflection and frequencies of light interaction from pigments in various situations, etc.

      Again, this is NOT a criticism of the game mechanics of Minecraft. But saying it "teaches" you stuff about chemistry and thermo isn't very accurate... it just "teaches" you how to play a game. Along the way, it might teach abstract logical skills -- the same way doing geometrical proofs, composing rote sentences in Latin, and other stuff people used to do did. I'm not advocating for the latter, just noting the kind of "knowledge" gained from Minecraft is more abstract -- learning to follow recipes, being creative within the arbitrary constraints of a system/world, utilizing resources wisely, etc.

    9. Re:Wut by ArmoredDragon · · Score: 1

      Weirdly, carnivorous diets are much more energy efficient than vegetarian diets.

      From the perspective of a human consumer, it absolutely is. Your body has to do very little to extract nourishment from meat and can sustain itself for far longer on meat than any other food source. Meanwhile, it has to do a lot to extract it from plant matter, and in fact our bodies can't even extract nourishment from most plants, save for those we've selectively bred over thousands of years to be less fibrous. This is why true herbivores can survive well off of just any grass or leaves, but we'll starve if we try to do so.

    10. Re:Wut by AthanasiusKircher · · Score: 1

      Weirdly, carnivorous diets are much more energy efficient than vegetarian diets.

      From the perspective of a human consumer, it absolutely is. Your body has to do very little to extract nourishment from meat and can sustain itself for far longer on meat than any other food source.

      You completely missed my point. I'm NOT talking about the "energy balance" inside the human body. I'm talking about the overall energy required to produce food, i.e., the thermodynamics of food creation in Minecraft. In the real world, all that nutrition in meat comes at a price -- you need to feed animals LOTS of food (some of which might instead be consumed by humans directly) as well as other resources to obtain that meat. In the real world, vegetables and grains may be less nourishing per pound, but if a human ate the same amount of vegetables and grains required to create one pound of meat, they would get more energy from the vegetables and grains than from the pound of meat.

      In sum, eating meat IS more nutritionally efficient (pound for pound), but you have to pay a larger cost in energy resources to produce that nutritionally efficient food than if you ate the vegetables directly.

      That isn't true in Minecraft, where the equivalent amount of food fed to animals will breed them to produce meat which creates even more energy than the vegetable food your started with.

      On an even more ridiculous level, when you cook a steak in Minecraft, it somehow satisfies roughly 3 times more hunger than raw meat. Yes, cooking does make meat easier to digest for humans and will release some nutrients, but it's not like it now has triple the extractable calories.

      Again, it's a game, so I don't care so much about whether it aligns with real life. Obviously in Minecraft they're trying to model something different by eating, something closer to satisfying "satiety" or whatever, rather than actually modeling how much food is equivalent to sustain your weight over the long term or whatever. But Minecraft is also about resource management -- some things are rare and others are harder to make, and sometimes you have to make trade-offs based on resources available. Energy is also a finite resource and the fact is that food in Minecraft spontaneously acquires more of it when you transfer from vegetable to animal form and then when you cook it. So, Minecraft is effectively modeling a situation where creation of animal food for human consumption is more efficient than simply eating the plant food without the animal intermediary. It may be more efficient (again, pound-for-pound) for humans to eat meat (and perhaps more tasty), but it's NOT more efficient from an overall resource perspective in the real world. Energy balances simply can't work that way.

    11. Re:Wut by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Redstone is not "basic logic gates". It's a cumbersome, glitchy, fragile, painful way to design pseudo-electronics that no one would seriously use if Circuitlab had online multiplayer. Unfortunately though, it's turing-complete, so some of the autists who play minecraft (not singling out minecraft, there are autists everywhere) take it upon themselves to spend months translating the schematics of basic electronic devices into redstone builds that wind up being as big as effing cities when they're complete.

      Designing electronics in redstone is like writing a piece of business software in Brainfuck. Yes you need to be smart to do it, but the fact that you tried says way more about you than the fact that you succeeded.

    12. Re:Wut by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      They'll breed unfed.

      The perpetual motion machines are plentiful in Minecraft.

    13. Re:Wut by matbury · · Score: 1

      Hi AthanasiusKircher, I wouldn't worry too much about kids learning bad physics from Minecraft. They probably aren't learning anything other than how to play Minecraft.

      So, they're claiming that Minecraft is useful for achieving educational learning outcomes. Where's the evidence? What are the effect sizes, what are they for, and under what conditions? I've managed to find two papers that discuss effect sizes; one simply claims that proficiency at Minecraft is a good indicator of already developed spatial temporal reasoning, the other was for teaching spatial-temporal reasoning but for a single, simple instance, and under very specific conditions that are unlikely to be replicated in real-world classrooms. Of course, the media are going to continue to run with stories about how Minecraft are great for education without doing any fact-checking, just like they did with Fold-It, which although it was excellent for performing chemical manipulations that computers couldn't do for researchers, turned out not to teach anyone playing the game anything useful.

      I foresee a generation of college graduates with Minecraft skills on their resumes.

    14. Re:Wut by allcoolnameswheretak · · Score: 1

      I think the actual strength of a game like Minecraft is not that it teaches you anything, but that it raises interests in things like architecture, electronics, farming, geography, etc. So it inspires kids to learn real-world things.
      I got interested in history, cultures and politics thanks to the Civilization games. Though I doubt the Civ games tought me much in and by themselves.

    15. Re:Wut by leedzung · · Score: 1

      Maybe your Minecraft had a conflict with any software. You should download the latest version and reinstall. You can download at: http://downloadminecraftpe.com.... Have fun!!!

  4. Requires W10 or El Capitan by lecithin · · Score: 4, Informative

    I taught a Minecraft class last year at our school last year for 3rd-8th grade kids. They tolerated Minecraft EDU, but would rather just play on servers or in LAN world as a regular Minecraft Client.

    They won't be having the class this year as the Education Edition requires them to upgrade their lab to Windows 10. They aren't going to do that and want linux in the classroom. Now that Education Edition requires W10 for both client/server, I no longer have any interest in the 'value add' of the EDU product.

    I can almost appreciate the need for a W10 server, but requiring all clients to be on W10? No thanks.

    --
    It could be worse, it could be Monday.
    1. Re:Requires W10 or El Capitan by drinkypoo · · Score: 2

      What's so great about edu edition anyway? You can get mods that give you programmable blocks and whatnot so it seems like an educational mod pack would be just as good in every way, maybe better in some.

      --
      "You're right," Fisheye says. "I should have set it on 'whip' or 'chop.'"
    2. Re:Requires W10 or El Capitan by lecithin · · Score: 2, Informative

      I completely agree and that is why I recommended 'standard' edition. This was refused by the school because they have been sold on the EDU edition. The value adds are minimal, with the exception is that it was 'free'.

      --
      It could be worse, it could be Monday.
    3. Re:Requires W10 or El Capitan by 0100010001010011 · · Score: 1

      After looking through my kids future school's budget I really want to know how your school district started looking at Linux in the classroom.

      They were proud that they saved $20k on anti-virus software by buying in bulk... without saying how much they spent.

    4. Re:Requires W10 or El Capitan by LienRag · · Score: 1

      Have you tried Minetest?

  5. 'Weaponize' ? by lbalbalba · · Score: 3, Insightful

    So education is 'weaponizing' now ?
    Note to ./ editors : stop making overly sensationalist headlines. Please.

    1. Re:'Weaponize' ? by drinkypoo · · Score: 3, Insightful

      So education is 'weaponizing' now ?

      No, tying a "free" educational release to Windows 10 is weaponizing it. There's obviously nothing so special about Minecraft that it would require any of the new APIs in Windows 10. Minecraft edu edition is part of Microsoft's strategy for spreading Windows Spyware Edition. There's nothing about minecraft edu that's superior to just using some mods with MC aside from the price, so this is not about education. This is about inducing schools to move to Windows 10.

      --
      "You're right," Fisheye says. "I should have set it on 'whip' or 'chop.'"
    2. Re:'Weaponize' ? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      > There's obviously nothing so special about Minecraft that it would require any of the new APIs in Windows 10.
      Any evidence to back that up?

    3. Re: 'Weaponize' ? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      clearly it needs a one line function in the windows 10 api that returns true.

      bool isWindows10()

    4. Re:'Weaponize' ? by _Sharp'r_ · · Score: 1

      Naw, you guys are missing the proper context for the title.

      There is a "war" over what kind of government propaganda to feed kids in classrooms.

      Clearly, with titles like "City Planning for Population Growth" and "Effects of Deforestation" , Microsoft has created new weapons for the left-wing radical environmental side in the "war".

      But don't worry, the propaganda is already so ingrained in our teachers and school system that most people won't even notice what they've done here...

      --
      The party of stupid and the party of evil get together and do something both stupid and evil, then call it bipartisan.
    5. Re:'Weaponize' ? by rtb61 · · Score: 1

      Your forget that windows 10 than also forces the use of Windows Office as obvious package deals and all those purchases, well special deals for the people, the individuals making the purchases and free trial copies for them et al. So corrupt business practices continue.

      --
      Chaos - everything, everywhere, everywhen
    6. Re:'Weaponize' ? by drinkypoo · · Score: 1

      There's obviously nothing so special about Minecraft that it would require any of the new APIs in Windows 10.

      Any evidence to back that up?

      Okay, have a cookie: "Minecraft: Windows 10 Edition is an adaptation of Minecraft Pocket Edition to run on the universal Windows 10 platform. It contains the same features as in Pocket Edition with a few additions, and is also capable of running on devices such as the HoloLens. [...] In addition to features existing in Pocket Edition, the Windows 10 Edition also has the ability to play with up to seven players using Xbox Live and also others using Pocket Edition through Pocket Realms or local multiplayer with an update that was released shortly after the initial beta version. Some other additional exclusive features include multiple control schemes, a player feedback feature, and the ability to record and share gameplay with Windows 10's built in GameDVR." So there you go, I was wrong (gasp): there is one feature in the new MC that requires Windows 10. However, it is not central to the product, and could easily simply be left off of versions for prior editions of Windows. I'm going to file this under "irrelevant to the point".

      --
      "You're right," Fisheye says. "I should have set it on 'whip' or 'chop.'"
  6. Microsoft haven't "discovered" a direction by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1, Insightful

    They haven't "discovered" anything. Mojang has had a long history of social activism and using Minecraft for educational purposes, long before Markus sold everyone at the company up the river to Microsoft. Vu, Lydia and Owen did more to do good with the brand than Microsoft can ever hope to do by simply using the brand as a screwdriver in their toolbox to drive mindshare to their own products.

  7. Have you looked into migrating to... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

    Minetest?

    It is minecraft using C++ and lua. Doesn't necessarily have every feature of minecraft, but it runs on windows, osx, linux, android, and a few others. If there are necessary restrictions you need for running it at school they should be doable with the source code or the extremely friendly user community.

    Furthermore its resource usage is extremely low. You can run it on a pentium 2 or 3 with an OpenGL 2.1 card. Maybe even lower, but that is pushing the minimum frame rate boundaries.

    If you get a chance check it out. If we could get enough push going on esp in the education community, we could blunt M$'s whole minecraft push and get more people friendly with open source at the same time :)

  8. Cross Platform Sales by Luthair · · Score: 1

    Are probably to a lot of the same people.

    1. Re:Cross Platform Sales by diamondmagic · · Score: 1

      Same goes for Tetris, how many platforms has that been ported to?

      The versions aren't even all that dissimilar, why don't we just aggregate all the versions of Madden together while we're at it?

      --
      Wonder what the public key field is for?
  9. Finally by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0, Insightful

    I knew MS was going to ruin Minecraft eventually.

    1. Re:Finally by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

      Meh, all MS is doing is cashing in as hard as they can on the last gasps of popularity of an old game. They're driving it into the ground faster than it otherwise would've gone to be sure, but it was headed there soon enough. Really, modding is the only thing that's kept it going this long anyway (and that's not a thing in the new editions).

      Minecraft was perfect after about version 1.6 or 1.7 and has been stagnant or on the decline since. Even before MS got ahold of it, Mojang had gotten to the point that they were basically adding random crap or aimlessly tinkering with things just for the sake of having something to put together and call an 'update'. Popularity was waning, people were outgrowing the game, and Mojang's (good and necessary) decision to ban p2w servers had the side effect of hurting the quantity and quality of public servers in general.

      Now they're giving away their crippled version with Win 10 or selling it for 75% off the normal price as a phone app and using the inflated numbers to say it's as popular as ever.

  10. Snake sold far more by Stormwatch · · Score: 1

    But Minecraft is the second best-selling game of all time, behind only Tetris

    If you count games bundled with a system, the best-selling game ever is certainly Snake, as it came with pretty much every Nokia cell phone since 1997. That must be well over a billion devices.

    --
    Circumcision is child abuse.
  11. Deforrestation by JBMcB · · Score: 2

    Pretty good simulation of deforestation. If you don't chop down trees and built a fort, the zombies eat you.

    --
    My Other Computer Is A Data General Nova III.
    1. Re:Deforrestation by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      You can always make a shelter with dirt

    2. Re:Deforrestation by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I tried that, it took too long. Instead I used flint and steel to burn it down. Even felt the heat a bit, current Minecraft seems to have a small performance issue with large area fires.

  12. ScraM: All the benefits, without the lock-in by AirHog · · Score: 1

    If you're interested in introducing kids to coding in Minecraft, but without the Windows 10 lock-in, try out ScraM: http://scram.frequal.com

    Don't throw away your Minecraft PC or Pocket edition licenses, you can use your existing hardware and software with ScraM. Mods and minigames you and your students create work in PC and Pocket Edition, from Linux, Windows, Mac, iOS, or Android.

    ScraM: Mod Once, Play Anywhere!

    See how easy it is to get started with ScraM in these YouTube videos: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCOonteTB8NQmyz5rG2Slxpw

    Or log in to ScraM right now from Minecraft at: us.frequal.com

        -ScraM Team

  13. Great by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Except that it is just *one* tool. Trying to base an entire cirriculum on it is going to fail. Also, anyone that thinks Google is interested in anything but $$$ is not paying attention, they have imposed themselves on education, they were not and are not sought out, asked for, or invited. Ditto Gates et.al. Tech readers really need to get their heads out of the sand, or at the least, out of the freaking valley. It is NOT the world, nor is it representative of it.

    Go here. This is what pretty much everyone else thinks of tech corporations' and individuals' blatant greed. They aren't fooling anyone outside of a bay area zip code.

    https://dianeravitch.net

  14. Disgusting by s.petry · · Score: 4, Insightful

    Education _IS_ entertainment. The most brilliant minds in history were not surrounded by circus clowns and gladiators to learn, they took pleasure in learning because the end result is finding more knowledge and teaching others. The Academy in Athens was not full of hookers and cocaine, yet it produced the overwhelming majority of Political Philosophy we see today, the majority of the Mathematics we use and see today, and extended a language which became the root of most languages spoken today. Socrates died middle class yet taught, and still teaches those willing to *gasp* read a book today. Aristotle s Trig and early Calculus, Euclid's Geometry, and Pythagoras's Math are still taught today. They did it without bright flashy lights and everyone being required to path them on the back and get trophies for "trying".

    We have immense problems with Government mandated "common core" and that's after more than a half a century of curriculum cutting and reorganization to turn "Education" into "Indoctrination". And you want "entertainment"? Are you speaking from a position of ignorance or insanity?

    Either way, you and people making these types of statements and demands make me understand why the USA has gone from one of the top places in the World for education to the 29th for math and science. This is not a problem of kids being dumb, it's a problem of parents being dumb and believing propaganda over facts.

    --

    -The wise argue that there are few absolutes, the fool argues that there are no probabilities.

    1. Re:Disgusting by drinkypoo · · Score: 1

      Aristotle s Trig and early Calculus, Euclid's Geometry, and Pythagoras's Math are still taught today. They did it without bright flashy lights and everyone being required to path them on the back and get trophies for "trying".

      Yes, but today we have bright flashy lights for shit like cold sore cream, and you have to compete with that.

      --
      "You're right," Fisheye says. "I should have set it on 'whip' or 'chop.'"
    2. Re:Disgusting by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Shit, I need some cold sore cream. Could you tell the phone number from that billboard you saw?

    3. Re:Disgusting by PPalmgren · · Score: 1

      Making education entertaining conditions children into enjoying education. A common thread among the geniuses of the past is that they all started education at a very early age and it was ground into them, so they almost instinctively had it become their raison d'tere. Not everyone has that kind of upbringing. LEGO has created more engineers than ENG101 because it taught children how to enjoy the process of building, regardless of whether that was their original inclination. The same has been done with computer games and programming. Now we're seeing attempts to do the same via Minecraft.

      You can't roll back the clock, so talking about the good old days doesn't solve anything. Work with where we are now, the world we are in today.

    4. Re:Disgusting by s.petry · · Score: 1

      Making education entertaining conditions children into enjoying education.

      Prove it. If that was true today's society would be producing a populace with higher IQs than we have previously had, yet we have a massive reduction in IQ's over the last 70 or so years. Facts show you are wrong, and was the point of my post. How many people were patting Descartes on the back and giving him and his classmates participation trophies? How many circuses did Einstein attend during the public portion of his schooling? He dropped out because it was easy, not because he was not entertained. Socrates must have been surrounded by all of the artists and courtesans in Athens, show me some proof that he was "entertained" to learn.

      A common thread among the geniuses of the past is that they all started education at a very early age and it was ground into them, so they almost instinctively had it become their raison d'tere.

      Veritably untrue if you are using a generalization akin to modern schools. We start kids in School at 4 to 5 years old today, way before kids were walking miles and miles to and from school. Most kids at 4-5 were taught at home and performed menial chores. Interest in education starts young, but school is not the culprit for sparking interest.

      You can't roll back the clock, so talking about the good old days doesn't solve anything. Work with where we are now, the world we are in today.

      I may be cynical but I ground my position in facts. You on the other hand are defeatist and don't seem to care much about facts. So you lose, give me my way! My side has to win every couple hundred years to put reality back in place. Seriously, check a history book sometime.

      --

      -The wise argue that there are few absolutes, the fool argues that there are no probabilities.

  15. Eventually? by s.petry · · Score: 1

    It was ruined right after they bought it. It was hard to notice because Mojang's earlier versions worked just fine in stand alone or with the Mojang provided server.

    --

    -The wise argue that there are few absolutes, the fool argues that there are no probabilities.

  16. Minetest is a better alternative at school by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Minetest (http://minetest.net) is already used by teachers (in France and other places) :
    http://www.ocsmag.com/2016/04/04/mining-for-education/
    https://framablog.org/2016/09/01/framinetest-edu-laissez-microsoft-hors-de-portee-de-nos-enfants/ (FR)
    and it's *way better* because :
    open source,
    works on old computers as well as tablet, Raspi, you name it,
    you can easily adapt it to your needs,
    you can really teach kids to code by modifying the game : 11yo kid can do it even spontaneously as proven in http://svtuxboxproject.pagesperso-orange.fr/svtuxboxproject/minetest-pedago.html (FR)
    Minecraft is only there because of the big money of M$, you can do without the chains !

  17. Re:most brilliant minds by slashrio · · Score: 1

    Most people learning physiscs in school aren't 'the most brilliant minds', so if minecraft can help motivate them it has my blessing.

    --
    "Trump!!", the new Godwin.
  18. Knowledge Should Pull by ememisya · · Score: 1

    Isn't this a bit like sneaking kale and spinach in the burger? It's good for you but that's not why you eat a burger.