Slashdot Mirror
Is Your Internet Connection Free From Bufferbloat? (blogspot.com)
Bufferbloat is that "undesirable latency that comes from a router or other network equipment buffering too much data," according to the site for
an ongoing project trying to address it. Now long-time Slashdot reader mtaht writes:Inside the lede-project, two core new bufferbloat-fighting techniques are poised to enter the linux mainline kernel and thousands of routers -- the first being a fq-codel'd and airtime fair scheduler for wifi, and the second, the new "cake" qdisc, which outperforms fq_codel across the board for shaping inbound and outbound connections.
His submission ends with a question for Slashdot readers. "It's been nearly six years since the start of the bufferbloat project. Have you or has your ISP fixed your bufferbloat yet?"
His submission ends with a question for Slashdot readers. "It's been nearly six years since the start of the bufferbloat project. Have you or has your ISP fixed your bufferbloat yet?"
...is what slows my connection speed down. Fuck, I could have a gigabit connection and would spend 80% of my time waiting for the next version of ad.doubleclick.net, etc. Really? Bufferbloat? I wish!
Badly managed buffers are a massive problem for latency. Just look at this graph from the article. You see the four ping time measurements on the right? You see how one of them is 100-250ms and the rest are more like 20ms? That's exactly the same link in all cases, but the first measurement has a giant pile of latency introduced purely by poor buffer management.
I'm not going to dismiss the problem you described, because I agree it's a problem. But it makes no sense to worry about 100ms on cross-Atlantic links and yet completely dismiss 200ms right on the first hop.
It doesn't matter how big or small the buffer is, what matters is why it's filling up to start with.
If you're buffering because of a transient traffic spike or network load, then the buffer helps. If it's constantly filling up and evicting then there's a deeper problem that won't be solved either by using, eliminating, or changing the buffering strategy.