Slashdot Mirror


Research Suggests Effects of Shift Work or Jet Lag On Our Body Clocks Can Be Reduced By Simply Changing Meal Times (qz.com)

Jonathan Johnston reports via Quartz: Around one in five people in Western countries could be putting their health at risk simply by going to work. This is because working shifts outside of the rest of the population's normal hours has been linked to obesity, diabetes, heart disease, cancer and even declines in brain function. Scientists think this is because our bodies are programmed to run on cycles known as circadian rhythms, and changes in our routine caused by shift work or traveling long distances disrupts those rhythms. But our new research suggests that the effects of shift work or jet lag on our body clocks could be reduced simply by changing the times at which people eat. The key to this theory is the idea that each person doesn't just have a single body clock but rather a complex network of billions of cellular clocks found throughout the body. In humans and other mammals, there is a master clock within a region of the brain called the suprachiasmatic nuclei (SCN) and many peripheral clocks found elsewhere. For our research, we wanted to see how one aspect of this approach -- changing meal times -- affected circadian rhythms. We found that delaying meals by a certain amount caused a similar shift in some peripheral clocks, without changing the master clock. This is important because research in animals suggests peripheral clocks take longer to adjust to a new routine.

51 comments

  1. Probably not as good as by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    changing sleep times.

  2. This just in! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Water is wet...

    News at 11

    1. Re:This just in! by Mr+D+from+63 · · Score: 2

      Water is wet...

      News at 11

      No sheet. I've been adjusting my meals ahead of time as a matter of routine. Don't eat dinner on a US flight to Europe when it is 2 am there. I figured that out after my first trip.

  3. Tweaking the human by rmdingler · · Score: 5, Interesting
    It's an interesting study, but ATFA, human trials were administered on ten healthy males for eleven days. By delaying the mealtime routine, blood glucose levels were affected... not exactly startling.

    If it's true the people already affected by a lifestyle that conflicts with circadian rhythms are not typically pictures of health, we probably need a larger sample that includes overweight, jet-lagged, burnouts with dark circles under their eyes.

    There seems to be enough evidence that routine within the many thousand year-old light and dark cycle is the healthiest lifestyle, but since somebody's got to man the late shift, tweaking the biological clock may be a great second option.

    --
    Happiness in intelligent people is the rarest thing I know.

    Ernest Hemingway

    1. Re:Tweaking the human by Brett+Buck · · Score: 2

      Eleven days is not *nearly* long enough to make any useful conclusions. I have done a lot of swings and graveyard work in the past, and it always took me and all my fellow workers took weeks and weeks to see the full effect. It would take even longer now (~30 years on). As noted in another response, switching shifts after a few weeks is even worse, because then you never get to any sort of stable equilibrium (stable, not good). Of course, we tried various approaches to cope and many of them seemed OK for very short periods of 10-11 days, but later stopped working and caused worse problems than doing nothing special.

    2. Re:Tweaking the human by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I wish I could get shifts, I'm anytime, any day.

  4. How about just not changing shifts? by Rande · · Score: 3, Insightful

    If someone is happy to do night shift or graveyard shift, don't keep switching it around every 2-3 weeks with the inevitable disruption.

    I still haven't heard anyone explain _why_ workplaces want to keep regularly changing everyones shifts.

    It takes me up to a week to get used to a new sleep schedule, so my body would be screwed up for 2 weeks every month if I had to do changing shifts.

    1. Re: How about just not changing shifts? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Because the person managing the shift schedule works the same hours each day and doesn't know their SCN from their ASS.

    2. Re:How about just not changing shifts? by swb · · Score: 1

      Why?

      Probably lots of explanations. The person (or algorithm) scheduling people simply doesn't care and has other priorities, like keeping total hours below benefits or other ancillary compensation thresholds.

      There could be a deliberate attempt to disrupt worker relationships to maintain management control of information, prevent cliques or unionization.

      Some employees may have preferential status and get the shifts they want and other slots are simply backfilled based on other criteria.

      Then there's simple ignorance. I worked a job one summer where I was the primary employee (but lived off-site) and the 4 others who lived on site picked up the rest of the hours. We picked 4 hour shifts round-robin, which of course led to me working 6 days a week with a bunch of split shifts (sometimes both 7-11 am and pm). Until I complained, nobody really noticed.

    3. Re:How about just not changing shifts? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      The true scary thing is that this type of changing work shift is common in the medical field. Practically required in fact.

      That's seriously fucked up. And we wonder why there are so many medical mistakes and poor decisions. Hmmm...

    4. Re:How about just not changing shifts? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      There is never a good reason to keep changing a persons work hours! Employers need to hire people for the hours that they need them to work, and not give them any expectation of being able to change shifts. Many people do not want to works nights or weekends. This is one reason that I have found that employers change days off and work hours.

      I believe that employees should have the right to have their days off all in a row. For example if an employee works 4 days a week, they should work 4 days and then have 3 days off. I also believe that it should be required that employers give employees 72 hours notice about any changes in scheduled work hours or days, not just be able to call them in at a moment's notice. And there should be no mandatory work outside of the employees scheduled work hours.

    5. Re:How about just not changing shifts? by radarskiy · · Score: 2

      "If someone is happy to do night shift or graveyard shift"

      a) There aren't enough people who prefer a permanent night shift to staff a permanent night shift
      b) People on opposite shifts need to meet on occasion.
      c) People on shift work need to deal with the outside world not on shift work.
      d) Even if the night shift is preferred, there is always the initial change to the night shift when first taking the job.

    6. Re:How about just not changing shifts? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      "I still haven't heard anyone explain _why_ workplaces want to keep regularly changing everyones shifts."
      Fairness. We never could get enough people to volunteer for Shift work. So everybody was made equally miserable.
      Surprisingly, some actually got quite used to rotating Shifts; 7/3/7/4... You get to deal with such things as the DMV and some Banking during the day, see some Prime Time TV, listen to some lunatics on late night radio.

      However, it can also break people. After doing this for a decade, it's been another two decades since I've had eight hours of consecutive sleep at night. I stopped getting hungry at mealtimes long ago; I just eat when I feel hungry. In the first year, I lost 25 pounds; my metabolism slowed way down. Maybe one meal a day.
      A regular Social life is impossible, so the Shift Differentials that may be spent on a weekly Night Out just kept on accumulating in my checking account, for a decade. A year and a half's pay. Down payment on a house.
      Every Male that I worked with during that decade either never married or were divorced.
      Nobody is ever at their best on rotating Shifts, so expectations are lowered. Once the Shifts are deemed interchangeable, so are the People that work them. Consistency, rather than Excellence is expected.

      Why would anybody put up with this crap? The work itself was fascinating. Think Manhattan Project, but without the Big Bada Booms at the end. (The "Fifth Element" reference is actually sort of a pun. I bought the DVD. There are far more than five Elements.)
      But I would like that decade back...

    7. Re:How about just not changing shifts? by Kierthos · · Score: 2

      You aren't kidding.

      I did the graveyard shift at a FedEx Office (before it was known as such) for over a decade. During that time, I worked with easily a dozen other people on that shift, most of whom couldn't hack it.

      Not in terms of work or anything. They just found it very hard to adjust to sleeping during the day, and working at night. (One poor guy was trying to be a full time student, work the graveyard shift, and work part time at his church. He.... didn't last long at the store.)

      And every once in a while, my manager would insist that I show up at the generally pointless store meetings. He finally understood why I wasn't showing up when I explained it as "Okay, go home. relax a little. Have dinner. Go to bed. And then, three hours later, get up, stay up for an hour and a half, and then go back to bed. And see how effective you are in the morning when you're supposed to come in."

      Alas, shortly after he understood it, he transferred to another store, and I had to go through the whole rigamarole with a new manager.

      --
      Mr. Hu is not a ninja.
    8. Re:How about just not changing shifts? by John+Bodin · · Score: 1

      Not just medical, but a very good friend and her husband are security guards. They do like a week on one shift then couple days off then a different shift, and couple days off then finally overnight with couple of days off.

      --
      John
    9. Re:How about just not changing shifts? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Medical management is notoriously clueless. The notion is probably fairness, such that everyone will have some days with daytime off and some weekends off, and no one has to work night shift all the time. And yet no one is happy with it. In the hospital that I work at, we have a manager who seems to believe that her job is to make her employees' lives difficult - e.g., she'll grant time off but cut it a day short or schedule you on a day in the middle because she thinks she should do so for the sake of doing so rather than for anything like staffing needs. I'm grateful that I'm not under her.

      I currently (voluntarily) work Friday-Sunday every week, 12 hours shifts, and am quite happy. It sometimes sucks working every weekend, but I'll take it over swing shifts any day.

      Captcha: corpses

    10. Re:How about just not changing shifts? by baegucb · · Score: 1

      I work day shift Thursday and Friday, 12 hour night shifts Saturday and Sunday. And I've been doing it for 15 years. The day shifts are for meetings and the night shifts cover our change window. The only way to do it, for me, is to have a routine of when I sleep and when I eat (never before 6 PM).
      It's not the worst shifts I've worked. That would have been rotating shifts every 3 weeks, early in my career.

    11. Re:How about just not changing shifts? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      "If someone is happy to do night shift or graveyard shift"

      a) There aren't enough people who prefer a permanent night shift to staff a permanent night shift
      b) People on opposite shifts need to meet on occasion.
      c) People on shift work need to deal with the outside world not on shift work.
      d) Even if the night shift is preferred, there is always the initial change to the night shift when first taking the job.

      And all of them are invalid.

      a) Then at least let those willing to have a permanent night shit, rotate only those not willing.
      b) Have extra 30-60 minutes overlap between shifts once in a while. Why the heck do opposite shifts need to meet anyway?
      c) Deal with it during off-days, or outside shift hours, you know, just like regular 9-5 jobs.
      d) This is not even a reason.

    12. Re:How about just not changing shifts? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Exactly. I used to work on rotating shifts. And I did change my meal times. I had "permanent" jet lag and didn't know it until I took another job. A few weeks into the new job I got over the jet lag from the previous job. It was like waking up from a deep sleep.

    13. Re:How about just not changing shifts? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Permanent "late afternoon shift" is great for me. This is rather jet-lag shift from Europe to East Coast.
      get up at 8-9AM local, do your "free time stuff" , get to work at 3PM local, end
      work around midnight local, get drink and dinner , go home , sleep.

      Pros:
      - no morning traffic jam
      - not much people at the offices, stores - mostly mom+kid or seniors.
      - working remotely and on night shift allows me to travel on work days:
          take train/bus to Prague after work, travel by night,
          see the city by day, go to work from hotel at evening , sleep,
          repeat for other European cities within short drive or flight.
          One thing to remember - never mention that to your coworkers
          for some reason it is pissing them off if you mention that you are working from Paris today.
      - I do not have jet lag coming to the US.

      Cons:
      - social life - it is hard to connect with people living on "standard shift".
                                              No chance for bar pickup if you are at that stage ...
                                              Fortunately my wife is "night owl" type so we are getting along fine

    14. Re:How about just not changing shifts? by mjwx · · Score: 1

      If someone is happy to do night shift or graveyard shift, don't keep switching it around every 2-3 weeks with the inevitable disruption.

      I still haven't heard anyone explain _why_ workplaces want to keep regularly changing everyones shifts.

      It takes me up to a week to get used to a new sleep schedule, so my body would be screwed up for 2 weeks every month if I had to do changing shifts.

      I work in an almost 24/7 operation. The reason we swap shifts around is because we have lives, families, girlfriends/wives. Not all of us want to work nights every single week. Distributing it makes the system fairer so someone isn't stuck with the crappy shifts for weeks or months on end. Also, most people can easily adjust their sleep cycles, for me, I can do it in a day if need be.

      The money for doing shift work is also quite good.

      --
      Calling someone a "hater" only means you can not rationally rebut their argument.
  5. Better yet, eat food endemic to arriving country by JoeyRox · · Score: 1

    That way your body will know it's in a different time zone and automatically adjust. For example, if you're traveling from Europe to NYC, eat a Pastrami on Rye sandwich right after you land.

  6. The real cure for jet lag... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    That They don't want you to know: Put lithium oxide in your 7up.

    It's that easy! :)

  7. How ? by religionofpeas · · Score: 2

    Research Suggests Effects of Shift Work or Jet Lag On Our Body Clocks Can Be Reduced By Simply Changing Meal Times

    Don't most people already change their meal times to align with the new time zone ?

    1. Re:How ? by Stormy+Dragon · · Score: 1

      I think they mean to change meal times before you leave on the trip.

    2. Re:How ? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      So, nearly perfect GF except for the inevitable mental issues then.

    3. Re:How ? by PPH · · Score: 1

      And since you are not dead there is no God. QED.

      --
      Have gnu, will travel.
    4. Re:How ? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      If you are a man, why would you date a girl if you didn't want to get her pregnant with your child?

      If you have no interest in reproducing, just use one of your hands. Left or right, it doesn't matter. Let your genetic code spill all over the floor, and let all the work your ancestors have done die. Right on the fucking floor.

      Genociding your ancestors is something worth being proud of. I mean, it's not like there was actual EFFORT involved in making sure that you exist at all, right? Gay pride. Proud of your desire to commit suicide. ROFLMAO.

      What's worse... killing another person, and potentially preventing another genius from existing? ...or being a self-hating homosexual, and preventing another genius from existing? ...what is the real reason for being gay?

      There was a time when being suicidal was considered a mental illness. I guess it is TOTALLY FUCKING COOL NOW, HUH???

      Laugh Out Loud (AKA LOL).

    5. Re:How ? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      There never was a "God"... just thousands of different gods that mankind has made up and worshiped for many millennia because so many humans either fear death and look for false hope in imaginary deities or they are so afraid to live that they need something to look forward to in death.

      We are all born atheist and are forced to learn to worship imaginary sky faeries in childhood. Some of us grow up and stop worshiping the latest god, others continue the abnormal behavior by abusing their children the same way and trying to jam their beliefs on everyone else around them as well.

  8. Re:Better yet, eat food endemic to arriving countr by Opportunist · · Score: 4, Funny

    Or have some tap water right after arriving in Mexico, you wouldn't believe how your body adjusts and how you can stay awake.

    --
    We used to have a Bill of Rights. Now, with the rights gone, all we have left is the bill.
  9. How by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    I eat constantly, so how's that supposed to work?
    --
    creamerd

  10. article != summary by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    The article says the opposite of the summary:
      - the master hypothalamus "SCN clock" isn't affected by meal time.
      - "peripheral clocks" may be affected, or we may just be calling things clocks that aren't
      - to be healthy, peripheral clocks and SCN clock must be in sync.

    so changing meal times isn't adequate.

  11. Well Yes. by TechyImmigrant · · Score: 1

    I assume everyone who travels a lot knows this. Eat food at the time you want to be waking up in the new timezone. Your body get's a clue and goes along with it. That's why a fry up in LHR at 7.00am GMT after flying from the USA is ideal.

    --
    I should use this sig to advertise my book ISBN-13 : 978-1501515132.
    1. Re:Well Yes. by mjwx · · Score: 1

      I assume everyone who travels a lot knows this. Eat food at the time you want to be waking up in the new timezone. Your body get's a clue and goes along with it. That's why a fry up in LHR at 7.00am GMT after flying from the USA is ideal.

      I've never considered food to be part of the equation... but something to try out on my next big flight. Then again, I've never been fastidious about keeping to correct meal times, I usually just eat when hungry.

      For me, beating jet lag is easy. The easiest way to adjust your circadian rhythm is to stay up to a normal bed time at your destination, any time past 8pm local time is good. Sometimes this means forcing yourself to stay awake. I always try to get flights that arrive in the late afternoon/evening of my destination because I've never been able to sleep on planes. Getting into LHR at 7:00 am is terrible for me, however 15:30 means I get home around 18:30, dinner, shower and relax until I'm ready to sleep.

      First time I came to London from Perth, Western Australia I arrived at my lodgings at 19:00, went to sleep sometime around 20:30, woke up at 07:00, but completely adjusted to my new time zone.

      Also, exposure to sunlight helps adjust your circadian rhythm.

      --
      Calling someone a "hater" only means you can not rationally rebut their argument.
    2. Re:Well Yes. by TechyImmigrant · · Score: 1

      >I've never considered food to be part of the equation.

      I read it in a paper a few years ago and tried it out and it seemed to work well. Don't eat when you should be sleeping in the destination time zone. Load up at breakfast time in the destination time zone.

      This was at a time where I was effectively permanently recovering or in jetlag due to travelling internationally twice a month. So had plenty of opportunity to I try things. Sunlight, food and sleep at the right times were the key for me. Melotonin did nothing. Ambian was seriously addictive. Alcohol isn't a bad sleep aid if you enjoy experiencing bars in foreign countries.

      After a while I couldn't sustain it and I changed my role to limit travel.

      --
      I should use this sig to advertise my book ISBN-13 : 978-1501515132.
  12. Business class = Jet lag. by 140Mandak262Jamuna · · Score: 1

    I get severe jet lag only when I fly business. They give nice food and bed and you sleep in the plane. Once you land your body takes several days to adjust. When I fly coach, if I force myself to stay awake all/most of the flight, I arrive dead tired. Somehow stay away till 6pm to 9pm local time after landing on the first day. Body will be so tired, it will sleep for 8 to 10 hours. No jet lag from the next day.

    --
    sed -e 's/Chuck Norris/Rajnikant/g' joke > fact
    1. Re: Business class = Jet lag. by Snuggles · · Score: 1

      You do not have to sleep in business. I've found it helpful that you can get breakfast there whenever you want and can thus adjust easier than in couch.

    2. Re:Business class = Jet lag. by TechyImmigrant · · Score: 1

      >I get severe jet lag only when I fly business.

      I do better in business class. In business I have the choice to sleep or eat. In cattle class, sleeping isn't an option.
      I find there are two major components to feeling crappy, first your body clock being off, second sleep deprivation. If I just sleep as much as possible, it won't improve my body clock any, but at least I'm not sleep deprived and it feels manageable. I try to travel a couple of days early if I need to be on top of my game in meetings.

      I do the usual things. Eat a big breakfast, stop eating a few hours before bed time, walk in the sun in the morning. Set an alarm.

      I tried drugs (ambien) and that was a disaster. Melotonin did nothing.

      --
      I should use this sig to advertise my book ISBN-13 : 978-1501515132.
  13. Not really news to shift workers... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    There are a lot of folks who have never done shift work and never will understand the impact it has on a body. I did shift work for 11 years or so, in my twenties and early thirties. Now that I'm in my early sixties there is no way I would want to go back to that. I was really lucky, the shops I worked shifts in all did shift changes based on the local college terms so we could plan to take classes in our off time. That also gave us plenty of time to settle in to a shift and even with that it could still be hard, especially the mid shift. One good thing was that we changed shifts in, what I considered, the normal order. We went from days to swings to mids and back to days. You just stayed up later each time you changed shifts, nothing easier.

    While working mids I always tried to keep to my sleep schedule on my days off but many of my co-workers, especially the married ones, would get off on Friday morning and stay up to be with family during the weekend. Then they would come to work Sunday night (we started at 11pm) and try to stay awake after being up all day. As a shift supervisor I would find myself having to constantly wake them up all through the wee hours of the morning until we got off around 7am. I was usually the only one wide awake that first night back to work.

    One of the hardest kind of shift work (for me) was when we went to 12 hour shifts for exercises and contingencies (active duty military). In shops doing shift work, most day shifters would work 8a-8p and didn't suffer that much... the rest of us would end up on the 8p-8a shift which screwed up pretty much everyone else's sleeping and eating schedule. Later in my career when I was in shops that only worked days, I would inevitably end up on the night 12's and the first night or two would be absolute murder, then the we would revert back to normal and I would have to go thru it all again to adjust back to regular days. Being young really helps with that but it never was easy.

    The absolute worst shift work I ever heard of was the cop shops in the Air Force that would do three days, three mids, three swings, then four days off. Rotating backwards and having such short and odd shift periods was absolutely nuts by my figuring. It was impossible to go to school, or do much of anything else routine, in your off duty time with a schedule like that. You can bet the guys making up that schedule only worked the day shift.

    I really hated that everything extra to regular work was scheduled during the day so that swing and mid shift workers would have to come in on their off duty time when for day shifters it was just part of the work day. When I worked mids I slept during the day so I would have to come in when I would normally be sleeping. When I worked swings if often meant getting up an hour or three earlier than normal. You'd never see a day shifter giving up their sleep time for routine appointments and other meetings.
    --
    Steve (AC because I haven't bothered to register in all these years)

  14. Not "shift work" by Pfhorrest · · Score: 0

    Goddamnit people, it's SWING SHIFT specifically that you are talking about. Any scheduled period of time that you work is "shift work", even if it is always the same schedule every day; when that schedule changes radically all the time, that is specifically SWING SHIFT. Stop saying "shift work" when you mean "swing shift".

    --
    -Forrest Cameranesi, Geek of all Trades
    "I am Sam. Sam I am. I do not like trolls, flames, or spam."
    1. Re:Not "shift work" by drinkypoo · · Score: 1

      Any scheduled period of time that you work is "shift work", even if it is always the same schedule every day; when that schedule changes radically all the time, that is specifically SWING SHIFT

      Nope. It's the shift between night and day shift, like midnight down. Thanks for playing, though.

      --
      "You're right," Fisheye says. "I should have set it on 'whip' or 'chop.'"
    2. Re:Not "shift work" by Pfhorrest · · Score: 1

      That is graveyard shift.

      --
      -Forrest Cameranesi, Geek of all Trades
      "I am Sam. Sam I am. I do not like trolls, flames, or spam."
    3. Re:Not "shift work" by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Obviously you never worked in a factory.

      Day shift: 8am-4pm.
      Swing shift: 4pm-midnight.
      Night (aka grave or graveyard) shift: midnight-8am.

  15. No Need to Overthink This by Mkkby · · Score: 1

    Sleep when you are tired. Eat when you are hungry. Millions of years of evolution for the win.

    1. Re:No Need to Overthink This by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Eat when you are hungry. Millions of years of evolution for the win.

      Except most people mistake thirst for hunger. This explains why the average adult is now overweight or obese.

      Better: Eat on a regular schedule, and drink a half liter (aka 16.9 freedom units) of water if your stomach growls off-schedule.