Slashdot Mirror


Jonathan Coulton's New Dystopian Album Becomes a Graphic Novel (jonathancoulton.com)

An anonymous reader quotes NPR's report on one of Slashdot's long-time favorite musicians: In April, musician Jonathan Coulton released Solid State, a sci-fi concept album that represented a significant departure -- both from Coulton's wry, bright, tuneful back catalog and from any conventional understanding of what a sci-fi concept album sounds like... On first listen, with its shout-outs to futurist Ray Kurzweil, comment-section trolls, thinkpiece-gluts, and hack memes, Solid State seems a caustic critique of the internet -- which would be, as Coulton notes, "a little-off brand for me." Spend a bit more time with it, however, and its muted, melancholy songs reveal their true target: the toxic culture of glibness and hot takes that's leaching from the internet into every aspect of our lives.

The album features multiple perspectives and timelines, but its soundscape is allusive and impressionistic, resisting strict narrative. For that, Coulton turned to writer Matt Fraction and artist Albert Monteys, who with Coulton's input have taken some of the album's words, images and thematic preoccupations and crafted a graphic novel set largely in a future that will seem familiar to any reader of science fiction: a corporate-owned dystopia where humans have become dutiful, unthinking, unfeeling worker bees attending to menial tasks amid a culture engineered to keep them unthinking and unfeeling...These three creators believe that the roots of this dystopic future are all around us, but we're collectively choosing to ignore them in precisely the same way we blithely click past online Terms and Conditions agreements without bothering to read them.

The official music video for one of the songs takes the form of a text adventure.

57 comments

  1. solid state by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Does the comic book tell me who wins the global fish war?

    1. Re:solid state by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Yes. The Neo Nazis and antifa defeated all others and then killed each other off, and a new Age of Dinosaurs began.

  2. Oh the irony by arth1 · · Score: 1, Troll

    What's truly dystopian is a future (which largely is already here) where people don't read novels but need them pre-digested as picture books.

    1. Re:Oh the irony by NoNonAlphaCharsHere · · Score: 1

      What's even more dystopian than that is a world where Ray Kurzweil is taken seriously.

    2. Re:Oh the irony by magusxxx · · Score: 1

      Or spoiler filled monetized youtube review videos.

      --
      Care killed the cat, but satisfaction brought it back.
    3. Re:Oh the irony by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      I see, so, your preference for picture-free books makes you arrogant and derisive of others, then?

    4. Re: Oh the irony by NoNonAlphaCharsHere · · Score: 0

      Mods completely missing the point.

    5. Re:Oh the irony by arth1 · · Score: 1

      I see, so, your preference for picture-free books makes you arrogant and derisive of others, then?

      I have nothing against pictures. But not as a replacement for descriptive language. Pictures are snapshots with big gaps between them, and have to be caricatures if they are to convey emotions, or they will be lost. Subtlety is almost impossible to convey, or it will be missed.
      But if you transform a 400 page novel into an 800 page illustrated novel, I see no problem with it. But if it becomes a 60 page comic book, well, a lot will get lost.

      As for arrogance and derision, those are generally seen as bad - by those who feel hit. The solution to that is not to drag everybody down to the same level.

    6. Re: Oh the irony by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

      By billionaires with political power, no less.

    7. Re: Oh the irony by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Shouldn't surprise anyone that when a minority voice is ignored, some will simply start screaming.

    8. Re:Oh the irony by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Irony indeed, or a joke? Coulton got the dystopian part right, as I'd hate to live in a world where this is considered quality music. Good guy, but this is a truly horrible album with weak instrumentation backing up poor singing, trite, pseudo-techy lyrics, and the simplest pop melodies and rhythms. I wanted to like it, but any concept for an album needs some meat and potatoes, or at least boxed mac & cheese or even a high-end TV dinner to back it up. He clearly has a concept (which appears to be garbage) and sticks to it admirably, or perhaps it sticks to him like the doodoo it is. It pains me to rip an artist in such a merciless manner, since I am a fan of numerous artists representing nearly as many genres, but I'm disappointed that Coulton and his presumed listener base might be so lazy and undemanding as to accept this album as anything more than trash.

    9. Re:Oh the irony by uvajed_ekil · · Score: 1

      What's even more dystopian than that is a world where Ray Kurzweil is taken seriously.

      Or where this album is taken seriously. Yuck!

      --
      This is a hacked account, for which the owner can not be held responsible.
    10. Re:Oh the irony by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      You gotta learn to appreciate the art!

  3. Seems like a decent album so far by alvinrod · · Score: 2

    There's a youtube video out there that has the full album if you care to listen to the whole thing. So far it's a pretty interesting blend, that's really hard to put a label on. One song reminded me of The Postal Service and another sounded a little like something Fleetwood Mac could have done. I'll have to finish the whole thing, but so far it's something I'd consider purchasing.

    1. Re:Seems like a decent album so far by uvajed_ekil · · Score: 1

      There's a youtube video out there that has the full album if you care to listen to the whole thing. So far it's a pretty interesting blend, that's really hard to put a label on. One song reminded me of The Postal Service and another sounded a little like something Fleetwood Mac could have done. I'll have to finish the whole thing, but so far it's something I'd consider purchasing.

      Fleetwood Mac!?!? I'm glad I listened on Youtube and didn't pay money for it. It sounds more like Ben Folds forgot what music sounded like, hired Vampire Weekend minus the "talent" and with worse instruments, after scanning Slashdot for buzzwords. I don't mean any part of that as a compliment. I hate being the hater, but I expected an NPR favorite would do better. Wow, this is so lame and cliched yet equally bad instrumentally that I can't even wrap my mind around it or adequately explain how much I hate it. I can't remember the last time I listened to a whole album like this, hoping all the while it was going to get better. It didn't.

      --
      This is a hacked account, for which the owner can not be held responsible.
    2. Re:Seems like a decent album so far by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      How can I give you an upvote? +1

  4. Or worse yet... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Need their music made into best selling picturebooks because they are too lazy to listen or *READ* stories :)

    1. Re:Or worse yet... by arth1 · · Score: 2

      Need their music made into best selling picturebooks because they are too lazy to listen or *READ* stories :)

      The dumbing down of music is also well underway. Music consists of melody, harmony and rhythm, but melody and harmony require a slight amount of attachment, and are on the way out. Harmony is largely gone already; single notes are complex enough.

      There are also signs that the already short ~4 minute "radio edit" for songs is becoming too long. Some modern stations are cutting to 3 or less - presumably attention span is not what it was.

    2. Re: Or worse yet... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      What does song length have to do with quality? A 25 minute rap song will still be total shit, because song length is independent of quality. Even just 30 seconds of some of the best classical music is more expressive than any rap song of any length could ever be.

    3. Re:Or worse yet... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      The dumbing down of music has been underway since the first caveman beat on a log.

      Not every form of entertainment needs to be lofty and intellectual in order to fulfill human emotional needs, you pretentious snot.

    4. Re:Or worse yet... by fluffernutter · · Score: 1

      For me, lyrics alone can make a song. Traditionally it was already difficult to find truly poetic lyrics that discussed something worth discussing, but now it's almost impossible.

      --
      Laws are rules for the court, but merely a bottom bar to hit for life. Think beyond laws in your actions always.
    5. Re: Or worse yet... by arth1 · · Score: 1

      What does song length have to do with quality? A 25 minute rap song will still be total shit, because song length is independent of quality. Even just 30 seconds of some of the best classical music is more expressive than any rap song of any length could ever be.

      Length doesn't matter for crap, but for many great works of music (old or modern), you need the time to build up, transform, and paint the bigger picture. There are plenty of great music that isn't played on the radio because it doesn't fit. NPR and BBC seem to only want to play longer pieces of classical music, nothing else, which is a shame.

    6. Re: Or worse yet... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

      I think the complaint isn't that "dumbed down" music exists, it's that it's become incredibly difficult to find anything else via radio.

    7. Re: Or worse yet... by infolation · · Score: 2

      I used to think that too, but then I heard that my favourite song, John Cage's 4'33" has been remixed into an extended 10 minute version on itunes. So much better than the original.

    8. Re: Or worse yet... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      There are *so many* affordable alternatives to radio.

      Radio, like anything else, caters to its market. Sounds like someone isn't in that market.

    9. Re:Or worse yet... by hackwrench · · Score: 1

      Jonathan Coulter did the music on the three main portal games, Lego being the third and Harry101UK does some smash-up work in that department. You can go as low fi as text or as hi-fi as full blown musicals and there's even an unofficial musical of Portal.

    10. Re:Or worse yet... by hackwrench · · Score: 1

      Lilium https://www.youtube.com/watch?...
      Hosea https://www.youtube.com/watch?...
      And just about anything by Harry Calligan, aka Harry101UK. He also has Portal comedy and fangames footage.

    11. Re:Or worse yet... by arth1 · · Score: 1

      Jonathan Coulter did the music on the three main portal games,

      Portal and Portal 2 are certainly famous games, but not for the music. if you ask random people who played the games what the music was like, I think you'll get a lot of "um" and "er" replies, unless they remember the turrets and GLaDOS "singing". And the main body of music wasn't by Coulton either.

      For some good video game scores, try Civilization IV, Homeworld or Red Dead Redemption.

    12. Re:Or worse yet... by schleimkeim · · Score: 1

      The dumbing down of music is also well underway.

      That was already successfully happening in the 90ties.

    13. Re:Or worse yet... by TuringTest · · Score: 1

      Portal and Portal 2 are certainly famous games, but not for the music.

      If you utter the words "This was a triumph!", anyone who has finished the game will remember the song about making science, even if they don't remember their writer's name.

      If you don't ask about "the music" in abstract but about "the songs", it's likely that anyone (who finished the game) will remember it, because it makes a very strong emotional impact.

      --
      Singularity: a belief in the "God" idea with the "demiurge" relation inverted.
    14. Re:Or worse yet... by arth1 · · Score: 1

      If you utter the words "This was a triumph!", anyone who has finished the game will remember the song about making science, even if they don't remember their writer's name.

      I finished both, and all I remember was some children's music with vocoder-mixed turret/GLaDOS voices meant as comical relief. If that passes as great music now, we're doomed.

    15. Re:Or worse yet... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      You, sir, should return your geek card. The lyrics of the song were perfectly crafted to the narrative you had just experienced, and it contributed to build the best written antagonist of the decade even after the story had finished.

    16. Re:Or worse yet... by arth1 · · Score: 1

      You, sir, should return your geek card. The lyrics of the song were perfectly crafted to the narrative you had just experienced, and it contributed to build the best written antagonist of the decade even after the story had finished.

      Lyrics don't define the music that hosts it. Whether you sing "Ein Vogelfaenger bin ich ja" or "tadum ta dumdum dum dum dum" only changes the performance, not Mozart's music.

  5. Re:Thanks Slashdot! by cruff · · Score: 1

    Yeah, I feel that way about movies.

  6. Re:Thanks Slashdot! by Zero__Kelvin · · Score: 1

    You aren't really grasping this whole "information" concept are You? If they were telling you about music everyone already knows about, and everyone has heard / experienced via the medium everyone already has in their collection, THAT would be the time to complain.

    --
    Guns don't kill people; Physics kills people! - John Lithgow as Dick Solomon on Third Rock From The Sun
  7. Re:Thanks Slashdot! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    It's cute you think this is original, cupcake.

  8. Re:Thanks Slashdot! by Kohath · · Score: 0

    Information without relevance has negative value.

  9. Re:Thanks Slashdot! by Zero__Kelvin · · Score: 1

    Congratulations on your complete lack of reading comprehension mr stalker!

    --
    Guns don't kill people; Physics kills people! - John Lithgow as Dick Solomon on Third Rock From The Sun
  10. Re:Thanks Slashdot! by Zero__Kelvin · · Score: 1

    So you are saying what you just wrote has zero value ... agreed.

    --
    Guns don't kill people; Physics kills people! - John Lithgow as Dick Solomon on Third Rock From The Sun
  11. JoCo! by MMC+Monster · · Score: 1

    Thanks for the ad for the new album. Totally didn't realize he had something new.

    That being said, that's one sad music video.

    --
    Help! I'm a slashdot refugee.
  12. Looks like an advertisement, but is it good? by blindseer · · Score: 1

    It's nice, I guess, to see people talk of what they are passionate about and want to share with others. I'll say good things about music, books, movies, and such I like with anyone that asks, and a few that don't ask.

    This Jonathan Coulton music and book sounds like something I might want to try but unless I hear it's good from someone that does not financially gain from the sale I'll have my doubts.

    So, is it any good?

    --
    I am armed because I am free. I am free because I am armed.
    1. Re:Looks like an advertisement, but is it good? by MMC+Monster · · Score: 1

      I'm not sure about this album, but his live album 'Best. Concert. Ever.' is fantastic. Love every song. Just have to cut out the last song from the playlist when my kids are listening to it.

      https://www.youtube.com/watch?...

      --
      Help! I'm a slashdot refugee.
    2. Re:Looks like an advertisement, but is it good? by MMC+Monster · · Score: 1

      Forgot to mention: The music starts at 5:40 on the YouTube video.

      --
      Help! I'm a slashdot refugee.
  13. comic books by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 1

    Whats the difference between comic books and graphic novels? Number of pages? Existence of a plot?

    1. Re: comic books by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Nothing, really. The phrase 'comic book' aquired some negative connotations over time. It made people think of overweight, unkempt, unwashed, smelly, neckbeard, basement-dwelling virgin 45-year-old men. So the term 'graphic novel' started being used instead. But since the readership hadn't changed, we're seeing the new term acquire the same negative connotations.

  14. Re: Does it have Neo Nazis in it? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    What's it like being not funny or smart?

  15. Re:Thanks Slashdot! by mccalli · · Score: 1

    I think they might have identified him explicitly, but I don't think it's too far of a stretch to have an article about the musician from Portal - Still Alive (This Was A Triumph); Now I Only Want You Gone - plus a few other geek-known tracks here and there. Agree they should have given a quick lead-in on background though.

  16. Re: Does it have Neo Nazis in it? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Nazis were rather funny and smart.

  17. I don't get it by 93+Escort+Wagon · · Score: 3, Informative

    How can so many people with reasonably low Slashdot UIDs apparently not know who Jonathan Coulton is? Even setting aside his cred as a geeky tech-loving musician - stories about him have been featured on this site for years.

    Heck, he even recut "Code Monkey" and sent it to CmdrTaco in celebration of Slashdot's 15th anniversary.

    --
    #DeleteChrome
    1. Re:I don't get it by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      it's an ad

    2. Re:I don't get it by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      How can so many people with reasonably low Slashdot UIDs apparently not know who Jonathan Coulton is?

      Because we skip the stories that aren't about tech.

  18. Re: Does it have Neo Nazis in it? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Nazis were rather funny and smart.

    Shut up, nazi.

  19. Dystopian *future*? by dddux · · Score: 1

    "a corporate-owned dystopia where humans have become dutiful, unthinking, unfeeling worker bees attending to menial tasks amid a culture engineered to keep them unthinking and unfeeling..." I don't think that's future. It's the present.

    --
    "It is no measure of health to be well adjusted to a profoundly sick society." - Jiddu Krishnamurti