Slashdot Mirror


Hurricane Maria Knocks Out Power To Entire Island of Puerto Rico (cnn.com)

An anonymous reader writes: Hurricane Maria's eye has left Puerto Rico, but the mammoth storm is still lashing the island with devastating winds. Maria weakened to a Category 3 hurricane Wednesday afternoon, hurling winds of 115 mph. But hurricane-force gusts topping 74 mph still extend over much of Puerto Rico, the National Hurricane Center said. Maria's brute force wiped out electricity to the entire island. "We are 100% without power," a spokesman for the Puerto Rico governor's office said Wednesday. The storm also ripped trees out of the ground and caused widespread flooding. "This is total devastation," said Carlos Mercader, a spokesman for Puerto Rico's governor. "Puerto Rico, in terms of the infrastructure, will not be the same. ... This is something of historic proportions." Maria is expected to dump a total of 12 to 18 inches of rain on Puerto Rico before barreling toward the Dominican Republic starting Wednesday night.

72 comments

  1. I'm not sure why this is news by the_skywise · · Score: 1, Insightful

    The cat3 hurricane ENGULFED THE ENTIRE ISLAND.
    Real news would've been all the power staying on!

    1. Re:I'm not sure why this is news by cayenne8 · · Score: 1
      Time to sell your Bacardi stock....

      :(

      --
      Light travels faster than sound. This is why some people appear bright until you hear them speak.........
    2. Re:I'm not sure why this is news by the_skywise · · Score: 1

      MUH RUMMM!!

      (Heh... why is the rum gone?... oh...)

    3. Re:I'm not sure why this is news by cayenne8 · · Score: 1

      Hard to have a hurricane party without rum....

      --
      Light travels faster than sound. This is why some people appear bright until you hear them speak.........
    4. Re:I'm not sure why this is news by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Proof of Trump caused global warming in action!

  2. So if you don't have power by Pikoro · · Score: 4, Funny

    "We are 100% without power," a spokesman for the Puerto Rico governor's office said Wednesday.

    How did they get this quote? RFC 1149?

    --
    "Freedom in the USA is not the ability to do what you want. It is the ability to stop others from doing what THEY want"
    1. Re:So if you don't have power by TFlan91 · · Score: 2

      You've heard of satellites and portable generators, yes?

    2. Re:So if you don't have power by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      He's psychic. Or he has generator backups. But probably just RFC 1149 as you suggested, since that's what all political leaders use in case of a dire emergency.

    3. Re:So if you don't have power by bobbied · · Score: 0

      Heard of them? Of course, but they don't have any.. Puerto Rico is just about bankrupt so they cannot afford them or the fuel to run them.

      --
      "File to fit, pound to insert, paint to match" - Aircraft Maintenance 101
    4. Re:So if you don't have power by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      no, they are not. Puerto Rico may be an island that has many poor people on it, but there are rich persons and, having been there and stayed in a resort, I can honestly say that whenever the local power flickered, the resorts generators came on.

    5. Re:So if you don't have power by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      The puertorican govt is bankrupt but not the citizens themselves many people could very well and probably do own generators, and stock piles of gas due to their electric company also being bankrupt. Power is not the most reliable in parts of the island. They may even have satellite phones or satellite internet the likes of Hughes net. Cellular was working on the island up until about 2pm today as I was receiving texts from a friend that lives there. I have not gotten any texts since then.

    6. Re:So if you don't have power by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Bankruptcy is a tool for rich people to make others pay for their mistakes. In most cases, nothing is given up but debt.

    7. Re:So if you don't have power by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Heard of them? Of course, but they don't have any..

      Oh really?

      Puerto Rico is just about bankrupt so they cannot afford them or the fuel to run them.

      Izzat so?

    8. Re:So if you don't have power by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      "Just about" because of a Strom Thurmon-authored legislative provision from 1984 exempting Puerto Rico from bankruptcy protection.

    9. Re:So if you don't have power by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      > Of course, but they don't have any

      To think that there is not a single working generator on Puerto Rico is seriously out of touch with reality.

    10. Re:So if you don't have power by Osgeld · · Score: 1

      by sparking a car battery to send out morse code

      duh

    11. Re: So if you don't have power by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      In case you've forgotten, Puerto Rico is part of the United States... and the feds would *never* allow official bankruptcy to happen.

      It's just that as a practical matter, PR won't be allowed to become a state until one of the following things happen:

      * Likely Republican majority in Puerto Rico

      * Democrats gain majority of House, Senate, and state governments.

      * Somebody finds a new Republican enclave to carve out of a majority-Democrat state to neutralize-out PR's new Senators & Congressmen.

      Until then, Republicans will oppose PR statehood on purely partisan political grounds (and Democrats would do the exact same thing if the tables were turned... there are unclean hands on both sides of the aisle).

    12. Re: So if you don't have power by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Time to resurrect the state of Jefferson!

    13. Re:So if you don't have power by MightyMartian · · Score: 1

      To think that there is not a single working generator on Puerto Rico is seriously out of touch with reality.

      Welcome to Slashdot

      --
      The world's burning. Moped Jesus spotted on I50. Details at 11.
    14. Re: So if you don't have power by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Oh.... the irony... naming a new, Republican-majority state after the Democratic Party's most revered founder :-D

    15. Re: So if you don't have power by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Puerto Rico's government-run utility hasn't paid us for the last time we fixed one of their generators, which was 2 years ago. We only won that order because our competition wasn't stupid enough to bid on it.

    16. Re: So if you don't have power by KGIII · · Score: 1

      Strom was pretty squarely in the not-a-good-man category.

      --
      "So long and thanks for all the fish."
  3. If caught in a hurricane... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0, Informative

    Don't forget to use the hand-crank radio/flashlight/usb charger in case of emergency.

    1. Re: If caught in a hurricane... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Fuck off creimer with your affiliate spam.

      Someone please mod down. Its creimers affiliate link shenanigans again.

  4. I sympathize by CustomBuild · · Score: 0

    What a horrible stroke of luck. Hopefully we can gather important data from this disaster, and potentially improve upon our infrastructure.

    1. Re:I sympathize by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Good point. This could really be considered a great dry run for when DPRK detonates a nuke in the ionosphere over Kansas and takes out the grid in the continental US.

    2. Re:I sympathize by Grishnakh · · Score: 1

      Hopefully we can gather important data from this disaster, and potentially improve upon our infrastructure.

      What is this, some kind of joke? That's about as likely as the US voters picking a really great President in 2020, or world peace being achieved.

  5. It's Pretty Bad by apoc.famine · · Score: 3, Interesting

    Got family there, and they went out of communication around 4am. Pictures coming out from their city show some massive destruction, which looks pretty widespread across the island. It's going to take a long time for them to recover from this.

    San Juan still didn't have power in parts due to Irma when this one hit. I wonder how long it's going to take to restore power after this. Months, at least.

    --
    Velociraptor = Distiraptor / Timeraptor
    1. Re:It's Pretty Bad by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      My best to your family. My thoughts are with them.

    2. Re:It's Pretty Bad by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      They'll be fine. We caught matthew's eyewall @140mph last year, and it only took us 5 weeks to get most of the island (GBI) back up, and we're in way worse shape financially and organizationally than PR.

    3. Re:It's Pretty Bad by Mashiki · · Score: 1

      Depends on whether or not the transmission towers stood up or not. If they did, a street can be rewired in a couple of days or less depending on the number of people working. For underground systems, it's more of a case to make sure that junctions are dry, not corroding and the transformers don't go when they're repowered. When we had the ice storm in '88, that's where power went down and stayed down for months. 1000+ transmission towers had to be rebuilt from scratch, new foundations laid, all the cabling re-run. That meant parts of Ontario, Quebec, and New Brunswick were without power for months in -20C to -30C weather.

      Some parts are going to take a while, but it's far easier to get back up and running when the workers aren't having to worry about freezing to death while trying to get hydro back up for everyone else.

      --
      Om, nomnomnom...
  6. Re:Wind power doesn't work by bobbied · · Score: 1

    qed

    In 155 MPH winds? Why am I not surprised?

    Actually, the issue will be power transmission lines.... Not generation capacity, unless they got really unlucky...

    --
    "File to fit, pound to insert, paint to match" - Aircraft Maintenance 101
  7. all the twists & turns of a bad sci-fi script by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    plus game show style hypenosys media mongrelity.. old hat soft shoe burlesque at our worst... cease fire stand down.. weep along.. https://www.youtube.com/results?sp=EgIIBVAU&q=wmd+weather

  8. Good! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Puerto Rico only has electricity because racist white men put it there.
    It is now reverting to its holy unblemished natural state.

    1. Re:Good! by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

      Guess that explains why the system is junk.

  9. best of intentions to all of us unchosens by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    shakng, sinking, & being shot at all over the world again today.. better days ahead.. guaranteed

  10. This can't be true by WillAffleckUW · · Score: 1

    Anyone with a modern 2010 or later house built to hurricane standards and a Tesla solar roof and Tesla storage batteries, by definition, has full power.

    I think you meant to say "grid electricity to Puerto Rico will be offline for 4-6 months".

    Even people with wind power could have taken the wind turbine housing inside during the storm and put it back up after it passed. It's a fairly simple operation.

    Same goes for generators - you take it inside a secure location built to hurricane standards until after it passes and then move it outside.

    Does nobody on this site understand modern energy production?

    --
    -- Tigger warning: This post may contain tiggers! --
    1. Re:This can't be true by cashman73 · · Score: 1

      I think that's the major issue. The vast majority of homes and buildings in Puerto Rico are not built to code. In fact, many were built illegally due to cost issues. Sure, there are going to be some rich people with homes that have their own generators and/or solar panels. But the vast majority of the population is screwed.

    2. Re:This can't be true by WillAffleckUW · · Score: 1

      And resorts. Most resorts have both backup generators and solar/wind that can be taken offline and put back up.

      So the 100 percent no power claim is, by definition, false. The grid failed. The grid is offline. There are buildings and residences and commercial properties with power.

      --
      -- Tigger warning: This post may contain tiggers! --
    3. Re:This can't be true by WalksOnDirt · · Score: 1

      Anyone with a modern 2010 or later house built to hurricane standards and a Tesla solar roof and Tesla storage batteries, by definition, has full power.

      That's assuming you still have a roof. Even if you do, I'm dubious that the solar cells would still work.

      --
      a,e,i,o,u and sometimes w and y (at be if of up cwm by)
    4. Re:This can't be true by WillAffleckUW · · Score: 1

      Again, you have to build and anchor the grids/arrays. If the walls go, you have non-hurricane construction, so it wouldn't support roof solar. If you built for 125 kph winds, having 215 kph winds means some roofs and walls will fail, and debris may impact the cells. The Tesla roof solar units are fairly durable, and if built to the proper standard, should be fine, but if a tree moving at speed hits it, will take damage.

      People with small scale portable solar PV or portable wind turbines can dismount them and store them in secure rooms in the interior of the building. For a wind turbine, it's fairly quick; for a portable solar PV it's usually quick. Fixed roof solar is more a matter of how durable the roof support was, and whether the roof was impacted by heavy flying debris.

      Branson's island was impacted, but his solar and wind was stored inside, so he was able to get it running quickly after the fact. But he built to hurricane standard for both roof and walls, and took precautions.

      A resort may or may not have taken the same level of action, depending on staffing and training levels. A residence may have done so, but if vacant probably did not. You can board up the solar panels (surface application of covering boards, similar to windows) to reduce the chance of wind debris impacts, but if it's not secured to a secure wall, it can be ripped off the roof entirely.

      --
      -- Tigger warning: This post may contain tiggers! --
  11. Re:Wind power doesn't work, or does it? by WillAffleckUW · · Score: 1

    You just have to take the turbine blade off during the storm. It takes a few minutes, you put it inside a secure 2nd floor closet, and you put it back up once the storm has passed. I used to do that all the time. Are we seriously saying people are so stupid they don't take basic off-line power actions?

    --
    -- Tigger warning: This post may contain tiggers! --
  12. If you are a US citizen... by wjcofkc · · Score: 1

    Please remember that Puerto Rico is our responsibility. This something we need to be talking about.

    --
    Brought to you by Carl's Junior.
    1. Re:If you are a US citizen... by bill_mcgonigle · · Score: 1

      Please remember that Puerto Rico is our responsibility. This something we need to be talking about.

      How about we pull all of our troops out of Afghanistan, Iraq, and Syria, and send them to Puerto Rico to help rebuild instead?

      --
      My God, it's Full of Source!
      OUTSIDE_IP=$(dig +short my.ip @outsideip.net)
    2. Re:If you are a US citizen... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0
      Because troops are so well-equipped to rebuild? I suppose they'd be of great value for the demolition phase.

      I'm sure Trump, being so into the real estate thing, will turn this into a golden opportunity to build an infrastructure showcase.

    3. Re:If you are a US citizen... by Cheech+Wizard · · Score: 1

      What? And deny so many defense ordnance and related contractors business?

  13. That's not saying much by Tailhook · · Score: 1

    A lot of Puerto Rico's electrical network is badly neglected. Much of the system is suspended on old fashioned post-war power poles and overloaded with too many cables. It looks like something from 19th century New York. None of this is terribly surprising: it's a government run power system that is absurdly dysfunctional.

    The whole thing fell over. Big surprise. Not.

    --
    Maw! Fire up the karma burner!
    1. Re:That's not saying much by Miamicanes · · Score: 1

      Since when did they have concrete utility poles in 19th-century New York?

      Seriously. This isn't a street view of some backwards country... it's the street view of a commercial neighborhood in a big city where the power company is in the middle of replacing old wood utility poles with new concrete poles & simply hasn't taken down the old poles and wires yet.

      When FPL upgraded poles in Florida, lots of OUR streets looked EXACTLY like that for a year or more. The old wires didn't come down for months, and I think the poles themselves were left in place for another year or two after that.

    2. Re:That's not saying much by MBGMorden · · Score: 1

      That may actually be a good thing long term. Sometimes people won't "fix" something that's already working, even if it needs maintenance. If it's destroyed, then it can be built back up better.

      As an example, after the great Chicago fire it was rebuilt much better than it was before and there was a large influx of money and people for the reconstruction. The city of Myrtle Beach, SC was rebuilt into a resort town when it was largely destroyed by Hurricane Hazel back in the 1950's.

      --
      "People who think they know everything are very annoying to those of us who do."-Mark Twain
    3. Re:That's not saying much by Tailhook · · Score: 2

      commercial neighborhood in a big city

      Well run power utilities don't use poles in urban areas any more. Concrete or otherwise. Figuring out how this is lost on hurricane prone Puerto Rico or whatever mismanaged part of Florida you hail from is an exercise I'll leave you to work on.

      Here is one of your concrete poles splayed out on the road like the ghetto crap that it is. The wood one is probably in the Gulf somewhere. These knuckleheads will be in the dark until December and it will be the US proper that has to foot the bill. That power company was $9 BILLION in debt before the hurricane wiped it out.

      At least maybe this will provide an opportunity to involve some grownups in the matter.

      --
      Maw! Fire up the karma burner!
    4. Re: That's not saying much by Miamicanes · · Score: 1

      In Florida's case, it's because the state allows FPL to more or less dictate the terms of undergrounding, so we end up with absurd requirements like "FPL requires conveyance of a dedicated easement of 20 feet adjacent to a public road for undergrounding", which in many parts of South Florida would require the eminent-domain purchase (and potential destruction) of the ENTIRE FRONT YARD of everyone on one side of the street, and the entire front yard of one or two homes on the other side for the transformers. This is where FPL's insane post-Wilma "three trillion dollar" price tag to bury Dade County's power lines came from.

      All the state has to do is pass a law telling FPL, "listen up bitch, you're going to bury power lines in the 10' backyard easement where the current poles are, or we'll make you sell your franchise to someone who WILL".

      Of course, Florida will never do that. Mustn't harm the sanctity of a private company's profit margin...

      Trust me. Floridians are REALLY PISSED at FPL right now. Southeast Florida barely got nicked by a distant passing storm & had power outages exceeding a week. There's talk about a class-action lawsuit to claw back FPL's profits from the last 5 years & using them to bury power lines.

      My point is that Puerto Rico's power grid is no worse than Florida's was pre-Wilma, and isn't much worse than Florida's *present* power grid. Getting lines buried is *hard*, even when there's agreement from the mayors on down that it needs to be done. At the end of the day, FPL can afford to pay its lawyers more and keep swatting down attempts to MAKE them do it.

    5. Re:That's not saying much by Frederic54 · · Score: 1

      I had to double check your picture, it is exactly the same in Québec, everywhere, and we have snow storm and all and power cutoff every winter... a government run power system...

      --
      "Science will win because it works." - Stephen Hawking
  14. Best gift you can give Puerto Rican family members by Miamicanes · · Score: 5, Informative

    If you have family members in Puerto Rico and want to do them the greatest favor possible, buy them a 3000-3600 watt inverter-type generator, four 5-gallon gas cans (empty, of course), and one or two Carbon Monoxide detectors (or smoke alarms with CO detection built in), then FedEx (NOT UPS) it to them tomorrow so they'll get it by Monday.

    Why 3000-3600 watts? Big enough to start the air conditioner & refrigerator, with enough spare capacity to throttle it down to half-speed to keep them both running overnight. Trust me... if the climate in Puerto Rico is anything like the climate in Miami, air conditioning isn't a luxury, it's life-support.

    3000 watts is also big enough to run a second window a/c unit or a washing machine (tip: don't use the dryer... even if your generator is big enough, dryers cause large amounts of outside air to get sucked into the house... including outside air with lots of carbon monoxide from the generator sitting 10 feet away from the door or window that's cracked open so you can feed the extension cords through it.)

    Why inverter-type? Fuel efficiency. They're going to be using it for a few weeks, minimum. A traditional 10hp 4800-5600 watt generator burns through about 15-25 gallons of gas PER DAY. It's kind of like comparing a 1970 Cadillac Eldorado to a Toyota Prius. An inverter generator will literally pay for itself in gas savings after 2-3 weeks. Post-Irma, I spent more than $250 to keep my old generator running until the power was finally restored a week later... and THAT was with 4-8 hours/day of non-usage. They're also a LOT quieter than conventional generators, especially when running in "Eco" mode. Imagine trying to sleep over the noise of a typical window a/c AND two lawnmowers running in the back yard... that's what it's like trying to sleep with a traditional generator.

    Why gas cans? Gas cans are utterly IMPOSSIBLE to buy for at least a few weeks after a major hurricane. With an inverter generator, four 5-gallon cans should be enough to let them get away with going to the gas station every other day. Five or six are even better, but I was BLOWN AWAY last week when I saw how expensive gas cans are now (I paid $10/can post-Wilma and felt ripped off... now, they're more like $25-30 apiece AND have shitty new safety spouts that turn refueling into a 10+ minute exercise... if you have any old gas cans, treat their spouts like gold).

    Why the carbon monoxide detectors? Safety. Carbon monoxide can easily get into the house, and the fumes WON'T wake them up if they're asleep. Put one detector near the door/window that's open for the extension cords, and another next to wherever people are sleeping.

    Another tip to share with them: a typical American electric water heater (one or two coils, 240v, approx. 4500 watts) can be powered with 120v from a generator without problems. It'll draw 1/4th the total wattage (ie, around 1100 watts at 120v) and take longer to heat up the water, but it definitely works. Wire it up as follows: generator 120v "hot" to water heater's "240v hot #1". generator's "neutral" to water heater's "240v hot #2". generator's ground to water heater's chassis ground. Try to use an extension cord with at least AWG14 wire or better... AWG16 will work in a pinch, but you'll end up wasting 10-20% of your wattage heating up the extension cord instead of the water.

    Other nice features for the generator to have: bluetooth or wifi so you can check remaining fuel/runtime and current power draw using your phone or tablet. Push-button starting (esp. if someone who's not very strong has to start it).

    A generator able to sustain 1800W and surge to 2500W might be OK, but inverter-type generators in THAT range tend to have absurdly small gas tanks. Trust me... getting up in the middle of the night to refuel really, REALLY sucks. Especially when it's 89 degrees and 80% humidity outside.

    Typical current draws I noted after Irma:

    6000 BTU air conditioner: 5A, 550 watts

    8000 BTU air conditioner: 8A, 900 watts

    Side by

  15. Best Wishes by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    My thoughts and best wishes go out to the people of Puerto Rico, the Virgin Islands, and others devastated by hurricanes. I can't imagine the destruction and chaos this has caused.

  16. Re: Break up california by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Way ahead of you soj51 dot org

    Of course, the most likely way it becomes reality is if California secedes.

  17. So, it looks like... by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    ... the hurricane is damaging Puerto Rico almost as much as the treatment it gets from the federal government.

    (whoosh)

  18. Re: Wind power doesn't work, or does it? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Shut the fuck up will. You are a fucking idiot. Yea let's take a wind turbine and store it on the second floor. Fucking idiot.

  19. Pre-Columbian? by hduff · · Score: 1

    Almost back to a pre-Columbian era. And looks what happened to them. Stay safe, PR.

    --
    "I believe in Karma. That means I can do bad things to people all day long and I assume they deserve it." : Dogbert
  20. Re:Best gift you can give Puerto Rican family memb by PastTense · · Score: 1

    There is no possibility that Fedex nor any other shipping service will have restored operations that quickly. They certainly didn't in Florida after Irma.

  21. The governor's office was misinformed by RhettLivingston · · Score: 1

    A friend with family in Puerto Rico contacted three family members living in three different cities after this quote became public and all had power. Perhaps they rounded to the nearest 100%. That isn't to say it isn't bad. After having just spent eight days without power due to Irma, I feel for them.

  22. Re:Best gift you can give Puerto Rican family memb by Miamicanes · · Score: 2

    UPS, I totally agree, is fucked and hopeless. They probably won't even acknowledge the location of packages already in transit until the end of next week. They suck.

    FedEx might be do-able early next week if the package were held for pickup at their main facility in San Juan.

    Ditto for 3-day Priority Mail. According to USPS.gov, a 55-pound box measuring 22x22x20 would cost around $90 to mail and arrive on Monday, 9/25 (with caveat that their air freight capacity is limited & might sell out at any time)

    The only catch is that a 3200-watt generator would probably weigh too much to send via air, so you'd probably have to settle for a 1800-2200 running watt (2500-3000 starting watt) generator.

    There's actually another nifty fact I discovered last week: contrary to the official instructions that come with most inverter generators, you don't HAVE to use the manufacturer's official parallel cable, nor do you have to use two identical generators.

    Most parallel-capable inverter generators will sync up to ANY source of live voltage they see, regardless of source. You can even use a DC-AC inverter to add a few hundred watts of surge capacity to the generator (say, if your generator is big enough to RUN your air conditioner, but not quite big enough to START the air conditioner without a little extra help).

    All you need is a homemade "Y" cable (take two outdoor extension cords, cut off the plugs and receptacles leaving 18-24 inches of cord, then splice the wires from the two plugs onto the receptacle). The main thing you'll lose by making your own hacked cable instead of using the official one (with banana plugs) is passive safety... the official cables are designed so that if someone pulls the cable out from one of the generators, the live voltage will still be at least somewhat shrouded against accidental contact. If someone yanks out one of the plugs on a homemade cable, the pins on the plug will be carrying live voltage. Electrically, though, they're the same as far as the generator is concerned. Behind the plastic panel, those banana plug lugs are wired directly to their corresponding prongs in the receptacle.

  23. Re:Best gift you can give Puerto Rican family memb by Miamicanes · · Score: 2

    Just to add... if you hack your own parallel cable, you can also do something like pair a cheap $109 800W Harbor Freight generator with a more expensive 1800-2200 watt inverter generator. Just connect the homemade Y cable to both generators, start up the Harbor Freight generator first, then start up the inverter generator second... it'll see the voltage from the Harbor Freight generator and sync up to it. Once you've gotten everything that needs lots of surge power started up, you can turn off the Harbor Freight generator and leave the inverter generator running.

  24. Re: Wind power doesn't work by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    The winds are stronger at turbine height due to less friction. You'd never run a turbine in a hurricane because you'd destroy it. That's why there are mechanisms to prevent turbines from operating if the winds are too strong.

    Puerto Rico is actually a lousy place for wind power, anyway, just like most of the tropics. The wind is driven by differences in temperature, which cause differences in pressure. There isn't much of a temperature gradient in the tropics, so the winds are generally weak relative to higher latitudes. Puerto Rico is, however, a pretty good place for solar power. The cloud cover is low enough and the sunlight is pretty direct at the low latitude that solar power works pretty well there.

  25. Re: Wind power doesn't work, or does it? by KGIII · · Score: 1

    ... Do you know how big the blades are for turbines on this scale?

    --
    "So long and thanks for all the fish."
  26. Re:Wind power doesn't work, or does it? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Are we seriously saying people are so stupid they don't take basic off-line power actions?

    Well, I've seen them put up and take down a wind turbine on Alaskan Bush People, so yes. Definitely yes.

  27. Re: Wind power doesn't work, or does it? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Most mobile turbine blades come off. They're not very large, and they fold up for storage. In fact, that's how they ship them.

  28. Re: Wind power doesn't work, or does it? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Most residential wind power has blades about the size of your arm. You can literally put it on the corner of your upstairs deck.

    You're thinking industrial wind turbines.

  29. Re: Wind power doesn't work, or does it? by KGIII · · Score: 1

    "... on this scale." Yes, I'm thinking industrial. The smaller ones are pretty much useless for whole house power. Residential wind turbines don't really make a whole lot of sense for most people, certainly not in the tropics.

    --
    "So long and thanks for all the fish."
  30. Re:Best gift you can give Puerto Rican family memb by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Username checks out.

  31. Re: Wind power doesn't work, or does it? by Anonymous Coward · · Score: 0

    Residential wind turbines don't really make a whole lot of sense for most people, certainly not in the tropics.

    They make a great deal of sense. Emergency power in a compact unit, that isn't even as fragile as solar panels, let alone as bulky?

    You can be sure, a lot of people would LOVE to have even a 100-watt wind turbine now.

    A thousand-watt unit that can keep medicine cool, light some bulbs, even boil small amounts of water? Get me one now.

    It's all about the application, KGIII, all about the application.